Understanding the Origin and Dynamical Evolution of the Unique Open Star Cluster Berkeley 20 using FIRE Simulations
Alessa I. Wiggins, Jamie R. Quinn, Micah Oeur, Sarah R. Loebman, Peter M. Frinchaboy, Kathryne J. Daniel, Fiona McCluskey, Jonah M. Otto, Hannah R. Woodward, Elena D’Onghia, Andrew Wetzel, Hanna Parul, Binod Bhattarai, Maximilian Cozzi · 2025
Read Understanding the Origin and Dynamical Evolution of the Unique Open Star Cluster Berkeley 20 using FIRE Simulations by Alessa I. Wiggins, Jamie R. Quinn, Micah Oeur, Sarah R. Loebman, Peter M. Frinchaboy, Kathryne J. Daniel, Fiona McCluskey, Jonah M. Otto, Hannah R. Woodward, Elena D’Onghia, Andrew Wetzel, Hanna Parul, Binod Bhattarai, Maximilian Cozzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14958.txt.
Introduction
Alessa I. Wiggins, Jamie R. Quinn, and twelve co-authors use galaxy simulations to explain the odd orbit of Berkeley 20, an old open star cluster. Open clusters carry a chemical fingerprint and a known age, so their present paths record the Milky Way's past pushes and pulls. Berkeley 20 is unusually distant, metal-poor, and far above the galactic disk for its kind.
In the FIRE-2 simulation suite, the team finds a look-alike cluster and follows its life story. The simulated cluster wanders outward and climbs high above its home disk, much like the real one. Tracing how it got there shows which galactic events can lift a cluster onto such an extreme path.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alessa I. Wiggins, Jamie R. Quinn, Micah Oeur, Sarah R. Loebman, Peter M. Frinchaboy, Kathryne J. Daniel, Fiona McCluskey, Jonah M. Otto, Hannah R. Woodward, Elena D’Onghia, Andrew Wetzel, Hanna Parul, Binod Bhattarai, Maximilian Cozzi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14958
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Understanding the Origin and Dynamical Evolution of the Unique Open Star Cluster Berkeley 20 using FIRE Simulations Alessa I. Wiggins, Jamie R. Quinn, Micah Oeur, Sarah R. Loebman, Peter M. Frinchaboy, Kathryne J. Daniel, Fiona McCluskey, Jonah M. Otto, Hannah R. Woodward, Elena D’Onghia, Andrew Wetzel, Hanna Parul, Binod Bhattarai, Maximilian Cozzi Abstract Open clusters (OCs) act as key probes that can be leveraged to constrain the formation and evolution of the Milky Way (MW)’s disk, as each has a unique chemical fingerprint and well-constrained age. Significant Galactic dynamic interactions can leave imprints on the orbital properties of OCs, allowing us to use the present day properties of long-lived OCs to reconstruct the MW’s dynamic history. To explore these changes, we identify OC analogs in FIRE-2 simulations of MW-mass galaxies. For this work, we focus on one particular FIRE-2 OC, which we identify as an analog to the old, subsolar, distant, and high Galactic latitude MW OC, Berkeley 20. Our simulated OC resides ∼ \sim 6 kpc from the galactic center and ultimately reaches a height | Z max | > 2 |Z_{\mathrm{max}}|>2 kpc from the galactic disk, similar to Berkeley 20. We trace the simulated cluster’s orbital and environmental history, identifying key perturbative episodes, including: (1) an interaction with a gas overdensity in a spiral arm that prompts an outward migration event and (2) a substantial interaction with a Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy-mass satellite that causes significant orbital modification. Our simulated OC shows significant resilience to disruption during both its outward migration and the satellite-driven heating event that causes subsequent inward migration. Ultimately, we find these two key processes — migration and satellite heating — are essential to include when assessing OC orbital dynamics in the era of Gaia. show][email protected] I Introduction Open clusters (OCs) are vital tracers of local star formation in nearby galaxies ( 29 , e.g.,) and provide critical constraints on the structure and evolution of the Milky Way (MW)’s disk ( 17 ; 44 , e.g.,) . Large-scale astrometric and spectroscopic surveys like Gaia ( 13 ) and APOGEE ( 28 ) have enabled increasingly complete OC samples with well-determined positions, kinematics, ages, and chemical abundances ( 9 ; 33 ; 23 , e.g.,) . This wealth of precise data has transformed our ability to identify and study outlier clusters with atypical chemistry, orbits, or ages relative to their position in the disk ( 10 , e.g.,) . Such rare systems offer a unique perspective into the MW’s dynamic history. One such cluster is Berkeley 20 (Be20), a long-known but increasingly compelling outlier. Originally identified as an unusual system by 27 , Be20 is an old ( 9 , 4.79 Gyr;) , distant ( 9 , Galactocentric radius of 16.32 kpc;) OC with subsolar metallicity ([Fe/H] \approx-0.42 dex; 10 ; 33 ), and an extreme vertical position, currently located 2.61 kpc below the Galactic midplane ( 9 ) . Orbit integrations using Gala ( 35 , version 1.9.1, with MW potential 2022;) calculate the mean angular momentum of the orbit and yield a guiding radius 1 1 1 Guiding radius is defined here as the radius of circular orbit with the same angular momentum. of 15.16 kpc. These results also indicate that the cluster is currently at its maximum vertical excursion ( 33 ; 34 ) . Kinematic measurements further support Be20’s status as a dynamic outlier. 19 identified six members with radial velocities of +70\pm 13 km s -1 , consistent with the values reported by 20 , and more recently, 33 measured an RV of +76.6\pm 0.2 km s -1 using APOGEE data. Early orbit reconstructions by 51 found Be20 to have a highly eccentric, vertically extended orbit, characteristics they interpreted as evidence for thick disk membership. 46 proposed an alternative scenario, suggesting the orbit might point to an extragalactic origin. However, more precise Gaia proper motions have enabled updated orbital integrations, which reveal a significantly lower eccentricity of 0.087 and relatively regular orbital parameters with an average vertical oscillation period of 374 Myr and a radial period of 323 Myr ( 33 ; 34 ) . In fact, despite its large vertical displacement, Be20 appears to follow a nearly circular orbit. High resolution spectroscopic analysis by 10 suggests that the cluster may be a perturbed thin disk object or a genuine thick disk system influenced by accretion-driven dynamics. They emphasize that Be20’s origin remains deeply uncertain and merits substantive investigation. Notably, in the era of Gaia , the MW’s disk is increasingly understood as a dynamically evolving structure shaped by both internal and external interactions. Stars, and presumably gravitationally bound OCs, can be redistributed across the disk through resonant interactions with internal structures such as a bar or spiral arms. A process, colloquially known as radial migration ( 16 , also known as and henceforth referred to as cold torquing,) , causes stars and clusters to have large changes in their mean orbital radii without significant changes in their orbital eccentricity ( 43 ) . Cold torquing specifically occurs at the corotation radius of transient spirals. However, other resonances from both spirals and bars ( 5 ; 11 , e.g.,) and overlapping resonances ( 31 ; 14 ) change orbital radii but also kinematically heat. Satellite interactions and mergers are also known to vertically heat orbits ( 40 ; 8 , e.g.,) ; additionally, scattering by GMCs ( 45 , e.g.,) can convert in-plane motions to vertical excursions ( 25 , e.g,) . The impact of each of these mechanisms has been explored both in isolation, especially in controlled experiments and idealized models ( 42 ; 15 ; 38 , e.g.,) , and in cosmological simulations, which have examined the impact of spiral structure and bars on vertical heating ( 21 , e.g.,) . However, cosmological hydrodynamic simulations have yet to provide a comprehensive, orbit-level connection between large scale structures, like spiral features, and individual stellar and OC trajectories. Among the most significant of the external perturbations for the MW is the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy (Sgr dSph), which has likely completed several pericentric passages on a near polar orbit over the last 6–8 Gyr ( 36 ; 26 ; 4 ) . These events have been shown to trigger warps, vertical oscillations, spiral structure, and broad-scale radial migration. Simulations by 36 and 26 demonstrate that repeated Sgr dSph passages can excite bending and breathing modes, drive phase-space spirals, and redistribute stars throughout the disk ( 3 ) . Recent work by 12 using a collisionless N -body simulation highlights how such interactions displace stars from near-circular orbits, altering guiding centers and eccentricities in a coherent, quadrupole pattern. While these studies underscore the disk-wide dynamic consequences of satellite interactions, the long-term survival and migratory history of individual OCs in this cosmological context remains unexplored. In this work, we use high-resolution hydrodynamic cosmological simulations that self-consistently form OCs and follow their orbital evolution over time. In particular, we follow one such cluster that migrates outward, directly experiences satellite-driven perturbations, then migrates inward and ultimately survives to the present day. This approach offers a new window into how complex interactions shape the orbital evolution of clusters like Be20. II Methods Table 1: Comparison of