Holographic Constraints on the String Landscape Journal: Physics Letters B

Alek Bedroya, Paul J. Steinhardt · 2025

Read Holographic Constraints on the String Landscape Journal: Physics Letters B by Alek Bedroya, Paul J. Steinhardt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15784.txt.

Introduction

Alek Bedroya and Paul J. Steinhardt show that holography sharply limits which scalar field potentials can exist in the string theory landscape. Holography says a gravity theory in a volume can be described by a theory on its boundary. Scalar potentials shape possible universes in string theory, and the allowed shapes are set by how space-time behaves far away.

Applying holographic consistency rules rules out broad families: long flat plateaus, asymptotics that are too steep or too shallow, certain zero crossings, and some aligned stable minima. With a standard assumption about how the dual theory is realized on a brane, scale separation is forbidden in one limit direction. The rules also enforce a censorship conjecture and exclude leading proposals for special vacuum states.

Catalog record

CREATORAlek Bedroya, Paul J. Steinhardt
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15784

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Holographic Constraints on the String Landscape Journal: Physics Letters B Alek Bedroya, Paul J. Steinhardt Abstract We show that holography imposes strong and general constraints on scalar field potentials in the string landscape, determined by the asymptotic structure of the underlying spacetime. Applying these holographic consistency conditions, we identify broad classes of scalar potentials that are incompatible with a well-defined dual description. These include potentials with extended plateaus, excessively steep or shallow asymptotics, certain zero crossings, and specific alignments of stable AdS minima in moduli space. In particular, making the standard assumption that the CFT dual to a stable AdS vacuum must be realized as a worldvolume theory of a brane in string theory, we show that the brane selects an infinite-distance limit in moduli space where parametric scale separation is forbidden. Furthermore, the steepness and positivity of the potential are restricted in that infinite distance direction. We also find that requiring the validity of the effective theory in the future vacuum—a natural holographic criterion—automatically enforces the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) for classical cosmological solutions with positive potentials. Taken together, these constraints exclude the leading proposals to realize scale-separated AdS vacua and metastable de Sitter vacua in the string theory landscape such as DGKT and KKLT. 1 Introduction In string theory, infinite-distance limits of moduli space display universal behavior. First, scalar potentials fall off exponentially fast in weak-coupling limits at infinite distance in field space [ 1 ] . Second, an infinite tower of light, weakly coupled states emerges, with masses decreasing exponentially as functions of the scalar moduli fields in the asymptotic limi [ 2 ] . This implies that the lightest tower mass must scale polynomially with the potential. Finally, as this tower becomes lighter, gravity grows strongly coupled at a parametrically lower scale than M_{\rm Pl} , causing an exponential fall-off of the quantum gravity cutoff denoted by \Lambda_{s} [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . These features are well established in string theory and are conjectured to have generalizations that persist throughout the interior of moduli space. In this work we focus on two conjectures motivated by these features. One applies to negative scalar potentials, the other to positive potentials: Strong AdS Distance Conjecture (SADC) [ 2 ] : In any AdS vacuum described by Einstein gravity, there exists a tower of states with mass m satisfying \displaystyle m^{2}<A\,|\Lambda_{\rm AdS}|\,, (1) where A is an \mathcal{O}(1) constant. Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) [ 7 ] : Any FRW phase of accelerated expansion with scale factor a and Hubble parameter H obeys \displaystyle\frac{a_{f}}{a_{i}}\,l_{P}\;\leq\;\frac{1}{H_{f}}\,, (2) where i and f denote the initial and final times. If these conjectures are correct, it is imperative to establish them under minimal assumptions, given their profound implications for the interior of moduli space, which is likely where our universe resides. This motivates developing sharp, bottom–up principles that apply away from weak–coupling boundaries. In this Letter, we draw from a series of recent works [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] to formulate new holographic methods that yield robust constraints on scalar potentials and establish special cases of the conjectures above. The central logic is that, in theories where the scalar potential vanishes at infinite distance in field space, one can construct solutions in which the scalar itself runs off to infinity. Since observables in quantum gravity are defined at the boundary, the behavior of fields at infinity encodes detailed information about the interior of spacetime, and hence of moduli space. Thus, the structure of the interior of the moduli space is not independent of but, rather, highly constrained by its asymptotic behavior. 2 Constraints on scalar field potentials We begin by establishing four conditions (C1–C4) that any scalar potential in a consistent quantum–gravitational theory must satisfy. C1: TCC for classical scalar cosmologies [ 9 ] . Every expanding, spatially flat FRW cosmology driven by a scalar field that runs to infinite distance without tunneling must satisfy the TCC. C2: Asymptotic No–Scale–Separation (ANSS) [ 11 ] . For every stable AdS critical point in the landscape, there must exist an infinite–distance limit \varphi\to\infty aligned with \nabla V in which V\to 0^{-} and \partial_{\phi}\!\ln V\;\partial_{\phi}\!\ln\Lambda_{s}\leq\frac{2}{d-2}, (3) in Planck units. Equivalently, \frac{\nabla V}{V}\!\cdot\!\frac{\nabla\Lambda_{s}}{\Lambda_{s}}\leq\frac{2}{d-2}, (4) where \nabla is taken with respect to the light moduli and the metric on field space is G_{IJ} from the kinetic term \mathcal{L}_{\rm kin}=\tfrac{1}{2}\,G_{IJ}\,\partial_{\mu}\Phi^{I}\partial^{\mu}\Phi^{J} . This condition is closely tied to the relation between V and the mass scale m of the lightest tower of states. The Emergent String Conjecture implies the universal relation [ 12 , 13 ] \frac{\nabla m}{m}\!\cdot\!\frac{\nabla\Lambda_{s}}{\Lambda_{s}}=\frac{1}{d-2}, (5) so ANSS may be rewritten as \frac{\nabla V}{V}\!\cdot\!\frac{\nabla\Lambda_{s}}{\Lambda_{s}}\leq\frac{\nabla m^{2}}{m^{2}}\!\cdot\!\frac{\nabla\Lambda_{s}}{\Lambda_{s}}, (6) implying that m^{2} must decay at least as fast as V along \nabla\Lambda_{s} , hence the connection to scale separation. Two corollaries of the derivation of ANSS, established in this work, are: C3: Existence of a brane. There must exist a stationary warped solution with a spatially varying scalar field, i.e. the dual brane, in which the scalar field interpolates from the AdS critical point to the infinite–distance limit satisfying ANSS. C4: Bound on potential steepness. In the infinite–distance limit where V\to 0^{-} , the exponential falloff cannot be too steep: \bigl|\nabla V/V\bigr|\leq 2\sqrt{\frac{d-1}{d-2}}. (7) This constraint excludes steep negative potentials from admitting a consistent holographic dual. A partial argument for C1 was given in Ref. [ 8 ] , showing that the TCC is automatically satisfied in string theory at the future infinity of power–law FRW backgrounds a(t)\!\sim\!t^{p} where the scalar field \phi rolls down an exponential potential. If TCC is violated at future infinity (i.e. p>1 ) the boundary two–point functions of the tower of light states vanish at separated points. This implies that all boundary correlators, including higher–spin modes, are trivial. Since no boundary observables such as scattering amplitudes or frozen correlators exist in this case, the configuration violates the holographic principle. The argument relies on \lim_{t\rightarrow\infty}m/H=\infty and therefore does not exclude metastable de Sitter vacua where m/H is finite and boundary data can be defined through dS/CFT [ 14 ] . Rather, it shows that after tunneling from a metastable de Sitter vacuum, the late–time expansion must satisfy a(t)\!\sim\!t^{p} with p\!\leq\!1 , which is precisely the TCC bound [ 7 ] for power–law FRW backgrounds. To complete the argument for C1 , Ref. [ 9 ] proved by contradiction that the TCC holds in the interior of moduli space. Consider a background that transitions from an accelerating phase a(t)\!\sim\!t^{q} with q>1 to a decelerating phase a(t)\!\sim\!t^{p} with \frac{1}{2}<p<1 . Using the WKB approximation to the Mukhanov–Sasaki equation, one finds unavoidable particle production in the accelerating phase, n_{k}\!\sim\!\Big(\tfrac{k}{\mathcal{V}_{\max}}\Big)^{-2\sqrt{\frac{q(2q-1)}{(1-q)^{2}}}-\sqrt{\max\!\big(0,\frac{p(2p-1)}{(1-p)^{2}}\big)}}. (8) At small k , if the accelerating phase lasts long enough to violate TCC, this production leads to trans–Planckian excitations when the vacuum is evolved backward in time, contradicting the validity of the effective theory in the future vacuum. Hence, any scalar cosmology that rolls to infinite distance without tunneling must satisfy the TCC. As for C2 , ANSS: Holographic duals of AdS vacua arise when low–energy degrees of freedom localized on branes (or in near–horizon regions of black branes) decouple from bulk gravity. Upon dimensional reduction on the transverse directions, extremal black

Read the complete text