Resolving Speed and Encoding Bottlenecks in Fast Heteromeric Self-Assembly
Félix Benoist, Pablo Sartori · 2025
Read Resolving Speed and Encoding Bottlenecks in Fast Heteromeric Self-Assembly by Félix Benoist, Pablo Sartori (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16362.txt.
Introduction
Félix Benoist and Pablo Sartori model how protein complexes assemble accurately and quickly inside the cell, where many shared parts must find the right partners despite thermal noise. Energy-based toy models miss the role of kinetics, so the authors extend a heteropolymer growth model to the retrieval of two-dimensional structures.
In the extended model, assembly runs into strong speed and encoding bottlenecks: structures either form slowly or cannot be specified reliably. Raising the connectivity of just a small fraction of components suppresses both bottlenecks at once. Controlling a few critical binding events kinetically thus explains how large complexes assemble on time, and points to a unifying role for the assembly factors that guide real protein construction.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Félix Benoist, Pablo Sartori |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16362
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Resolving Speed and Encoding Bottlenecks in Fast Heteromeric Self-Assembly Félix Benoist, Pablo Sartori Abstract The cytoplasm is a heterogeneous mixture containing many types of proteins that self-assemble into a wide variety of complexes. The accuracy and speed of cytoplasmic self-assembly is astonishing because it involves the correct identification of components shared among different structures, despite pervasive thermal fluctuations. Typical toy models of self-assembly are based on the specificity of binding energies among components and neglect kinetic effects. However, kinetics plays a key role in biological self-assembly, often catalyzed by a plethora of assembly factors. Building on this observation, we extend a previous heteropolymer growth model to describe the retrieval of two-dimensional structures. We find that the self-assembly of structures in this model is subject to strong speed and encoding bottlenecks. Moreover, we show that these bottlenecks can be suppressed by increasing the connectivity of a small fraction of components. This mechanism of kinetically controlling a small number of critical binding events provides a simple explanation for the timely assembly of large protein, and suggests a unifying principle for the role of assembly factors. I Introduction Many proteins assemble into heteromeric complexes, i.e. complexes composed of multiple protein species, to carry out essential cellular functions. During assembly, protein complexes must accurately identify their specific components from a crowded mixture of thousands of species. Assembly must not only be precise but also rapid, so that cellular functions proceed in a timely manner. Two remarkable examples are the spliceosomal complexes and the ribosomal subunits, each composed of dozens of proteins Khatter et al. 2015 ; Wahl et al. 2009 , with ribosomal subunits assembling in under 2 minutes Chen et al. 2012 . Advances in high-throughput cryoEM have steadily expanded our knowledge of the molecular and structural details of such complexes. Yet, the generic physical principles that enable high assembly speed and low error rates to coexist in heterogeneous cellular environments remain elusive. What are the key biological ingredients of cellular self-assembly? We identify two such ingredients: assembly factors and assembly geometry, which we describe below. Assembly factors are proteins that transiently assist the growth of complexes, akin to chaperones in protein folding Dörner et al. 2023 ; Wahl et al. 2009 ; Vercellino and Sazanov 2022 ; schematic in Fig. 1 A. Assembly factors bind at specific locations and times during the growth of protein complexes; examples in Figs. 1 B and C. Moreover, their number is often comparable to that of the proteins in the complex itself; see Fig. 1 D. Their molecular functions are diverse: some block premature binding or catalyze specific events Davis and Williamson 2017 ; Rousseau and Bertolotti 2018 ; Altegoer and Bange 2015 ; Dörner et al. 2023 , and yet others act as proofreading enzymes Dörner et al. 2023 ; Seffouh et al. 2024 ; Wahl et al. 2009 . Overarching this diversity is the observation that depletion of assembly factors slows down self-assembly and leads to the accumulation of incomplete intermediates Seffouh et al. 2024 ; Davis and Williamson 2017 ; Mulder et al. 2010 ; Sheng et al. 2023 . Another common feature is that assembly factors are dissipative, hydrolyzing ATP or GTP to perform their function Davis and Williamson 2017 ; Dörner et al. 2023 ; Altegoer and Bange 2015 ; Wild and Cramer 2012 . Thus, assembly factors are a key ingredient in protein complex assembly, ensuring both speed and accuracy by strongly driving specific binding events. FIG. 1: Formation of large heteromeric complexes rely on many assembly factors. A. Schematic representation of the self-assembly of a protein complex. The self-assembly of protein subunits is driven by assembly factors, that have the ultimate role of favoring speed and accuracy of complex formation. The complete protein assembly contains no assembly factor. B. Structural snapshots of assembly intermediates of the yeast ribosome large subunit. As we can see, assembly factors transiently bound to the RNA-protein assembly. Protein data bank IDs: 6EM3, 6LSR Berman et al. 2000 . C. Intermediates of the human proteasome (8QZ9) and of the bacterial photosystem II (7NPQ). D. In purely asymmetric complexes, numbers of assembly factors roughly increase with numbers of protein subunits. By contrast, complexes with a local rotational symmetry require fewer assembly factors. Gray lines: slope 2 and \frac{1}{2} . Data detailed in SI Sec. S1 and Refs. Wahl et al. 2009 ; Dörner et al. 2023 ; Woolford and Baserga 2013 ; Lavdovskaia et al. 2024 ; Vercellino and Sazanov 2022 ; Heinz et al. 2016 ; Yang et al. 2015 ; Wild and Cramer 2012 ; Rühle and Leister 2015 ; Altegoer and Bange 2015 ; Armitage and Berry 2020 ; Rousseau and Bertolotti 2018 therein. E. The connectivity of components in an assembly is highly variable. Highly-connected components correspond to RNAs. Detailed plot in Fig. S1 . F. Our kinetic encoding model consists in the acceleration of correct binding events via kinetic cooperativity and catalyzing assembly factors. A second fundamental ingredient is the diversity of protein shapes and connectivities within heteromeric complexes. Even at a coarse grained level, some proteins (or RNA components) are large and elongated, while others are small and globular Erickson 2009 ; Reuveni et al. 2017 . Consequently, their connectivity varies widely: Some proteins bind to many other proteins in the final complex, while others bind to few; see Fig. 1 E for examples across complexes. This structural diversity has important kinetic consequences. In particular, the kinetic cooperativity of neighboring proteins is known to largely accelerate self-assembly Bunner et al. 2010 ; Williamson 2008 . We thus expect that highly connected proteins can be kinetically discriminated and thus quickly assemble without errors. Overall, unlike large homomeric complexes such as actin filaments Chhabra and Higgs 2007 ; von der Ecken et al. 2015 , microtubules Fellous et al. 1977 or viral capsids Mateu 2013 which are highly symmetric and require few assembly factors, large heteromeric complexes feature far more intricate geometries and involve many catalyzing assembly factors. In this paper, we develop a toy model of heteromeric self-assembly to investigate the role of the two ingredients above. Our goal is not to undertake detailed molecular dynamics of heteromeric self-assembly Kurisaki and Tanaka 2022 ; but rather to design simplified models that illuminate fundamental principles of nonequilibrium self-assembly and geometry, and their implications in biological and synthetic systems Gartner and Frey 2024 ; Lenz and Witten 2017 ; Manoharan 2015 ; Ravasio et al. 2024 . Building on previous work in self-assembly Gartner and Frey 2024 ; Murugan et al. 2015 ; Sartori and Leibler 2020 ; Benoist and Sartori 2025 and nonequilibrium information processing Dill et al. 1993 ; Bennett 1979 ; Sartori and Pigolotti 2013 ; Tsai and Johnson 2006 ; Benoist et al. 2025 , we explore how kinetic discrimination and variable connectivity enable fast and accurate assembly in the presence of confounding interactions. II Model setup Within our framework, a set of square tiles with varying connectivity can reversibly bind at specific locations on the boundary of a growing structure, aided by catalyzing assembly factors; see Fig. 1 F. We abstract the action of assembly factors and the kinetic cooperativity discussed in the introduction by accelerating binding events