Bell Inequality Violation with Vacuum-One-Photon Number Superposition States

Zi-Qi Zeng, Jian Wang, Xiu-Bin Liu, Xu-Jie Wang, Li Liu, Hanqing Liu, Haiqiao Ni, Zhichuan Niu, Carlos Antón-Solanas, Bang Wu, Zhiliang Yuan · 2025

Read Bell Inequality Violation with Vacuum-One-Photon Number Superposition States by Zi-Qi Zeng, Jian Wang, Xiu-Bin Liu, Xu-Jie Wang, Li Liu, Hanqing Liu, Haiqiao Ni, Zhichuan Niu, Carlos Antón-Solanas, Bang Wu, Zhiliang Yuan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15413.txt.

Introduction

Zi-Qi Zeng, Jian Wang, and nine co-authors report a new way to make entangled light, a linked state used in quantum tools. Entanglement means two particles act as one system even when split apart. Their source is a single quantum dot, a tiny solid speck, driven by light so it glows in a controlled way.

Instead of making many photons, the team uses states that mix no photon with one photon. Splitting that state on a beam splitter creates time-bin entanglement, where the link sits in early and late arrival times. Tests with linked detectors break a classic Bell limit, which confirms real entanglement and points toward simpler solid-state sources.

Catalog record

CREATORZi-Qi Zeng, Jian Wang, Xiu-Bin Liu, Xu-Jie Wang, Li Liu, Hanqing Liu, Haiqiao Ni, Zhichuan Niu, Carlos Antón-Solanas, Bang Wu, Zhiliang Yuan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15413

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bell Inequality Violation with Vacuum-One-Photon Number Superposition States Zi-Qi Zeng, Jian Wang, Xiu-Bin Liu, Xu-Jie Wang, Li Liu, Hanqing Liu, Haiqiao Ni, Zhichuan Niu, Carlos Antón-Solanas, Bang Wu, Zhiliang Yuan Abstract Entanglement is a central resource in quantum technologies, and the realization of photonic entanglement necessarily relies on interaction with matter. Resonance fluorescence (RF), originating from the coherent interaction between a driving field and a two-level system, plays a pivotal role in quantum optics. Here, we demonstrate a novel route to entanglement generation based on RF from a single quantum dot. Rather than relying on generation of multiphoton states, our approach directly exploits vacuum–one-photon number superposition states created under resonant excitation. By delocalizing this superposition via a beam splitter, we realize time-bin entanglement and observe a clear violation of the Clauser–Horn–Shimony–Holt Bell inequality using Franson-type interferometry. Our scheme removes the need for multiphoton generation, simplifies the experimental requirements, and establishes a scalable pathway toward solid-state entangled photon sources. Photonic quantum states underpin quantum information technologies, with their nonclassical features enabling computation, communication, and precision measurement beyond classical limits 10 ; 5 ; 31 ; 27 . Among these, superpositions of photon-number (Fock) states constitute one of the most essential quantum resources, since it provides an unbounded Hilbert space 20 ; 23 . While multi-photon Fock states ( \ket{n} , with n{>}1 ) are often viewed as essential resources to explore the qudit encoding, the first step is to harness the superposition of vacuum and single-photon states, \sqrt{p_{0}}\ket{0}+\sqrt{p_{1}}\ket{1} . Such states not only provide the basis for optical qubits but, more importantly, can be extended into highly efficient entangled states simply by correlating them across multiple spatial or temporal modes 17 ; 2 . Demonstrating this entanglement scheme offers a simpler and more efficient pathway than relying on the preparation of complex multi-photon states. Figure 1: Experimental setup. (a) , The setup is composed by a quantum light source (light pink area) with a QD-micropillar device, resonantly driven by a CW laser, same resonant scheme as in Ref. 30 . The RF signal is split by a fiber beam splitter (FBS) and directed into two independent time-bin analyzers consisting of two AMZIs located at A and B sites(light blue areas). Coincidence counts are recorded by single-photon detectors (see detectors A_{1} , A_{2} and B_{1} , B_{2} , respectively). Independent \phi_{A} and \phi_{B} phases of the two AMZIs are stabilized to desired values using a PID feedback loop based on the intensity of the phase locking laser. (b) , High-resolution RF spectra measured with a Fabry-Pèrot interferometer (FPI). (c) , Auto-correlation function g^{(2)}(\tau) measured at an average photon number \bar{n}=0.01 using a Hanbury Brown-Twiss (HBT) setup. FC, fiber collimator; QWP, quarter-wave plate; HWP, half-wave plate; MR, mirror; PZT, piezoelectric transducer; BS, beam splitter; PBS, polarizing beam splitter. A_{1} , A_{2} , B_{1} , and B_{2} are the labels for the superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPDs). In general, efficiently preparing and manipulating vacuum-one-photon states requires sophisticated quantum state engineering and conditional preparation 19 ; 7 ; 15 . Resonance fluorescence (RF) from a two-level quantum emitter offers a natural platform for preparing these superpositions. By resonantly exciting a quantum dot (QD), it has been shown the precise superposition control over \ket{0} and \ket{1} states, marking a significant breakthrough in quantum state preparation encoded in the photon-number basis 15 ; 8 ; 12 ; 29 . Building on this scheme, the deterministic generation of time-entangled states via sequential pulsed driving, the teleportation of vacuum-one-photon states 18 , and the generation of two-photon states \ket{2} via phase-controlled quantum interference 29 ; 13 has been recently demonstrated. However, these efforts have not been systematically extended to distributed entangled-state between different spatial modes. In parallel, pioneering work has demonstrated energy–time entanglement between photon pairs harnessing the RF from natural and artificial atoms 14 ; 28 . Yet, these approaches rely on post-selecting two-photon components (e.g., \ket{2} or sideband photon pairs), which severely limits efficiency. In this work, we establish and experimentally demonstrate an alternative route: generating time-bin entanglement from vacuum–one-photon superposition states directly arising from the atom RF, without further preparing or filtering two-photon states. Using a Franson-type interferometer to implement projective measurements in the time-basis, we observe a clear violation of the Clauser–Horn–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) Bell inequality 6 , providing direct evidence of genuine entanglement shared between separate nodes. All experimental results are consistently explained and quantitatively reproduced within the framework of the pure-state model 29 . Our approach avoids reliance on multi-photon emission, and demonstrates the state-of-the-art efficiency of solid-state-based photon sources. Figure 1 describes the experimental setup, following the standard Franson interferometer scheme 9 . The quantum light source is composed of a self-assembled InAs QD coupled to a micropillar cavity, resonantly driven by a continuous wave (CW) laser. The excitation scheme is the same as in Ref. 30 ; the laser and QD emission are not in cross-polarization configuration (see Fig. 1 (a)): the micropillar is engineered to be almost non-reflective at the cavity resonance. Hence, at low drive, the QD response dominates over the negligible cavity background (see Section II-1 of the Supplemental Material for further details). As a result of the RF excitation at low driving, the device emits a CW stream of single photons, see QD spectrum and anti-bunched photon statistics under a laser excitation of \bar{n}=0.01 in Figs. 1 (b,c), respectively. The excitation fluxes ( \bar{n} ) were strictly calibrated via the incident optical power ( P_{in} ) upon the sample surface using the relation \bar{n}=P_{in}T_{1}/h\nu , where T_{1} =67.2 ps is the exciton lifetime and \nu=329.14 THz is the pump laser frequency. For the sake of simplicity, and representing a good description of our single photon source emission at low driving, we describe the quantum light state as a pure superposition of temporally de-localized vacuum and single photons states \sqrt{p_{0}}\ket{0}+\sqrt{p_{1}}e^{i\omega_{0}t}\ket{1} , where p_{0}+p_{1}=1 and the one-photon mode takes the excitation laser phase 15 ; 29 . In order to test the violation of the Bell inequality, a time-entangled state is generated. Initially, the vacuum-one-photon superposition stream is entangled between two spatial modes (Alice and Bob) after a fiber beamsplitter (FBS), see central part of Fig. 1 . Vacuum-one-photon states from two different time bins, early ( e ) and late ( l ), form a time-bin entangled state resembling 1/\sqrt{2}(\ket{1^{e}_{A},1^{l}_{B}}+\ket{1^{l}_{A},1^{e}_{B}}) (the factor p_{1}/2 is removed in this expression from the state post-selection). Then, Alice and Bob implement local measurements in two independent asymmetric Mach-Zehnder interferometers (AMZIs) 25 . The AMZIs temporal delay is \tau=1.07 ns (satisfying the condition T_{1}\ll\tau\ll T_{L} , where T_{L}\approx 10 \mu s is the laser coherence time). Independent projective measurements are performed in the Alice and Bob nodes by varying the phases \phi_{A/B} , and the outcomes are detected by the single-photon detectors A_{1,2}/B_{1,2} , respectively (see Fig. 1 ). The whole system is actively phase locked using the driving laser as the locking reference (orange beam in Fig. 1 , see Section II-2 of the Supplemental Material for further details). Figure 2: Mappings of the second-order correlation function g^{(2)}(\Delta t) . The laser driving power was set at \bar{n}=0.01 . (a-d) , Normalized second-order correlation measurements of resonance fluorescence after the Franson interferometer

Read the complete text