Quantum Reorientational Excitations in the Raman Spectrum of Hydrogen

Philip Dalladay-Simpson, Eric Edmund, Huixin Hu, Mario Santoro, Federico Aiace Gorelli · 2025

Read Quantum Reorientational Excitations in the Raman Spectrum of Hydrogen by Philip Dalladay-Simpson, Eric Edmund, Huixin Hu, Mario Santoro, Federico Aiace Gorelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16010.txt.

Introduction

Philip Dalladay-Simpson and four co-authors attribute low rate Raman peaks in hydrogen to quantum reorientational excitations. Spectra were measured across wide pressure and heat level ranges up to very high pressure. Peaks below a standard wavenumber bound shift from the Rayleigh line as anisotropic links lift spinning degeneracy. Their actions tracks known spinning branches in pressure, heat level, and isotope mixture dependence.

Above a moderate heat level, a broad continuum emerges from populated higher spinning states and disorder. Entering the phase where spin is inhibited quenches that continuum into sharp phonons. At very low heat level, fine structure reveals isolated and paired excitations from impurity molecules. Those pair traits sensitively probe the host lattice. The assignment clarifies hydrogen spectra under extreme settings.

Catalog record

CREATORPhilip Dalladay-Simpson, Eric Edmund, Huixin Hu, Mario Santoro, Federico Aiace Gorelli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16010

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Reorientational Excitations in the Raman Spectrum of Hydrogen Philip Dalladay-Simpson, Eric Edmund, Huixin Hu, Mario Santoro, Federico Aiace Gorelli Abstract Low-frequency Raman peaks, below 250 cm -1 , are observed in hydrogen between 2–174 GPa and 13–300 K. The origin of these features is attributed to reorientational transitions ( Δ ​ J = 0 \Delta J=0 ; Q 0 Q_{0} -branch), which shift from the Rayleigh line as anisotropic intermolecular interactions lift the m J m_{J} degeneracy. This family of excitations closely follows the behavior of the S 0 S_{0} -branches, sharing their dependence on pressure, temperature, and ortho-H 2 concentration. Above 65 K, spectra corrected by the Bose-Einstein population factor reveal a broad continuum arising from populated higher J J -states and increased ortho–para disorder. Upon entering phase III, where molecular rotation is inhibited, this continuum is quenched, giving way to well-established optical phonons. Below 25 K, equilibrated samples demonstrate a fine structure from isolated and pair excitations from impurity ortho-H 2 molecules in a parahydrogen lattice, the latter a sensitive probe to anisotropic intermolecular interactions relevant to the quantum modeling of solid H 2 . Hydrogen is a prototypical quantum solid, evidenced by its inflated volume due to large zero-point motion, the preservation of its rotational dynamics to 0 K and the existence of nuclear spin isomers [ 36 , 37 , 26 ] . The latter is a consequence of the total nuclear spin state of the molecule, I , and the rotational quantum number, J , being coupled and results in two distinct molecular species of hydrogen: para-H 2 ( I=0 ; singlet-state: \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{\uparrow\downarrow}-\ket{\downarrow\uparrow}) only occupying even- J rotational levels and ortho-H 2 ( I=1 ; triplet-state: \ket{\uparrow\uparrow} , \ket{\downarrow\downarrow} and \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{\uparrow\downarrow}+\ket{\downarrow\uparrow}) only occupying odd- J levels [ 7 ] . Raman spectroscopy has been foundational in probing this quantum nature since its inception almost a century ago, providing early validation of quantum mechanics [ 19 , 7 ] through the characterization of the relative intensities of the rotational S_{1}(J) -branch, a direct signature of spin isomers and their thermal equilibrium concentration (1:3, para:ortho) at room temperature [ 28 ] . Raman spectroscopy remains pivotal, having mapped out most of hydrogen’s condensed phases prior to its long-sought density-driven metallization [ 39 ] . This includes the discovery of the broken-symmetry phase (Phase II) [ 35 ] , the orientationally ordered phase (Phase III) [ 20 ] , and the layered mixed-molecular phases (Phases IV/V) [ 22 , 4 , 11 ] , providing key constraints for the most advanced quantum models of hydrogen [ 30 , 31 , 9 ] . Up to 150 GPa, hydrogen’s phase diagram is dominated by phase I, which is characterized by a hexagonal close-packed (hcp) lattice of coupled quantum rotors [ 36 , 37 , 26 ] . In phase I, increased intermolecular interactions reduce J as an effective quantum number [ 29 , 32 ] . However, where J remains a good quantum number, below \sim 70 GPa [ 29 ] , the Raman spectrum of phase I is remarkably simple and characterized by vibrational ( \nu_{1\rightarrow 0} ), rotational ( S_{0}(J) ; \Delta J=2 ), and E_{2g} phonon modes. Notably, with the lowest rotational excitation S_{0}(0) at 350 cm -1 and the lowest E_{2g} phonon frequency recorded being 37 cm -1 [ 34 ] , one might expect a spectral gap below which no Raman excitations are observable. Anisotropic interactions in hydrogen lift the 2J+1 degeneracy of the orientational sub-levels, m_{J} , giving rise to low-energy Raman-active reorientational excitations where the J number is preserved, ie. a Q -branch. These were first identified over 50 years ago by pioneering Raman spectroscopy measurements on solid hydrogen at ambient pressure and low temperatures [ 34 ] . Subsequent studies, under similar conditions, detected them in a dilute-ortho-H 2 solid via microwave absorption [ 16 ] and, later, as combination bands with infrared absorption [ 8 ] . The excitations are characteristically very low in Raman frequency, less than 6 cm -1 [ 15 ] , making them particularly challenging to observe given their proximity to the Rayleigh line. However, high pressure is expected to amplify the underlying anisotropic interactions, thereby increasing their associated frequencies and intensities into more readily experimentally accessible regimes. Recent simulations have suggested that this reorientational branch exhibits a fine structure at room temperature with components reaching frequencies \sim 7-70 cm -1 at 40 GPa [ 3 ] . However, because of their symmetry, they are not observable in a perfectly back-scattering geometry with the c-axis parallel to the collection direction [ 3 , 32 ] . Therefore, due to the crystallographic preferred orientation of hydrogen in a Diamond Anvil Cell (DAC) [ 25 , 1 ] this has remained an experimental blind spot for high-pressure studies. As a consequence, their only tentative identification in D 2 required a 90 ∘ scattering geometry [ 34 ] , a technical limitation for high-pressure experiments. In this study low-frequency Raman peaks, below 250 cm -1 , have been observed between 2-174 GPa and 13-300 K. We interpret the origin of these features as reorientational transitions, a Q_{0} -branch, between orientational sub-levels ( m_{J} ) within the same rotational state J of the ground vibrational manifold. The appearance of these transitions is due to the lifting of m_{J} degeneracy, caused by anisotropic nearest neighbor ( nn ) interactions in the crystalline lattice, without which they would occur at zero-frequency. The Bose-Einstein population (BEP) corrected spectral line shape is found to be highly dependent on temperature and ortho-H 2 concentration. At higher temperatures, above 65 K, a low-frequency broad Boltzmann-like distribution is observed, consistent with a thermal population of higher J -states and increased ortho-para nn configurational disorder. These excitation’s behavior is similar to that of the rotational S_{0} -branches, further supporting the interpretation that both arise from quantum orientational motion. Upon entering phase III, where molecular rotation is arrested, this broad distribution quenches into the well-resolved, known phonons of that phase [ 12 , 13 ] . In phase I at low temperatures, below 25 K, and dilute ortho-concentrations, less than 5 %, a resolved fine structure emerges, indicative of impurity pair and isolated ortho-H 2 excitations [ 37 , 16 , 36 ] . This pressure-dependent fine structure serves as a sensitive probe of the anisotropic intermolecular interactions essential for constraining models of solid hydrogen. Figs. 1(a, c), 2 and End Matter Fig. 5(a, b) present raw measurements on samples of hydrogen in phase I at various pressures and down to 17 K, these spectra reveal the expected rotational S_{0} -branches of a quantum rotor and the weaker optical E_{2g} phonon of the hcp lattice. Across all spectra above 2.4 GPa, we observe a prominent and previously unaccounted-for feature characterized by a strong increase in intensity toward zero frequency in both the Stokes and anti-Stokes regions. As a result, this unusual lineshape appears almost like a peak centered at zero frequency, which is non-physical for a Raman excitation. As a consequence, this feature could easily be mistaken for an experimental artifact, such as poor filtration of the Raman excitation source and/or sample/diamond photoluminescence and perhaps explains why it

Read the complete text