Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation 2026 Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation – 14
Arunima Arunima, Mark R. Krumholz , Michael J. Ireland , Chuhan Zhang, Sven Buder · 2025
Read Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation 2026 Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation – 14 by Arunima Arunima, Mark R. Krumholz , Michael J. Ireland , Chuhan Zhang, Sven Buder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15215.txt.
Introduction
Arunima Arunima, Mark R. Krumholz, and three co-authors test whether stars keep the orbital fingerprints of their birth clusters inside a simulated Milky Way. Astronomers hope to trace scattered stars back to their dissolved home clusters, which assumes each star's orbital actions stay nearly constant. A real disk, with its moving spiral arms and lumps, may scramble those actions over time.
In a high-resolution simulation of a spiral disk galaxy, individual stars do drift in action within a short span. Stars born close together, though, drift in step, keeping similar actions for up to half a billion years. That coherence, steady across the disk, means cluster reconstruction should target groups rather than lone stars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arunima Arunima, Mark R. Krumholz , Michael J. Ireland , Chuhan Zhang, Sven Buder |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15215
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation 2026 Evolution of action-space coherence in a Milky Way-like simulation – 14 Arunima Arunima, Mark R. Krumholz , Michael J. Ireland , Chuhan Zhang, Sven Buder Abstract Efforts to dynamically trace stars back to the now-dissolved clusters in which they formed rely implicitly on the assumption that stellar orbital actions are conserved. While this holds in a static, axisymmetric potential, it is unknown how strongly the time-varying, non-axisymmetric structure of a real galactic disk drives action drift that inhibits cluster reconstruction. We answer this question using a high-resolution magnetohydrodynamic simulation of a Milky Way-like spiral disc galaxy. We show that, while stars experience significant action evolution over ≲ 100 \lesssim 100 Myr, they do so in a correlated fashion whereby stars born in close proximity maintain very similar actions for up to 0.5 Gyr. The degree of coherence shows no significant dependence on galactocentric radius, but varies between action components: vertical actions decohere for stars born more than a few hundred parsecs apart (likely due to giant molecular clouds), while radial and azimuthal actions remain correlated on kiloparsec scales (likely influenced by spiral arms). We use our measurements of the rate of action decoherence to develop a probabilistic framework that lets us infer the initial sizes of the star cluster progenitors of present-day stellar streams from their measured action distributions, which we apply to 438 known moving groups. Our results suggest that most of these streams likely originated from compact clusters, but that a significant minority are instead likely to be resonant or dynamically induced structures. This method of classifying streams complements existing methods, optimises the use of expensive spectroscopic abundance measurements, and will be enhanced by the more precise kinematic data that will soon become available from Gaia DR4. 1 Introduction Stars form in clustered environments inside giant molecular clouds (GMCs), inheriting mutually similar kinematics and chemical compositions from their shared birth material ( 44 ) . Most of this clustered structure is not gravitationally bound following dispersal of the star-forming gas, and dissolves within tens to hundreds of million years (Myr) leaving the stellar population dispersed in the Galactic field. Even after the stars disperse in physical space, however, they retain imprints of their birthplaces in their characteristics ( 23 ) . If the dispersal occurs in a smooth, axisymmetric, and time-static potential, orbital actions are among these imprints, as they are expected to remain adiabatic invariants under motion in a potential satisfying these conditions ( 9 ) . These conserved quantities have, hence, become central to dynamical studies and Galactic archaeology: if stars born together remain clustered in action space, then action-based co-natal tagging can become a powerful tool for mapping the star formation history of the Galaxy ( 27 ; 48 ; 66 ; 57 ) . However, the Milky Way potential is neither static nor axisymmetric. It is shaped by both external perturbations such as satellite interactions ( 2 ; 3 ; 22 ) and secular internal processes such as transient spiral arm structure, the rotating Galactic bar, and the formation and dispersal of GMCs ( 51 ; 50 ; 21 ; 46 ; 60 ) . These processes all contribute to a time-variable and non-axisymmetric component of the potential that can perturb stellar actions. Numerical simulations have confirmed this non-conservation of actions across a range of models: from N- body simulations without gas dynamics or star formation, the least realistic representations of the Galaxy ( 54 ; 62 ; 47 ) , to semi-analytic dynamical models ( 37 ) , and most recently and realistically, to fully self-consistent magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations that include star formation, feedback and live disc with flocculent spiral arms ( 59 ; 58 ; 6 , hereafter 6 ) . In 6 , we quantified the non-conservation of individual stellar actions and showed that actions undergo a logarithmic random walk over timescales of hundreds of Myr. Yet a fundamental question still remains unanswered: Do co-natal stars retain coherence in action space over longer timescales? That is, while individual stars’ actions undergo random walks that significantly change their values over timescales of \sim 100 Myr, is it possible that the random walks taken by stars that are born close together are correlated , so that their actions remain close together in action space for longer times? There are compelling reasons to expect they might be. Co-natal stars, having shared initial conditions and experiencing same gravitational perturbations, should show similar changes in their actions and remain clustered in action space. If such coherence persists, it would lend strong support to the use of actions for co-natal tagging, providing a robust tool for identifying disrupted clusters. Indeed, several earlier studies have found evidence of long-lived clustering in phase space or integral-of-motion space even after spatial phase mixing. N- body studies of disrupting satellite galaxies or clusters have shown that stars can remain tightly grouped in action space for many orbital periods ( 28 ; 26 ) . Using cosmological hydrodynamical simulations, 5 demonstrated that stars born close together in the FIRE-2 Milky Way analogue retain action-space coherence for several hundred Myr before gradual dispersion in an evolving potential. Similarly, 36 modelled clustered star formation with realistic Galactic potential and found that co-natal stars maintain correlated kinematic signatures for extended timescales. Observationally, recent studies using Gaia have identified groups with dynamical coherence indicative of common origin due to their chemical and age similarities ( 17 ; 24 ) . These results suggest that actions indeed hold promise as diagnostics of star-formation origins, but their utility depends on timescales, birth separation, and the dynamical environment. Despite these advances, no study has yet examined the evolution of co-natal action coherence in a high-resolution, self-consistent MHD simulation of a live Milky Way-like disc. This gap leaves open uncertainties in how reliably actions can be used as archaeological tracers of stellar birth origins. In this paper, we address this question using a high-resolution MHD simulation of a Milky Way-like disc galaxy. Building directly on our previous study of individual stars’ action diffusion, we aim to extend the study of evolution of stellar actions for pairs of stars. This allows us to quantify the evolution of action differences and to measure the characteristic timescales and physical scales over which stars lose dynamical coherence in action space (a process we refer to as action-space decoherence). Through this, we can infer the co-natal origin of stars based solely on their current dynamical separation – which is easier than ever to achieve thanks to immaculate astrometric information from Gaia DR3 ( 25 ) , with the promise of even better data from Gaia DR4 in the very near future. Hence, we explore the use of our insights for observational analysis of star cluster disruption, stellar streams, dynamical reconstruction of co-natal groups in the Galactic disc. The paper is organised as follows. In Section 2 , we describe the galactic simulation and methodology used in this study. In Section 3 , we present the main results from this study including temporal evolution of action differences for pairs of stars, scales of decoherence as well as dependence of this evolution on the stars’ birth environment.