Tracing Early Cosmic Chemical Enrichment: A Uniform XMM-Newton Survey of Metallicity in Galaxy Groups and Clusters

Anne E. Blackwell, Joel N. Bregman, Sophia Chan Davis · 2025

Read Tracing Early Cosmic Chemical Enrichment: A Uniform XMM-Newton Survey of Metallicity in Galaxy Groups and Clusters by Anne E. Blackwell, Joel N. Bregman, Sophia Chan Davis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16448.txt.

Introduction

Anne E Blackwell, Joel N Bregman, and Sophia Chan Davis survey metals in the hot gas of 26 galaxy groups and clusters with the XMM-Newton telescope, asking where that enrichment came from. The observed metal levels exceed what today's visible stars could have produced, even though clusters are nearly closed systems that keep their metals.

Measuring radial metallicity profiles and comparing them with the stellar fraction, the authors fit a tight relation with small scatter. Closed-box chemical models using updated supernova yields still underpredict the gas metallicity, and the shortfall grows where the stellar fraction is low. The gap requires an early enrichment population distinct from visible stars. Three systems break the trend with steep gradients and low metallicity, which the authors read as late-forming systems enriched only recently.

Catalog record

CREATORAnne E. Blackwell, Joel N. Bregman, Sophia Chan Davis
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16448

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tracing Early Cosmic Chemical Enrichment: A Uniform XMM-Newton Survey of Metallicity in Galaxy Groups and Clusters Anne E. Blackwell, Joel N. Bregman, Sophia Chan Davis Abstract Observed metal abundances in the intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxy groups and clusters, Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} , exceed what is expected from present-day stellar populations alone. Galaxy clusters are presumed to be near closed-box systems, allowing constraints to be placed on the origins of metals and stellar populations responsible for Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} . We present a uniform XMM-Newton survey of 26 galaxy groups and clusters, measuring radial metallicity profiles and relating Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} with the stellar fraction M ∗ / M g ​ a ​ s M_{*}/M_{gas} . We determine Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} via spectral fitting across multiple annuli finding a best fit of Z I ​ C ​ M = − 0.08 − 0.07 + 0.07 ​ l ​ o ​ g ​ ( M ∗ M g ​ a ​ s ) + 0.30 − 0.06 + 0.06 Z_{ICM}=-0.08^{+0.07}_{-0.07}\,log\left(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{gas}}\right)+0.30^{+0.06}_{-0.06} with intrinsic scatter σ p = 0.09 − 0.01 + 0.02 \sigma_{p}=0.09^{+0.02}_{-0.01} . We use closed-box chemical evolution models to estimate the metallicity yield from observable stellar populations, incorporating updated supernova yields and corrections for metals locked in remnants, Z ∗ = ( 1.14 ± 0.52 ) ​ l ​ o ​ g ​ ( 1 + M ∗ M g ​ a ​ s ) Z_{*}=(1.14\pm 0.52)\,log\left(1+\frac{M_{*}}{M_{gas}}\right) . Our results demonstrate that present-day stellar populations systematically underpredict Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} , with an inferred excess component increasing in systems with low M ∗ / M g ​ a ​ s M_{*}/M_{gas} . This trend supports the need for an early enrichment population (EEP) distinct from visible stars, Z E ​ E ​ P Z_{EEP} . We find this necessity holds when reconsidering the closed-box assumption by removing all galaxy groups, potential leaky systems, deriving Z E ​ E ​ P Z_{EEP} within 1 ​ σ 1\sigma when including and excluding groups. Three systems (NGC1132, NGC5098, and NGC4325) deviate from the survey trend, exhibiting steep negative radial metallicity gradients and unusually low Z I ​ C ​ M Z_{ICM} . We posit these systems to be late-forming whose ICM enrichment reflects only recent stellar populations. Our analysis quantifies the necessity of an EEP and provides trends for testing cluster chemical evolution models. I Introduction Metals serve as vital tracers of stellar evolution, feedback processes, and the integrated history of star formation throughout the Universe. In particular, the intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxy clusters is a critical environment for studying cosmic chemical enrichment ( 3 ; 48 ; 51 ; 26 ; 45 ; 25 ; 24 , e.g.,) . Galaxy clusters possess deep potential wells that retain enriched material, making them ideal laboratories for tracing the production of metals over cosmic time. Chemical enrichment models often adopt a “closed-box” framework, in which gas and metals are neither lost nor gained from the system. The observed ICM metallicity, Z_{ICM} , should be fully accounted for by the metals produced by the current observable stellar populations, Z_{*} , under an assumed initial mass function (IMF) within this model. However, a growing body of evidence suggests that this assumption may not adequately describe the observed metallicity trends, particularly in systems with low stellar mass fractions, M_{*}/M_{gas} ( 13 ; 10 ; 11 ) . Prior works indicate that closed-box models systematically underpredict Z_{ICM} , implying that an additional stellar population may have contributed significantly to an early enrichment, the early enrichment population (EEP) ( 20 ; 41 ; 13 ; 42 ; 63 ; 10 ; 11 ) . Several alternative theories have been proposed to resolve this discrepancy. 75 suggested that the missing stellar population may be found in diffuse intracluster light (ICL), but subsequent observations showed that the ICL does not contain enough mass to account for excess metals. 63 provide a comprehensive review of the broader metal budget problem and outline various scenarios that could explain the enrichment, including hierarchical assembly and selective metal loss. More recently, 9 used cosmological simulations to model the origin of metals in galaxy groups and clusters. They find that the stellar populations within their simulations accurately recreate Z_{ICM} and therefore claim to alleviate the iron budget tension. However, they overpredict the stellar mass and consequently the iron locked in stars, therefore underpredicting the iron share, the ratio of Fe diffused in the ICM to that locked in stars, ( 63 ; 26 ) by approximately an order of magnitude compared to observations. Despite these efforts and tensions, the challenge first identified by 20 remains unresolved, and the EEP hypothesis has not yet been conclusively ruled out. Previous efforts to constrain the EEP include the works of 10 and 11 , who analyzed trends in Z_{ICM} as a function of M_{*}/M_{gas} . In particular, 11 , hereafter 11 , conducted a uniform analysis of archival XMM-Newton data for 26 galaxy groups and clusters with M_{*,500} and M_{gas,500} from 37 . They derived plausible IMFs for the EEP that could account for the observed deviations from closed-box predictions. In this study, we present the full dataset and X-ray spectral fit results for the 26 galaxy groups and clusters comprising the survey. We evaluate the trend of Z_{ICM} vs M_{*}/M_{gas} under a closed-box chemical evolution model and demonstrate the need for an early enrichment component. We derive the expected contribution from present-day stellar populations, Z_{*} , using updated yields from Type Ia and core-collapse supernovae and accounting for metals locked in stellar remnants. This methodology builds upon that introduced by 42 , incorporating more recent estimates of supernova rates, IMF variations, and additional consideration of metals locked in remnants. The residual metallicity, Z_{EEP}=Z_{ICM}-Z_{*} , is the necessary contribution from the theorized EEP required to reproduce observations of Z_{ICM} . The contribution of Z_{EEP} may vary across systems as it may be entangled with other cluster properties such as entropy profiles, cuspiness, or dynamical history. We investigate the dependence of Z_{EEP} on these properties in a companion study (Gherri et al., in prep). For this paper, we assume a \Lambda CDM cosmology with H_{0}=70 km s -1 Mpc -1 , a baryon density parameter of \Omega_{b}=0.046 , dark matter density parameter of \Omega_{DM}=0.24 , and the total baryon density parameter is \Omega_{m}=0.29 ( 58 ) . We also adopt a diet-Salpeter IMF as developed by 6 and adopted in 10 and 11 . This IMF has a slope of \alpha=0.35 in the mass range 0.5-1M_{\odot} , and a slope of \alpha=1.35 in the mass range 1-150M_{\odot} for an IMF defined as \phi(m)=m^{-(1+\alpha)} (per unit log mass). This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we describe the survey selection, data reduction, and spectral analysis methodology. Section III presents the fit to the observed Z_{ICM} vs M_{*}/M_{gas} relation and the derivation of Z_{*} and Z_{EEP} . In Section IV , we discuss the implications of our findings, including assumptions, systematics, and the role of outlier systems. We conclude in Section V . II Survey Data Reduction and Analysis

Read the complete text