Corporate Earnings Calls and Analyst Beliefs
Giuseppe Matera · 2025
Read Corporate Earnings Calls and Analyst Beliefs by Giuseppe Matera (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-15214.txt.
Introduction
Giuseppe Matera shows that the stories told on corporate earnings calls move analyst beliefs beyond what the numbers alone explain. Executives frame results in narratives, and those frames shape how listeners read the same figures. Matera extracts narrative themes from call transcripts and shows they improve forecasts of both realized earnings and analyst expectations.
To isolate the effect, a text-morphing method uses language models to rewrite transcripts, changing the emphasis of the story while holding every number fixed. Analysts turn out to over-react to upbeat sentiment and under-react to talk of risk and uncertainty. The method gives researchers a clean way to price the persuasive layer of corporate communication.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giuseppe Matera |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 94 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-15214
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Corporate Earnings Calls and Analyst Beliefs Giuseppe Matera Abstract Economic behavior is shaped not only by quantitative information but also by the narratives through which such information is communicated and interpreted ( 100 ) . I show that narratives extracted from earnings calls significantly improve the prediction of both realized earnings and analyst expectations. To uncover the underlying mechanisms, I introduce a novel text-morphing methodology in which large language models generate counterfactual executive presentation from earnings calls that systematically vary topical emphasis (the prevailing narrative ) while holding quantitative content fixed. This framework allows me to precisely measure how analysts under- and over-react to specific narrative dimensions. The results reveal systematic biases: analysts over-react to sentiment (optimism) and under-react to narratives of risk and uncertainty. Overall, the analysis offers a granular perspective on the mechanisms of expectation formation through the competing narratives embedded in corporate communication. 1 Introduction Economic decision-making is shaped not only by data and models, but also by the narratives through which agents interpret and communicate economic reality. As 100 argues, narratives---compelling stories that convey meaning and emotional resonance---spread across economic actors much like contagions, influencing behavior and expectations in ways that traditional models of rational information processing often overlook. Yet, despite their acknowledged importance, the empirical content of such narratives remains difficult to quantify, and their role in shaping belief formation is not well understood. 1 1 1 Studies using surveys and large language models to examine and measure the role of narratives in financial markets and the macroeconomy include 4 , 24 , 9 , 3 , 45 , 48 , 2 . This paper offers an empirical approach to this problem by focusing on a setting where narratives are explicitly produced and transmitted: the interaction between corporate managers and financial analysts. Financial analysts occupy a central position in this narrative ecosystem. Tasked with interpreting corporate disclosures and market information, they act as intermediaries between firms and investors, translating managerial communication into forward-looking assessments of firm value. While the full-information rational expectations (FIRE) framework posits that forecasts should reflect the unbiased and comprehensive use of quantitative data, substantial evidence indicates that analysts’ expectations systematically deviate from this benchmark. Analysts tend to underreact to new information in the short term ( 80 ) and overreact in the long term by extrapolating recent positive signals ( 74 ) , with biases varying by forecast horizon ( 43 ; 40 ) . These systematic biases also relate to important macroeconomic and financial phenomena, including business cycles and asset price variation. 2 2 2 See 34 , 104 , 7 , 88 , 70 , 56 , 18 ; 19 ; 20 , 8 , 52 , and 95 , among others, and 1 for a review. These empirical regularities suggest that analysts belief formation processes are influenced by more than hard data alone. Consequentially, framing, tone, and emphasis, the narrative elements of corporate communication, play a crucial role in shaping how information is interpreted and transmitted. Earnings calls provide a particularly suitable context for this research. Held quarterly, they serve as both disclosure and performance overview: occasions where executives present quantitative results while also framing the firm’s trajectory through interpretive narratives. For analysts, these events offer a concentrated flow of both hard and soft information, with forecast revisions peaking in the immediate aftermath of the call. As such, earnings calls constitute a natural laboratory for testing how narratives are constructed, transmitted, and internalized within financial markets—and whether the attention financial analysts devote to them is justified by their informational content. The first contribution of this paper is to examine whether and how analysts incorporate information expressed and framed in corporate earnings calls into their belief formation processes. I also study whether analysts’ focus on these narratives reflects genuine informational value or merely responds to managerial framing. I show that the narrative and linguistic content of earnings calls indeed contains incremental information about firms’ fundamentals, and analysts take this into account while forming their beliefs. Extracting such narratives requires modern Large Language Models (LLMs) because corporate disclosures are inherently high-dimensional and context-dependent, and early textual proxies, such as word counts or readability indices, fail to capture the semantic nuance and communicative style. Specifically, to represent text, I compute earnings call transcripts embeddings 3 3 3 Embeddings are high-dimensional vector representations of the text capturing semantic and syntactic features. Every LLM generates a different embedding of a given text. using a finance-specific FinBERT model pretrained on financial text available before 2014. 4 4 4 Implementation details appear in later sections. For the model, see https://huggingface.co/ProsusAI/finbert . I deliberately avoid the latest foundation models to eliminate the risk of a look-ahead bias. 5 5 5 Several papers (see, e.g., 53 , 97 , 83 , have criticized using modern LLMs for economic research due to their inadvertent exposure during pretraining to economic data or contemporaneous news in the sample that the models are used to explain. By contrast, all results in this paper are free from such exposure. Hence, they should be interpreted as conservative: more expressive, state-of-the-art models would likely capture additional meaning and structure in the transcripts, yielding potentially stronger findings than those reported in this work. To pin down the incremental information contained in the narratives, I benchmark my results against a comprehensive set of more than 300 numerical firm characteristics constructed from the Global Factor Data of 67 (henceforth referred to as JKP data), as well as the most recent financial statements from the SEC 10-Ks filings. I also include abnormal stock returns (FF5-adjusted) on the earnings announcement date, along with realized earnings yields and the Standardized Unexpected Earnings (SUE; ( 80 ) ), as additional characteristics. I estimate several machine learning (ML) models based on three alternative feature sets: one using numerical stock characteristics alone, one using embeddings of earnings call transcripts alone, and one combining both sources. I then evaluate the models’ out-of-sample performance primarily through changes in the out-of-sample R-squared. Since direct comparisons of R-squared values can be sensitive to differences in the variability of test samples, I complement this analysis with the 30 test to assess whether the observed improvement in predictive accuracy is statistically significant. Textual information derived from earnings calls markedly improves the prediction of analysts’ expectations and forecast dispersion. Incorporating these linguistic measures provides a statistically significant enhancement in capturing analysts’ beliefs, beyond what can be explained by traditional quantitative predictors. These results suggest that linguistic content from managerial disclosures provides incremental information beyond traditional quantitative fundamentals, capturing nuanced aspects of firm communication that complement established information sources in the analysts’ forecast formation process. The second contribution of this paper is to identify which narratives of corporate communication are most influential in shaping analysts’ beliefs, and whether these same features predict subsequent realized earnings. Estimating what causes particular analysts’ reactions would, in an ideal world, require rerunning the same earnings call while varying only one clearly identified narrative of the CEO’s remarks—an experiment which is clearly infeasible. Instead, I propose a novel framework that (i) constructs credible counterfactual disclosures: precise, transparent edits (henceforth, morphs) to the CEO’s speech along pre-specified linguistic dimensions; (ii) holds fundamentals and the market’s information set