Structured Extraction of Vulnerabilities in OpenVAS and Tenable WAS Reports Using LLMs

Beatriz Machado 1 , Douglas Lautert 1 , Cristhian Kapelinski 1 , Diego Kreutz 1 · 2025

Read Structured Extraction of Vulnerabilities in OpenVAS and Tenable WAS Reports Using LLMs by Beatriz Machado 1 , Douglas Lautert 1 , Cristhian Kapelinski 1 , Diego Kreutz 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15745.txt.

Introduction

Beatriz Machado, Douglas Lautert, Cristhian Kapelinski, and Diego Kreutz use large language models to turn messy security scanner reports into structured data. Reports from the OpenVAS and Tenable WAS scanners list vulnerabilities in unstructured text, which is slow to use for risk management. Their automated method extracts each weakness and rewrites it in a standardized format.

In a test on a report containing thirty-four vulnerabilities, two leading models produced output closest to a human baseline, scoring high on a standard text overlap measure. The authors conclude the approach is feasible for turning complex reports into usable data sets. Structured output enables clearer prioritization and opens the door to anonymizing sensitive details later.

Catalog record

CREATORBeatriz Machado 1 , Douglas Lautert 1 , Cristhian Kapelinski 1 , Diego Kreutz 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE14 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15745

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Structured Extraction of Vulnerabilities in OpenVAS and Tenable WAS Reports Using LLMs Beatriz Machado 1 , Douglas Lautert 1 , Cristhian Kapelinski 1 , Diego Kreutz 1 Abstract This paper proposes an automated LLM-based method to extract and structure vulnerabilities from OpenVAS and Tenable WAS scanner reports, converting unstructured data into a standardized format for risk management. In an evaluation using a report with 34 vulnerabilities, GPT-4.1 and DeepSeek achieved the highest similarity to the baseline (ROUGE-L greater than 0.7). The method demonstrates feasibility in transforming complex reports into usable datasets, enabling effective prioritization and future anonymization of sensitive data. I Introduction Vulnerability scanners such as OpenVAS and Tenable WAS are widely used to identify flaws in web applications; however, they produce structurally heterogeneous reports, which complicates automated analysis and integration with machine learning models. This inconsistency, combined with the large volume of reported vulnerabilities, intensifies the challenge of prioritization, especially in institutions with limited resources. Data from SGIS 1 1 1 https://tinyurl.com/RelatorioRNP2017 indicate that more than 500,000 vulnerabilities remained unaddressed in 2017, a trend that increases with the expansion of the attack surface and the continuous growth of threats, as highlighted by the RNP Security Report 2 2 2 https://www.rnp.br/publicacao/relatorio-anual-de-seguranca-de-2023 . In this context, this work proposes a method based on Large Language Models (LLMs) to extract vulnerabilities from OpenVAS and Tenable WAS reports. The developed tool, called Vulnerability Extractor 3 3 3 https://github.com/AnonShield/Vulnerability_Extractor , converts these reports into a structured format to enable subsequent analysis, prioritization, and the construction of datasets usable by machine learning models. The approach aims to standardize and harmonize the extracted information, ensuring consistency across different tools and significantly reducing manual processing overhead. Additionally, the method is designed for future integration with anonymization modules, enabling the creation of secure and shareable datasets among institutions. II Vulnerability Reports OpenVAS and Tenable WAS are among the leading tools for automatic vulnerability detection, but they present structural and semantic differences that directly impact the extraction and analysis of results. Understanding these distinctions is essential for ensuring greater consistency in information extraction and data standardization from both sources. Table I: Fields present in OpenVAS reports. Element Description Summary Brief summary of the identified issue. Vulnerability Detection Result Indicates vulnerable URLs, ports, or services detected by the scanner. Impact Explains the potential consequences of exploiting the vulnerability. Solution Provides recommendations to mitigate or remediate the issue. Affected Software/OS Identifies the affected software, operating system, or component. Vulnerability Insight Details the origin and exploitation mechanism of the vulnerability. Vulnerability Detection Method Describes the method or script used by the scanner to identify the flaw. Log Method Specifies techniques or logging approaches used during detection. References Lists CVE identifiers, links, or other relevant references. OpenVAS, as shown in Table I , prioritizes a high level of technical detail, including fields such as Vulnerability Insight , which describe the nature and causes of vulnerabilities [ 3 ] . On the other hand, Tenable WAS (see Table II ) adopts a more risk-management-oriented approach, incorporating sections such as Risk Information , which directly support remediation prioritization [ 6 ] . Table III illustrates how the same vulnerability may be represented differently across vulnerability scanners, reflecting variations in structure and detail. While OpenVAS tends to use a more granular and technically oriented organization, Tenable WAS emphasizes consolidated information with a focus on risk management and prioritization. This structural heterogeneity required adaptations in the extraction process to ensure correct interpretation and standardization of data from both tools. Table II: Fields present in Tenable WAS reports. Element Description Affected Application Information about the affected application, including name, first and last detection dates. Description Details of the Tenable plugin responsible for identifying the vulnerability and contextualizing its behavior. Solution Recommended mitigation actions, including official fixes when available. See Also External links and references that expand the technical description. Vulnerability Properties General properties such as severity, exploitability, publication date, and remediation status. Discovery Records the first and last detection dates, providing monitoring history. VPR Key Drivers Factors used to calculate the Vulnerability Priority Rating (VPR), such as impact and exploitation trends. Plugin Details Technical information about the detection plugin, including version and dependencies. Risk Information Associated risk metrics (CVSSv2, CVSSv3, CVSSv4), attack vectors, and risk modifications such as Accept or Recast . Reference Information External references related to the vulnerability, exploit, patch, or security bulletins. To handle the diversity of fields and structural differences in reports from both vulnerability scanners, we implemented an explicit mapping in the prompt sent to the language model, associating tool-specific fields with a set of generalized labels. Missing fields were filled with NULL values to prevent the model from generating artificial information and to preserve fidelity to the original data. This mapping, documented in the Vulnerability Extractor documentation, ensures consistency across reports and defines the unified schema used to normalize fields from different scanners. Table III: Comparison of OptionsBleed in OpenVAS and Tenable WAS. Element OpenVAS Tenable WAS Vulnerability name Apache HTTP Server OPTIONS Memory Leak Vulnerability (OptionsBleed) Apache 2.4.x < 2.4.28 HTTP Vulnerability (OptionsBleed) CVE CVE-2017-9798 CVE-2017-9798 Description Apache HTTP Server allows remote attackers to read data […] Versions of Apache 2.4.x prior to 2.4.28 are affected by a vulnerability […] Installed version 2.2.8 2.4.7 Fixed version 2.4.28 (or equivalent patch for 2.2.34) 2.4.28 Impact Allows unauthorized reading of memory blocks from the server. https://httpd.apache.org/security/vulnerabilities_24.html\#2.4.28 Severity (CVSS) 5.0 (Medium) 7.5 (High, CVSSv3) Solution Update to Apache HTTP Server 2.4.28 […] Update to Apache HTTP Server 2.4.28 […] Detection method Apache Web Server Detection (OID: 1.3.6.1.4.1.25623.1.0.900498) Plugin ID 98913 Family / Category Web Server Vulnerability Component Vulnerability References http://openwall.com/lists/oss-security/2017/09/18/2 […] https://httpd.apache.org/security/vulnerabilities_24.html\#2.4.28 […] III Related Work As summarized in Table IV , automated extraction of unstructured data from technical documents has become a relevant advancement in cybersecurity, especially for vulnerability identification and analysis. Recent studies demonstrate that LLMs such as GPT-4, LLaMA, and Claude improve both precision and semantic consistency in various information extraction scenarios. Works such as [ 2 ] show significant gains in clinical contexts, while [ 5 ] and [ 8 ] explore the potential of LLMs in visual and multimodal documents, highlighting their versatility in integrating text and images. Approaches such as [ 4 ] , complemented by analyses from [ 1 ] , reinforce the models’ ability to generalize extraction tasks, their high adaptability, and efficiency in cross-domain transfer. Table IV: Information extraction with LLMs Reference Domain / Application Document Type Model (LLMs) [ 4 ] General / multiple KIE domains Tables + non-standard layouts GPT-4, T5-XXL, LLaMA-3 [ 2 ] Clinical / multilingual medical notes Clinical text (French and English) GPT-4, LLaMA-3, Mistral-7B [ 8 ] Multimodal / image-text Multimodal AI documents CLIP, BLIP-2, GPT-4V [ 1 ] General AI / prompt engineering Review / survey GPT-4, Gemini 2, Claude 3, LLaMA-3, Mistral-Large [ 7 ] Technical / document processing Technical documents and forms T5, BART, LLaMA-2, GPT-4 This work Vulnerabilities / Chunking Vulnerability reports (OpenVAS / Nessus) GPT-4, GPT-4.1, LLaMA-3, LLaMA-4, DeepSeek Despite these advances, the current literature focuses mainly on clinical, multimodal, or generic technical documents, with limited emphasis on operational security scanners. This work differs by specifically investigating standardized extraction of vulnerabilities from heterogeneous OpenVAS

Read the complete text