Realist and Pluralist Conceptions of Intelligence and Their Implications on AI Research
Ninell Oldenburg, Ruchira Dhar, Anders Søgaard · 2025
Read Realist and Pluralist Conceptions of Intelligence and Their Implications on AI Research by Ninell Oldenburg, Ruchira Dhar, Anders Søgaard (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15282.txt.
Introduction
Ninell Oldenburg, Ruchira Dhar, and Anders Søgaard argue that AI research is quietly split by two rival pictures of what intelligence is. One picture, realism, treats intelligence as a single universal capacity that any system can be measured against. The other, pluralism, sees many context-bound capacities that no single scale can capture.
Tracing current debates, the authors show these hidden commitments steer the field in concrete ways. They shape how models are selected, how benchmarks are designed, and how results are validated, and they change what counts as evidence in the first place. Naming the split, the paper suggests, would let researchers argue about the real disagreement instead of talking past each other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ninell Oldenburg, Ruchira Dhar, Anders Søgaard |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15282
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Realist and Pluralist Conceptions of Intelligence and Their Implications on AI Research Ninell Oldenburg, Ruchira Dhar, Anders Søgaard Abstract In this paper, we argue that current AI research operates on a spectrum between two different underlying conceptions of intelligence: Intelligence Realism , which holds that intelligence represents a single, universal capacity measurable across all systems, and Intelligence Pluralism , which views intelligence as diverse, context-dependent capacities that cannot be reduced to a single universal measure. Through an analysis of current debates in AI research, we demonstrate how the conceptions remain largely implicit yet fundamentally shape how empirical evidence gets interpreted across a wide range of areas. These underlying views generate fundamentally different research approaches across three areas. Methodologically, they produce different approaches to model selection, benchmark design, and experimental validation. Interpretively, they lead to contradictory readings of the same empirical phenomena, from capability emergence to system limitations. Regarding AI risk, they generate categorically different assessments: realists view superintelligence as the primary risk and search for unified alignment solutions, while pluralists see diverse threats across different domains requiring context-specific solutions. We argue that making explicit these underlying assumptions can contribute to a clearer understanding of disagreements in AI research. Introduction There is a growing debate among researchers on the nature and potential risks of AI, as well as the importance of respective research programs. On one hand, researchers warn that building bigger models may eventually lead to human-like, superhuman, or “transformative” and possibly dangerous levels of intelligence ( 4 ; 8 ; 64 ; 33 ) . On the other hand, scholars argue that simply creating larger models is unlikely to yield human-like cognition ( 65 ; 56 ; 41 ) . What is intriguing about this debate is that researchers are observing the same empirical data, model architectures, scaling laws, and model performance, while holding on to profoundly different interpretations, e.g., scaling laws as a sign of emerging superintelligence vs. task-specific improvements. In this article, we suggest that this dichotomy can be traced back to diverging beliefs on what intelligence is. On one hand, intelligence realists hold that intelligence represents a single, universal capacity measurable across all systems. On the other hand, intelligence pluralists see intelligence as diverse, context-dependent capacities that cannot be reduced to a single universal measure. This has first-order implications for how we understand “artificial” intelligence, what we consider useful and dangerous, how we test, evaluate, and interpret systems, and how we build them. Different interpretations of empirical scaling laws, i.e., whether they represent convergence toward universal intelligence or domain-specific optimization, depend on which philosophical framework researchers inherently hold. Our framework contributes to the philosophy of science by demonstrating how paradigmatic commitments shape observation and interpretation in contemporary AI research. Following 46 ’s theory that theoretical frameworks determine what counts as significant evidence, we show how realist and pluralist assumptions function as competing paradigms that make identical empirical results (scaling curves, benchmark performance, system failures) intelligible in fundamentally different ways. This extends 32 ’s theory-ladenness of observation to AI: what researchers “see” in GPT-4’s performance depends on their prior commitments about intelligence’s nature. By making these implicit paradigms explicit, we enable more productive scientific discourse and clearer identification of genuine empirical disagreements vs. philosophical differences. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. We first present the features of each view with examples from the literature. We acknowledge that this conceptualization should be seen as a continuum rather than a hard classification before describing the implications these positions have on AI research methodology and AI alignment. Table 1: Diagnostic Rubric for Identifying Intelligence Positions Dimension Realist Indicators Intermediate/Mixed Pluralist Indicators Ontology Intelligence as singular capacity; seeks universal algorithms Acknowledges diversity but looks for common principles Intelligence as multiple, incommensurable capacities Benchmarks Aggregates across domains (ARC-AGI, BIG-bench) Domain-specific scores but with overall rankings Separate evaluation per domain; refuses aggregation Comparison Claims “X is more intelligent than Y”; cross-species/-system rankings Qualified comparisons (“more intelligent at task T”) Rejects cross-system comparison as category error Scaling Laws Evidence of AGI convergence Sees progress but notes gaps Benchmark-specific optimization Failure Attribution “Engineering problems”; “needs more scale/data” Some architectural, some fundamental “Fundamental mismatches”; qualitative differences AI Risk Focus AGI; univ. alignment principles Both x-risk and near-term risks Context-specific, near-term Architecture Pref. Unified, general-purpose models Modular systems Specialized domain/task models Success Criteria Domain-general competence Task-specificity, some transfer Specific cognitive phenomena Our contribution is thereby not to invent a new distinction but to provide a targeted synthesis that contextualizes long-standing debates in psychology, philosophy, and cognitive science within contemporary AI research. What is novel is demonstrating how these debates structure AI research in ways researchers often do not recognize . By making explicit the implicit philosophical commitments underlying methodological choices, interpretive disagreements, and alignment strategies, we provide a vocabulary for clearer scientific discourse and more productive policy debates. Different Assumptions of Intelligence Assumptions Before presenting our classification, we want to disclaim two points. First, by claiming that different researchers have different underlying assumptions of intelligence, we do not intend to imply that these necessarily have been articulated . We posit that assumptions are revealed through methodological choices and interpretation of empirical research, and will point below to these exact differences. Second, as mentioned above, by asserting that different views of intelligence exist, we do not intend to imply that these exist only under hard, declarative boundaries. Agreement with either position need not involve a wholesale endorsement of every aspect. We briefly develop an intermediate position below. Intelligence Realism Intelligence realism makes three distinct but related claims: (1) Ontological: There exists a single, universal computational process that constitutes intelligence across all systems; (2) Epistemological: This universal process is discoverable through scientific investigation; (3) Methodological: Different intelligent systems can be meaningfully ranked according to how well they approximate this universal process. Here, we detail its underlying assumptions. 1 1 1 We use “Intelligence Realism” to denote a position that combines ontological realism (intelligence exists as a real phenomenon) with monism (it constitutes a single, universal capacity). While these are technically separable commitments, they travel together in the AI research context we analyze, where claims about universal intelligence algorithms typically presuppose their reality as computational processes. Algorithmic Universality The core ontological premise of intelligence realism is that intelligence follows universal and discoverable mathematical principles regardless of its instantiation. Epistemologically, this translates to the possibility of intelligence being described and tested for in abstract terms. One example of this perspective is Marcus Hutter’s AIXI model ( 37 ) , which is a theoretical framework that defines (artificial general) intelligence as the ability to achieve goals in different environments. Hutter’s AIXI formulation assumes that optimal intelligence can be expressed as a single optimization function across all environments, presupposing that different environments are commensurable and that a single policy exists that maximizes value across all contexts. This implies that realists interpret scaling laws as evidence for algorithmic universality: if larger models consistently improve across diverse tasks, this suggests convergence toward a universal intelligence algorithm. The smooth power-law relationships observed across language modeling, reasoning, and multimodal tasks support the realist claim that a single optimization process underlies all intelligent behavior. Single Optimality Closely tied in with the algorithmic universality assumption, secondly,