Constructing bounded orbits of special types on homogeneous spaces

Manfred Einsiedler, Dmitry Kleinbock, Anurag Rao · 2025

Read Constructing bounded orbits of special types on homogeneous spaces by Manfred Einsiedler, Dmitry Kleinbock, Anurag Rao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16095.txt.

Introduction

Manfred Einsiedler, Dmitry Kleinbock, and Anurag Rao study points with bounded orbits on homogeneous spaces, quotients of a real Lie group by a lattice. A one-parameter subgroup acts on the space in a mixing way, and points whose forward orbit stays in a compact set form a dense set of full Hausdorff dimension. The authors ask how those special points relate to each other through orbit closures.

They prove the set is indecomposable: for any bounded-orbit point, uncountably many others have orbit closures containing it, densely across the whole set. When a neutral subgroup has dimension one, they also construct many points whose orbit closure is compact and has dimension arbitrarily close to that of the full space.

Catalog record

CREATORManfred Einsiedler, Dmitry Kleinbock, Anurag Rao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16095

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constructing bounded orbits of special types on homogeneous spaces Thanks: The second-named author was supported by NSF grant DMS-2155111. Manfred Einsiedler, Dmitry Kleinbock, Anurag Rao Abstract . Let X = G / Γ X=G/\Gamma be a quotient of a real Lie group by a non-uniform lattice. Consider a one-parameter subgroup F F of G G that is Ad \operatorname{Ad} -diagonalizable over ℂ {\mathbb{C}} and whose action on ( X , m X ) (X,m_{X}) is mixing. In this dynamical system we study the set of points x ∈ X x\in X with a precompact orbit, written as E ⁡ ( F , ∞ ) E(F,\infty) , which is known to be a dense subset of X X of full Hausdorff dimension. We prove that E ⁡ ( F , ∞ ) E(F,\infty) is indecomposable in the following sense: given any y ∈ E ⁡ ( F , ∞ ) y\in E(F,\infty) , the set of x ∈ E ⁡ ( F , ∞ ) x\in E(F,\infty) for which y ∈ F + ​ x ¯ y\in\overline{F_{+}x} , where F + F_{+} denotes the positive ray in F F , is uncountable and dense in E ⁡ ( F , ∞ ) E(F,\infty) . When the dimension of the neutral subgroup of G G with respect to F F is 1 1 we demonstrate, for any ε > 0 \varepsilon>0 , the existence of many points x ∈ X x\in X whose orbit closure F + ​ x ¯ ⊂ X \overline{F_{+}x}\subset X is compact and has Hausdorff dimension at least dim X − ε \dim X-\varepsilon . 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 37A17; 37A25, 37D40, 11J70 1. Introduction Let X be a metric space, and let F be either of the (semi) groups {\mathbb{R}} or {\mathbb{Z}} or {\mathbb{R}}_{\geq 0} or {\mathbb{Z}}_{\geq 0} represented as a family of self-maps of X . We will write F=\{g_{t}\} . For g\in F we will denote its action on X by (g,x)\mapsto gx . Now fix a subset Y\subset X and define the set of points of X approaching Y by F as A(F,Y):=\big\{x\in X:\exists\text{ an unbounded sequence }(g_{t_{k}})_{k\in{\mathbb{N}}}\subset F\text{ with }{\lim_{k\to\infty}g_{t_{k}}x\in Y}\big\}. Its complement, the set of points of X escaping Y by F will be denoted by E(F,{Y}) , namely E(F,{Y}):=\bigcap_{y\in Y}\big\{x\in X:y\notin\overline{(F\smallsetminus F_{0})x}\text{ for some bounded }F_{0}\subset F\big\}. If X is not bounded, we make the convention that x\in A(F,\infty) when the orbit Fx is unbounded. Take y\in Y and consider A(F,y):=A(F,\{y\}) and E(F,y):=E(F,\{y\}) . A natural question one could ask is how large the sets A(F,y) and E(F,y) can be. If the action admits an ergodic invariant probability measure, or has some hyperbolic behavior, some instances of this question can be answered. Namely, under the assumption of existence of an ergodic measure \mu of full support the set A(F,y) has full measure for any y\in X\cup\{\infty\} . Additionally, for many hyperbolic systems one can prove that the \mu -null sets E(F,y) are thick , that is, their intersection with any nonempty open set has full Hausdorff dimension. For results of this kind see e.g. [ D2 ] for toral endomorphisms, [ U , Do ] for Anosov flows, and [ D1 , KMa , Kl1 , AGK ] for partially hyperbolic flows on homogeneous space. Furthermore, in many cases these sets can be proved to be winning in the sense of Schmidt games (see e.g. [ AGK , BFK , D1 , D2 , Ts1 , Ts2 , Wu1 , Wu2 ] ). Consequently in these cases it follows that both A(F,y) and E(F,y) are thick. Moreover, both full-measure and winning conditions are stable with respect to countable intersections; thus for any choice of countably many semigroups F_{i} and points y_{i}\in X\cup\{\infty\} for which the above conclusions can be established, it holds that both \bigcap_{i}A(F_{i},y_{i}) and \bigcap_{i}E(F_{i},y_{i}) are thick. This paper addresses the following question: what if one considers a mixed case, that is, investigate the intersection (1.1) {A(F,y)\cap E(F,z),} where y,z\in X\cup\{\infty\} ? Problems of this type are amenable neither to the full-measure argument, nor to the technique based on Schmidt games. Also it is clear that some conditions on y,z should be imposed; for example if y=z it is clear that the intersection ( 1.1 ) is empty. In what follows we restrict our attention to F\cong{\mathbb{R}} , also denoting F_{+}:=\{g_{t}:t\geq 0\} . Assume that the F -action on X is continuous. Then let us record a natural obstruction to the set (1.2) {A(F_{+},y)\cap E(F_{+},z)} being non-empty: Lemma 1.1 . If y\in X and z\in X\cup\{\infty\} are such that y\in A(F,z) (that is, z can be approached by the trajectory of y either in the positive or in the negative time direction), then A(F_{+},y)\subset A(F_{+},z). Proof. Let x\in A(F_{+},y) , and let (s_{\ell})_{\ell\in{\mathbb{N}}} be an unbounded sequence in {\mathbb{R}}_{\geq 0} with \lim_{\ell\to\infty}g_{s_{\ell}}x=y. Let W\subset X be an open neighborhood of z . In the case, when z=\infty , we take W to be an open set with bounded complement. By the hypothesis, there exists a time t\in{\mathbb{R}} for which g_{t}y\in W . By the continuity of the action we have \lim_{\ell\to\infty}g_{s_{\ell}}g_{t}x=g_{t}y\in W. Note that the sequence (s_{\ell}+t)_{\ell\in{\mathbb{N}}} is unbounded and eventually positive. Since W was arbitrary, we conclude that x\in A(F_{+},z) . ∎ In view of the above lemma it makes sense to look for conditions guaranteeing that the set ( 1.2 ) is reasonably large under the assumption that y\in E(F,z) . In the present paper we will do it in the following set-up: we let X=G/\Gamma , where G is a real Lie group and \Gamma\subset G is a lattice, and consider the {\mathbb{R}} -action on X via the left multiplication by a one-parameter subgroup of G : (1.3) \big\{g_{t}:=\exp(ta_{0})\in G:t\in{\mathbb{R}}\big\}, where {a_{0}} is an element of {\mathfrak{g}}:=\operatorname{Lie}(G) , the Lie algebra of G . We shall fix once and for all an inner product on {\mathfrak{g}} to induce a right-invariant Riemannian metric \operatorname{dist}_{G} on G . Note that the invariance of the metric implies that it is geodesically complete, and so the Hopf–Rinow theorem implies that it is proper (closed and bounded sets are compact). Then one obtains a metric on X=G/\Gamma by setting \operatorname{dist}_{X}(g_{1}\Gamma,g_{2}\Gamma):=\inf\big\{\operatorname{dist}_{G}(g_{1}\gamma,g_{2}):\gamma\in\Gamma\big\}. This is the set-up in which we will attempt to study sets of the form ( 1.2 ). We will denote by m_{X} the G -invariant Haar probability measure on X , and by m_{G} the Haar measure on G scaled so that the measure of any fundamental domain for \Gamma is equal to 1 . Further, in this paper we will assume that X is noncompact and z=\infty ; that is, we will seek to construct bounded F^{+} -trajectories with prescribed limit points. Recently the second- and third-named authors proved the following result. Take G=\operatorname{SL}_{2}({\mathbb{R}}) , \Gamma=\operatorname{SL}_{2}({\mathbb{Z}}) and X=G/\Gamma . For t,\alpha\in{\mathbb{R}} consider g_{t}:=\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}e^{t}&0\\ 0&e^{-t}\end{array}}\right]\in G,\ F=\{g_{t}:t\in{\mathbb{R}}\}, and {x_{\alpha}:=\left[{\begin{array}[]{cc}1&\alpha\\ 0&1\end{array}}\right]\Gamma\in X.}{} Theorem 1.2 . [ KR2 , Theorem 1.3] Let X and F be as above, and let y\in E(F,\infty) ; then (1.4) \dim\big(\{\alpha\in{\mathbb{R}}:x_{\alpha}\in A(F_{+},y)\cap E(F_{+},\infty)\}\big)=1. Here and hereafter "dim" stands for Hausdorff dimension. In fact, even though it was not mentioned in [ KR2 ] , the proof actually demonstrates the thickness of the set in the left-hand side

Read the complete text