Refractive indices of photochemical haze analogs for Solar System and exoplanet applications : a cross-laboratory comparative study between the PAMPRE and COSmIC experimental set-ups

T. Drant, E. Sciamma-O’Brien, L. Jovanovic, Z. Perrin, L. Maratrat, L. Vettier, E. Garcia-Caurel, J.-B. Brubach, D.H. Wooden, T.L. Roush, C.L. Ricketts, P. Rannou · 2025

Read Refractive indices of photochemical haze analogs for Solar System and exoplanet applications : a cross-laboratory comparative study between the PAMPRE and COSmIC experimental set-ups by T. Drant, E. Sciamma-O’Brien, L. Jovanovic, Z. Perrin, L. Maratrat, L. Vettier, E. Garcia-Caurel, J.-B. Brubach, D.H. Wooden, T.L. Roush, C.L. Ricketts, P. Rannou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15310.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Drant, Ella Sciamma-O'Brien, and ten co-authors measure how laboratory-made hazes bend and absorb light across a huge range of wavelengths. Photochemical hazes cloud the skies of Titan, Pluto, the gas giants, and many exoplanets, and they skew every telescope observation of those worlds. Climate and retrieval models need the haze's refractive indices, yet those numbers depend sensitively on how the haze was brewed.

Two independent laboratory setups grow haze analogs for Titan, Pluto, and exoplanet conditions, and the teams compare results head to head. New data run from the ultraviolet to the far infrared. Cross-checking between labs shows how much of the variation is real chemistry and how much is apparatus, which steadies future models.

Catalog record

CREATORT. Drant, E. Sciamma-O’Brien, L. Jovanovic, Z. Perrin, L. Maratrat, L. Vettier, E. Garcia-Caurel, J.-B. Brubach, D.H. Wooden, T.L. Roush, C.L. Ricketts, P. Rannou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE108 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15310

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Refractive indices of photochemical haze analogs for Solar System and exoplanet applications : a cross-laboratory comparative study between the PAMPRE and COSmIC experimental set-ups T. Drant, E. Sciamma-O’Brien, L. Jovanovic, Z. Perrin, L. Maratrat, L. Vettier, E. Garcia-Caurel, J.-B. Brubach, D.H. Wooden, T.L. Roush, C.L. Ricketts, P. Rannou Abstract Previous observations of Titan, Pluto and Solar System gas giants along with recent observations of exoplanet atmospheres with the James Webb Space Telescope taught us that photochemical hazes are ubiquitous and form in a variety of temperature, gas composition and irradiation environments. Despite being crucial to understand their impact on observations and on the planetary radiative budget, the refractive indices of these haze particles are unknown and strongly influenced by changes in the gas phase chemistry. In this study, we perform a cross-laboratory investigation to assess the effect of the experimental set-up and gas composition on the refractive indices of Titan, Pluto and exoplanet haze analogs. We report new data in a broad spectral range from UV to far-IR (up to 200 μ \mu m) for future use in climate models and retrieval frameworks. We compare the refractive indices of laboratory haze analogs produced from six different gas compositions where we varied the relative abundances N 2 /CH 4 and CH 4 /CO in the initial gas mixture using the PAMPRE (LATMOS, France) and COSmIC (NASA Ames Research Center, USA) experimental set-ups. We observed strong variations of the k values in the spectral range from UV to near-IR between the different analogs which is caused by both the experimental set-up and by changes in the gas N 2 /CH 4 ratio. We found that the gas N 2 /CH 4 ratio has a stronger influence on the haze refractive indices in the entire spectral range compared to the gas CH 4 /CO ratio. The experimental set-up is the primary factor affecting the refractive indices confirming that the gas residence time, irradiation, pressure and gas temperature are important parameters influencing the composition of the solid analog. The higher n and k values in the UV-Visible and the stronger amine/alkene/aromatic/hetero-aromatic signatures in the mid-IR for the COSmIC analogs are consistent with a stronger incorporation of nitrogen into the COSmIC solid analogs compared to the PAMPRE analogs, even for similar nitrogen abundances in the gas phase. Haze analogs produced in gas mixtures without nitrogen, similar to the stratosphere of Solar System gas giants and the H 2 -dominated atmospheres of sub-Neptunes, are generally more transparent with lower n values in the entire spectral range from UV to mid-IR and should therefore be considered carefully in climate and observational applications. The variations of IR absorption features between hazes produced with and without nitrogen could help constrain the presence of N 2 in exoplanet atmospheres. 1 Introduction Photochemical hazes are ubiquitous in the atmospheres of the different objects in the outer Solar System ( Kim et al. 1991 ; Ortiz et al. 1996 ; Wong et al. 2003 ; Gladstone et al. 2016 ; Hörst 2017 ; Mills et al. 2021 ; Sánchez-Lavega et al. 2023 ) , as well as in exoplanet atmospheres ( Gao et al. 2021 ) . Their formation is triggered by a complex radical organic chemistry mainly driven by vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) photons in the upper layers of planetary atmospheres, but also possible via energetic cosmic rays (e.g. suggested for Pluto’s dark surface material, Krasnopolsky 2020 ) and electrons accelerated in planetary magnetospheres (e.g. Jupiter’s polar hazes and Titan hazes, Wilson & Atreya 2004 , Wong et al. 2003 ). The chemical pathways leading to haze formation and controlling the composition of the resulting solid material remain largely unknown, posing the main limitation to numerically reproduce this essential piece of the atmospheric physico-chemical structure. Insights on the gas phase haze precursors, solid composition and optical properties primarily rely on laboratory experiments which provide crucial data to support modeling efforts and help interpret observations. Laboratory experiments revealed that hazes form under a broad variety of gas compositions including CH 4 - (e.g., Khare et al. 1984 and Imanaka et al. 2004 ), CO 2 - ( Trainer et al. 2004a ; Gavilan et al. 2018 ) , CO- ( Hörst & Tolbert 2014 ) and H 2 O-rich ( He et al. 2018 ) mixtures. The formation pathways and gas phase precursors are known to vary with the gas composition, for instance transitioning between aliphatic and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon pathways following the methane abundance ( Trainer et al. 2004b ) . In N 2 -dominated gas mixtures representative of Titan and Pluto’s atmosphere, the photochemical build-up of nitrile chains contributes significantly to the formation of these aerosols ( Khare et al. 1994 ; Gautier et al. 2011 ; Sciamma-O’Brien et al. 2014 ; Hörst et al. 2018 ; Perrin et al. 2021 ; Perrin et al. 2025 ) . Ion chemistry also leads to the formation of charged hydrocarbon and nitrile compounds acting as precursors to these haze particles during their formation in the ionosphere ( Vuitton et al. 2009 ; Dubois et al. 2020 ) . The composition of the solid analog is strongly affected by the gas phase chemistry, it is thus controlled by the initial gas composition but also by the experimental conditions, i.e., the pressure, the gas temperature and the irradiation efficiency ( Sciamma-O’Brien et al. 2014 ; Jovanovic et al. 2020 ; Carrasco et al. 2016 ; Nuevo et al. 2022 ) . A general framework has yet to be established to link the gas phase chemistry to the composition and production rate of haze particles under a variety of atmospheric environments. This solid composition must however be considered carefully as it significantly affects the optical properties of the haze particles and thus strongly impacts observations of planetary atmospheres (see reviews of Brassé et al. 2015 and Sciamma-O’Brien et al. 2024 ). In radiative transfer models, the haze composition is accounted for using the material’s complex refractive index, with the real part n describing dispersion of light and the imaginary part k quantifying absorption. These refractive indices are intrinsic properties controlled by the chemical composition and thus independent of the particle’s size and shape. Khare et al. 1984 provided the first refractive indices of laboratory-generated haze analogs for a Titan-like gas mixture with 90% N 2 and 10% CH 4 . This pioneer dataset is widely used in the community for its broad spectral range, never reproduced to this day. There currently exists several groups able to produce laboratory haze analogs and measure their refractive indices. Among them, we identify the NASA Ames group with the COSmIC set-up ( Sciamma-O’Brien et al. 2023 ) , the John Hopkins group with the PHAZER set-up ( He et al. 2022a ; He et al. 2024 ) , the LATMOS group with the PAMPRE set-up ( Sciamma-O’Brien et al. 2012 ; Mahjoub et al. 2012 ; Gavilan et al. 2017 ; Jovanovic et al. 2021 ; Drant et al. 2024 ) , and the Colorado group ( Hasenkopf et al. 2010 ; Ugelow et al. 2017 ; Ugelow et al. 2018 ; Reed et al. 2023 ) . This massive work developed throughout the past decades revealed that the refractive

Read the complete text