Cloud droplet size distribution and optical properties only weakly linked to aerosol size
Kadja Flore Gali, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, Jesse C. Anderson, Payton Beeler, Aaron Wang, David Richter, Raymond A Shaw, Fan Yang, Will Cantrell, Laura Fierce · 2025
Read Cloud droplet size distribution and optical properties only weakly linked to aerosol size by Kadja Flore Gali, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, Jesse C. Anderson, Payton Beeler, Aaron Wang, David Richter, Raymond A Shaw, Fan Yang, Will Cantrell, Laura Fierce (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15832.txt.
Introduction
Kadja Flore Gali, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, and eight co-authors show that cloud droplet sizes often barely respond to the size of aerosol particles that seed them. Aerosols govern how droplets activate, and droplet size sets cloud brightness, a strong but poorly constrained influence on Earth energy balance. That chain suggests cloud properties should depend sensitively on aerosol size distributions.
Combining cloud chamber experiments with high-resolution simulations, the team finds microphysical and optical cloud properties are often insensitive to aerosol size. Clear effects appear only under weak convective forcing and high aerosol concentrations. In most conditions, cloud reflectivity can be predicted from aerosol number alone, simplifying how aerosol changes are represented in climate reasoning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kadja Flore Gali, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, Jesse C. Anderson, Payton Beeler, Aaron Wang, David Richter, Raymond A Shaw, Fan Yang, Will Cantrell, Laura Fierce |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15832
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cloud droplet size distribution and optical properties only weakly linked to aerosol size Kadja Flore Gali, Hamed Fahandezh Sadi, Jesse C. Anderson, Payton Beeler, Aaron Wang, David Richter, Raymond A Shaw, Fan Yang, Will Cantrell, Laura Fierce Abstract Changes in aerosol concentrations can modify cloud brightness, producing a strong but poorly constrained influence on Earth’s energy balance. Because cloud reflectivity depends on the size distribution of cloud droplets, and aerosol size strongly governs activation into droplets, one might expect cloud properties to be sensitive to aerosol size distributions. Here we show, through a combination of cloud chamber experiments and high-resolution simulations, that cloud microphysical and optical properties are often insensitive to aerosol size. Detectable impacts on cloud optical properties occur only under weak convective forcing and high aerosol concentrations. These results indicate that, in most conditions, cloud reflectivity can be predicted from aerosol number alone without detailed knowledge of aerosol size distributions, providing new constraints on how aerosol perturbations affect climate. Introduction Cloud reflectivity depends on the number and size of droplets within a cloud. Human emissions have increased atmospheric aerosol concentrations, brightening many clouds and producing a major, but uncertain, cooling effect on climate [ 9 , 22 , 26 , 20 ] . While the role of aerosol number in altering cloud properties has been extensively studied [ 32 , 33 , 34 , 1 , 25 , 29 , 21 ] , the contribution of aerosol size distributions remains less clear. Because aerosol size strongly governs whether particles activate as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) [ 11 ] , one might expect cloud droplet size distributions—and hence cloud optical depth—to be highly sensitive to aerosol size. Yet most prior work has explored this question only in simplified frameworks, such as CCN spectra as a function of supersaturation or single-parcel updraft simulations [ 19 , 18 , 29 , 10 ] . At the other extreme, global Earth System Models represent aerosols and clouds at such coarse resolution that potential size effects cannot be mechanistically captured [ 2 , 30 , 13 ] . Direct field observations are likewise limited, since aerosol and cloud properties vary rapidly in space and time, making it nearly impossible to disentangle the role of aerosol size from co-varying factors such as updraft velocity, humidity, and turbulence. Here we directly probe how aerosol size influences cloud properties using laboratory convective clouds in the Pi Chamber — a laboratory cloud chamber at Michigan Tech, designed to study aerosol-cloud interactions in turbulent environments through Rayleigh-Bénard convection —, which captures turbulent conditions more representative of the atmosphere than do parcel models or static CCN measurements [ 7 , 8 , 31 , 27 , 3 ] . Contrary to our expectations, we find that cloud droplet size distributions and optical proprieties respond only weakly to aerosol size, with detectable effects appearing only under polluted conditions and weak convective forcing. These results demonstrate that, once particles are large enough to activate, cloud reflectivity is controlled primarily by aerosol number rather than size—a mechanistic constraint that helps narrow the uncertainty in aerosol–cloud interactions and their role in Earth’s energy balance. Droplet sizes in laboratory-generated clouds only weakly linked to aerosol sizes To quantify how aerosol size influences the cloud droplet size distribution, we conducted a coordinated set of Pi Chamber experiments [ 8 ] and large-eddy simulations (LES) using the System for Atmospheric Modeling (SAM), adapted to the chamber’s geometry and operating conditions [ 31 , 40 , 39 , 37 , 36 , 35 , 41 ] . We performed twelve experiments in which dry NaCl particles (50, 100, and 250 nm) were injected under low and high aerosol loadings (clean vs. polluted) and under strong and weak convective forcing (proxy for updraft strength). Because hygroscopicity and size both modulate the critical supersaturation for activation, a weak response to size implies a similarly weak response to composition. Experimental and numerical details are provided in Methods and the Supplementary Information. Figure 1 summarizes results for the 12 cases: each row corresponds to a distinct experimental regime, with columns showing observed droplet size distributions (a), LES output (b), and the simulated distribution of water vapor supersaturation, s (c). With the exception of polluted conditions under weak forcing (bottom panel of Fig. 1 ), the number and shape of the droplet distribution above 5 \mu m show little dependence on injected aerosol size. We emphasize D>5\penalty\ \mu m because these droplets dominate cloud reflectivity. Despite the fact that increasing dry diameter of the aerosol particles from 50 to 250 nm reduces the critical supersaturation for activation by nearly an order of magnitude, the resulting droplet size distributions are nearly indistinguishable across aerosol sizes in most regimes. Model–observation differences are minor and attributed to limitations in the measurements and SAM’s numerical representation. In the SAM LES, the haze-capable microphysics resolves interstitial bins that are not captured by the Welas optical particle counter [ 39 ] , indicated by the grey shading in Fig. 1 b. The apparent absence of these features in Fig. 1 a reflects the Welas detection limit (see Methods for ranges and SI discussion). To better understand how the cloud environment modulates the sensitivity of the cloud droplet size distribution to the characteristics of the underlying aerosol particles, we analyzed differences in the water vapor supersaturation, s , within the LES across the different cases (Fig. 1 c). Within the LES, s is determined within each 6.25 x 6.25 x 6.25 cm 3 grid cell volume from the temperature and water vapor mixing ratio tracked by the LES. This simulation data provides details of small-scale variability in s that cannot be accurately measured directly within the Pi Chamber [ 5 , 4 ] and is not resolved in large-scale cloud simulations. Fig. 1 c shows the mean and variation in s for the three dry sizes that we tested (colors) and cloud conditions (groups). Differences in both the mean and spread of s across regimes (Fig. 1 c) align with the observed insensitivity of droplet size to aerosol size. Under conditions of strong forcing and low aerosol loading (top panel of Fig. 1 ), where s attains its highest values, the droplet size distributions are effectively independent of injected size. In this regime, nearly all particles activate rapidly and rarely experience subsaturated conditions; solute effects are minimized, and activated droplets behave similarly to pure water, yielding overlapping size distributions across aerosol sizes. At the other extreme—weak convective forcing and high aerosol loading (bottom panel of Fig. 1 )—increasing the size of the injected aerosol reduces the concentration of largest cloud droplets and alters the overall cloud droplet size distribution. Either weakening convective forcing in the chamber or increasing aerosol loading lowers the mean s within the chamber (Fig. 1 c), which enhances competition for vapor and makes activation more selective. While small differences appear for droplets between 1 and 5 \mu m under intermediate regimes, pronounced differences for D>5\penalty\ \mu m arise only under weak forcing and high pollution levels (bottom panel), coincident with the lowest s levels in the chamber. Cloud optical properties more responsive to aerosol size under polluted, weakly forced regimes We quantified how the microphysical