Proton specific entropy as a proxy for the O 7 + / O 6 + \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} charge state ratio over heliocentric distance
Jack D. Collard, Tamar Ervin, Ryan M. Dewey, Yeimy J. Rivera, Aidan J. Nakhleh, Jean-Baptiste Dakeyo, Samuel T. Badman, Trevor A. Bowen, John W. Bonnell, Nicholeen M. Viall, Susan T. Lepri, Jim M. Raines, Stuart D. Bale · 2025
Read Proton specific entropy as a proxy for the O 7 + / O 6 + \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} charge state ratio over heliocentric distance by Jack D. Collard, Tamar Ervin, Ryan M. Dewey, Yeimy J. Rivera, Aidan J. Nakhleh, Jean-Baptiste Dakeyo, Samuel T. Badman, Trevor A. Bowen, John W. Bonnell, Nicholeen M. Viall, Susan T. Lepri, Jim M. Raines, Stuart D. Bale (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14938.txt.
Introduction
Jack Collard and twelve co-authors test proton specific entropy as a proxy for a key solar wind composition ratio. The slow solar wind source remains uncertain, unlike the fast wind from coronal holes. Oxygen charge state ratios freeze in near the Sun and reveal source regions. Direct heavy ion measures were once limited to far distances.
Solar Orbiter data now cover the inner heliosphere from near the Sun outward. The team confirm a strong anti correlation between entropy and the oxygen ratio across that range. They also separate fast, slow, and slow Alfvénic wind by entropy traits. The proxy extends composition inference where direct measures are sparse.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jack D. Collard, Tamar Ervin, Ryan M. Dewey, Yeimy J. Rivera, Aidan J. Nakhleh, Jean-Baptiste Dakeyo, Samuel T. Badman, Trevor A. Bowen, John W. Bonnell, Nicholeen M. Viall, Susan T. Lepri, Jim M. Raines, Stuart D. Bale |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14938
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Proton specific entropy as a proxy for the O 7 + / O 6 + \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} charge state ratio over heliocentric distance Jack D. Collard, Tamar Ervin, Ryan M. Dewey, Yeimy J. Rivera, Aidan J. Nakhleh, Jean-Baptiste Dakeyo, Samuel T. Badman, Trevor A. Bowen, John W. Bonnell, Nicholeen M. Viall, Susan T. Lepri, Jim M. Raines, Stuart D. Bale Abstract While the fast solar wind has well-established origins in coronal holes, the source of the slow solar wind remains uncertain. Compositional metrics, such as heavy ion charge state ratios are set in the lower corona, providing insights into solar wind source regions. However, prior to the launch of Solar Orbiter, in situ measurements of heavy ion charge state were limited to distances of 1 AU and beyond. We investigate proton specific entropy as a proxy for the oxygen charge state ratio ( O 7 + / O 6 + \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} ),which generally becomes frozen-in below ∼ \sim 1.8 R ⊙ \mathrm{R_{\odot}} , leveraging observations from Solar Orbiter’s Heavy Ion Sensor and Proton and Alphas Sensor covering 0.28 to 1 AU. Our analysis confirms a strong anti-correlation between specific entropy and the oxygen charge state ratio that persists over a broad range of distances in the inner heliosphere. We categorize observed solar wind into fast solar wind, slow Alfvénic solar wind, and slow solar wind, identifying clear distinctions in specific entropy values and charge state ratios across these types. The work demonstrates the potential to use proton specific entropy as a classifier of solar wind source regions throughout the heliosphere. By establishing the S p \mathrm{S_{p}} - O 7 + / O 6 + \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} relationship and quantifying its radial dependence, the specific entropy can be used as a quantity to identify the solar wind source region in the absence of in-situ charge state measurements. This motivates future studies as to the applicability of this proxy to near-Sun observations (such as Parker Solar Probe) and throughout the inner heliosphere. Astropy [ 7 , 5 , 6 ] , heliopy [ 53 ] , matplotlib [ 29 ] , numpy [ 25 ] , pandas [ 37 ] , pySPEDAS [ 2 ] , scipy [ 56 ] , spiceypy [ 3 ] , SunPy [ 14 ] I Introduction The solar wind is comprised of streams of charged particles, composed of protons, electrons, alpha particles, and traces of heavy ions, that are continuously escaping from the corona [ 46 ] and flowing supersonically through the heliosphere. While the fast solar wind (FSW; speeds above 500 \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} at 1 AU), has been shown to emerge from coronal holes [ 36 , 35 , CHs;] , it is still uncertain as to the contribution of different structures to the slow solar wind [ 55 ] . Identifying the source of the slow solar wind is a complex problem, due to various difficulties with combining models, observations and theory. Compositional metrics, such as heavy ion charge state ratios and elemental abundances, have been found to be a potential tracer of the solar wind’s source region(s) which could help distinguish the different sources contributing to the slow wind [ 57 , 52 , 20 , 49 , e.g.] . Heavy ion charge states measured in the solar wind at large heliocentric distances are related to their solar sources (coronal hole, quiet Sun, active region) through their relative densities which can reflect the thermal structure of their coronal origins. While the elemental composition measured in the heliosphere (specifically the degree to which the first ionization potential bias is observed) is broadly governed by the magnetic topology and wave activity of the solar wind’s coronal source. In the solar wind, ion charge state ratios remain constant after some radial distance from the Sun, due to the so-called ‘freeze-in’ process [ 28 , 42 ] . As the solar wind moves outward from the Sun, the electron density and temperature decrease until it reaches a point, the ‘freeze-in’ point, where ionization and recombination can no longer occur and the ion abundance ratios remain fixed after this distance [ 43 ] . The freeze-in point is low in the corona, typically <1.8 \mathrm{R_{\odot}} , as shown by observations and modeling [ 31 , 9 , 24 , 54 , 48 ] . This process allows the use of these quantities to determine information about the coronal plasma from where the solar wind emerges [ 11 , 13 ] . The variability in the timescale associated with ionization and recombination processes is a consequence of changing solar wind conditions up to their freeze-in altitude as well as among solar sources that ultimately leads to differences in heavy ion ratios measured in-situ. These ratios contain information about the thermodynamic history of the plasma parcel specific to its source which can be used as tracers of lower coronal origin. It has been established that fast solar wind (FSW) streams, originating in CHs, show ion composition ratios (e.g. \mathrm{C^{6+}/C^{5+},C^{6+}/C^{4+},O^{7+}/O^{6+}} etc.) that are lower, consistent with quick acceleration of plasma from cooler, lower density coronal hole structures [ 22 , 17 , 58 , 20 ] . In comparison, the slow solar wind (SSW) often has largely varying charge state ratios that have been related to varied coronal source regions [ 47 , 10 , 32 , 15 ] . Total elemental composition (e.g. the amount of Fe or O or C) is also dependent upon the solar wind source structure. Solar wind parcels that emerged quickly (e.g. on open field lines) have elemental abundances that are similar to photospheric levels, while wind that spent time in topologically closed regions show enhancements in low-FIP (First Ionization Potential) elements. The processes that lead to the fractionation of the plasma, and thus differences in elemental abundances, are also thought to take place in the chromosphere, where the plasma is only partially ionized, and lower corona [ 30 , e.g.] , however FIP bias measurements will not be the focus of this work. While composition has been shown to be an excellent identified of source regions, transport processes and stream interactions that develop between the low corona and where it has been historically measured (near 1 AU) can make interpretations difficult. Ideally, one would want to sample the charges states closer to their solar sources where they can be more accurately connected to the places they were formed, thus eliminating much of its evolution as a factor in disentangling source region signatures. In particular, Parker Solar Probe [ 23 , PSP;] , while reaching distances very close to the Sun, lacks measurements of heavy ion charge states (such as \mathrm{O^{7+}/O^{6+}} ) in the ambient wind, a critical piece to building a full picture of the lower coronal source regions of the solar wind, as the composition and plasma parameters of the SSW are generally more variable compared to the FSW, making it more difficult to distinguish and trace the SSW to its (variable) source(s). These compositional measurements are also difficult to make, due to challenges with spacecraft mass budgets (among other factors) and there are limited observations in the near-Sun environment. It is therefore of interest to find proxies for the oxygen charge state ratio (