Mean Mass Density near the Sun from the Divergence Theorem and Pulsar Accelerations

Thomas Donlon II, Lawrence M. Widrow, Sukanya Chakrabarti · 2025

Read Mean Mass Density near the Sun from the Divergence Theorem and Pulsar Accelerations by Thomas Donlon II, Lawrence M. Widrow, Sukanya Chakrabarti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15865.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Donlon, Lawrence M. Widrow, and Sukanya Chakrabarti introduce a new way to estimate how much mass sits within a sphere centered on the Sun. Their data are the line-of-sight accelerations of millisecond pulsars, spinning neutron stars whose signals reveal tiny changes in their motion. Applying the divergence theorem, a calculus identity linking a volume total to surface flow, turns those accelerations into a mean mass density without assuming a model shape.

Results agree with earlier analyses, and paired with a baryon model they give dark matter density as a function of distance rather than one number. Current data cannot yet isolate the local dark matter signal cleanly, but growing pulsar data should soon allow it. Density asymmetries across the galactic midplane are also estimated.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas Donlon II, Lawrence M. Widrow, Sukanya Chakrabarti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15865

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mean Mass Density near the Sun from the Divergence Theorem and Pulsar Accelerations Thomas Donlon II, Lawrence M. Widrow, Sukanya Chakrabarti Abstract We introduce a new, non-parametric method for estimating the mass enclosed within a sphere of arbitrary radius centered on the Sun. The method is based on the divergence theorem as applied to measurements of the line-of-sight accelerations of millisecond pulsars. We describe a procedure for inferring the mean mass density within a sphere of a given radius centered on the Sun and find results that are consistent with previous analyses. When combined with a model for the distribution of baryons, this provides the mean mass density of dark matter as a function of distance from the Sun, rather than a single value as is typically reported by kinematic studies. However, with the present pulsar data, the method cannot unambiguously measure a signal from the local distribution of dark matter at this time; such a measurement is expected to soon become possible as the amount of pulsar acceleration data grows and its precision improves. We derive an extension of the well-known shell theorem to a spherical-harmonics expansion of the density and potential, and use the result to obtain estimates for density asymmetries with respect to the Galactic midplane from the observed acceleration data. The predicted asymmetries do not follow the observed distribution of MW disk stars or gas; this can potentially be explained by a non-uniform distribution of dark matter in the Solar neighborhood. I Introduction The challenge in determining the distribution of mass in the Milky Way (MW) is that we are generally unable to directly measure the accelerations of gravitational tracers such as stars and gas. Were we able to do so, we could construct a smooth map of the acceleration field and then infer the mass density via Poisson’s equation. Instead, we must supplement position and velocity measurements with assumptions about the dynamical state of the Galaxy ( 6 ) . For example, with Jeans modeling we make the assumption that the Galactic potential is time-independent and that the bulge and stellar disk, which provide both significant contributions to the mass of the Galaxy and suitable populations of tracers, are in dynamical equilibrium. Each of these stellar components can be described by a phase space distribution function (DF) f , which obeys the collisionless Boltzmann equation ( 5 , CBE, see) . For equilibrium systems, f depends on the phase space coordinates only through the integrals of motion (Jeans’ theorem). This condition is enough to ensure that we can uniquely determine the potential from measurements of positions and velocities ( 5 ; 1 ) . Alternatively, we can use velocity moments of the time-independent CBE, namely the continuity and Jeans equations, to determine the potential. Jeans methods have been used for nearly a century to determine the vertical force and the surface density \Sigma as functions of the position z relative to the Galactic midplane ( 37 ; 28 ; 7 ; 24 ; 48 ; 33 ; 8 ) . In general, the assumption that the Galaxy is in equilibrium is paired with the assumption that it is axisymmetric and symmetric about the midplane. However, the observed density, bulk velocity, and velocity dispersion profiles for disk stars show asymmetries with respect to the Galactic midplane ( 43 ; 46 ; 11 ; 44 ; 45 ; 4 ) . The interpretation is that the stellar disk near the Sun is in a state of disequilibrium. Another manifestation of disequilibrium is the Gaia snail, a spiral-like feature in the number density of stars across the z-v_{z} plane, which is strongly suggestive of incomplete phase mixing of a perturbation to the disk ( 2 ) . These departures from the assumption of equilibrium can lead to systematic errors in Jeans modeling ( 3 ; 27 ; 41 ) . Indeed, disequilibrium is often revealed through Jeans modeling; for example, the residuals of Jeans method models for the DF and potential provide clearly show the Gaia snail and similar features as functions of angle-action variables ( 29 ; 30 ) . Although there are ways of accounting for some disequilibrium features in Jeans modeling ( 25 , for example, see Section 5.3.2 of) , this often consists of adding additional terms of a series expansion, which is ultimately still an approximation. In principle, data from surveys such as Gaia ( 23 ) and APOGEE ( 32 ) allow for redundancy checks in Jeans modeling for the surface density and vertical force. Different populations of stars (as defined, for example, by abundance ratios) typically have different vertical structures, which are related to their distribution at birth and subsequent dynamical processes such as vertical heating ( 39 ; 26 ) . However, so long as the Galaxy is in equilibrium, when taken as tracers of the potential, these distinct populations should give the same results for the vertical force. Recently, 18 found that the vertical force inferred from Jeans modeling of two distinct samples, namely thin and thick disk stars, yielded very different results. They considered several explanations for the discrepancy, including the possibility that disequilibrium manifests itself differently in the thin and thick disks. This explanation is entirely plausible since dynamically distinct populations will respond differently to gravitational perturbations. These issues make it difficult to determine the correct value for the vertical force from tracer stars alone. Recently 9 and 31 have developed a promising algorithm for deriving the potential from astrometric data based on normalizing flows, an unsupervised machine learning method that is particularly well-suited to dynamical systems. The basic idea is to adjust the potential so as to minimize \partial\ln{f}/\partial t . Otherwise, there are no a priori assumptions about symmetries of the system. In other words, the model does not rigorously impose time-independence – rather, it finds the potential that minimizes time-dependence of f . When 31 applied the method to Gaia DR3 data, they found departures in the acceleration field from axisymmetry and symmetry about the midplane, which they attributed to disequilibrium processes. Recent advances in pulsar observations have introduced a promising alternative to Jeans modeling, which makes use of direct measurements of the Galactic acceleration field. There are now direct acceleration measurements for over 50 pulsars, opening up the possibility for determining the mass density from Poisson’s equation without any assumptions about the state of the Galaxy ( 12 ; 35 ; 21 ; 22 ) . One must, however, confront two significant hurdles. First, with only \sim 50 acceleration measurements within 3 kpc, the spatial resolution of the acceleration field is only 1-2\,{\rm kpc} , even if we set aside the considerable measurement uncertainties in the distance to the pulsars and the acceleration itself. Second, we only have access to a_{\rm los} , the component of the acceleration relative to the Sun along the line of sight. In 12 ; 21 ; 22 these issues were handled but using a parametric model for the Galactic potential. The best-fit model was found by comparing model predictions for a_{\mathrm{los}} with measurements toward each of the sources in the data set. Although we only use pulsar data in this study, our work here can also be

Read the complete text