Rheology of dense vibrated granular flows: non-monotonic response controlled by granular temperature

A. Plati, G. Petrillo, L. de Arcangelis, A. Gnoli, A. Puglisi, A. Sarracino, E. Lippiello · 2025

Read Rheology of dense vibrated granular flows: non-monotonic response controlled by granular temperature by A. Plati, G. Petrillo, L. de Arcangelis, A. Gnoli, A. Puglisi, A. Sarracino, E. Lippiello (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14859.txt.

Introduction

A. Plati, G. Petrillo, and five co-authors study how dense granular material flows when it is shaken from below. Sand-like flows under vibration matter for handling powders and grains, yet their effective thickness has resisted simple rules. The team simulates a stress-driven vane turning inside a vibrated grain bed.

The flow thickens as the confining pressure rises and thins as shaking grows stronger. Frequency behaves in a trickier way: mid-range shaking weakens the flow most, while very fast shaking loses that benefit. The pattern is explained by a balance between the jiggle energy fed to the grains and the squeeze that holds them down. That balance unifies older, conflicting reports on vibrated grains.

Catalog record

CREATORA. Plati, G. Petrillo, L. de Arcangelis, A. Gnoli, A. Puglisi, A. Sarracino, E. Lippiello
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14859

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rheology of dense vibrated granular flows: non-monotonic response controlled by granular temperature A. Plati, G. Petrillo, L. de Arcangelis, A. Gnoli, A. Puglisi, A. Sarracino, E. Lippiello Abstract We study the rheology of dense granular materials subjected to vertical vibration using numerical simulations of a stress-imposed vane rheometer. The effective viscosity increases with confining pressure, decreases with vibration amplitude, and exhibits a non-monotonic dependence on frequency: weakening is observed at intermediate frequencies but is lost at high frequencies. We show that the rheological response is governed by the balance between grain-scale agitation energy and the stabilizing effect of confinement. This framework reconciles previously observed trends in viscosity and friction weakening and emphasizes the central role of energy injection and dissipation in determining granular flow properties under vibration. I Introduction Granular materials are ubiquitous in natural environment and applications 2 ; 29 . Depending on the external forcing, they can exhibit both solid-like or fluid-like behaviour 22 ; 14 . The rheology of granular materials in shear cells or flowing over inclined planes has been extensively investigated 3 ; 23 ; 16 ; 9 ; 5 ; 15 ; 11 . At the same time, the role of vibration in determining granular flow properties has been highlighted in several theoretical, numerical and experimental studies 25 ; 12 ; 32 ; 18 ; 20 ; 19 ; 24 ; 27 ; 6 ; 21 ; 13 . External vibrations usually increase the flowability of a granular system and this can have dramatic consequences as in the case of earthquake-triggered landslides 17 ; 24 or can be exploited to facilitate the manipulation of granular systems in applications 31 . In laboratory experiments, vertical vibration is known to reduce to zero the yield stress and produce non-monotonic flow curves 12 . It may also induce a transition from thinning to collisional thickening 20 . The general setting for experiments or simulations to probe the rheology of granular materials under sinusoidal vibration considers the role of three main parameters: the vibration amplitude A , the vibration frequency f and the confining pressure p . Depending on the specific setup, different quantities can be used as proxies of the “resistance to flow” of the granular system. When the shear rate \dot{\gamma} is imposed, one usually measures the macroscopic friction coefficient \mu=\tau/p where \tau is the resulting shear stress. Conversely, if the shear stress is imposed, the flow is characterized by the effective viscosity \eta=\tau/\dot{\gamma} . Non-vibrated granular systems have been extensively studied by focusing on the so-called flow curves \mu(\dot{\gamma}) and \eta(\tau) 15 ; 16 ; 8 , however - when vibrations are taken into account - the goal is to characterize the flowability of the material either through \mu(\dot{\gamma},A,f,p) or \eta(\tau,A,f,p) . To restrict the parameter space, it is sometime useful to consider \dot{\gamma} and \tau fixed, focusing on \mu(A,f,p) and \eta(A,f,p) . In recent years, many experimental and numerical observations on these quantities have been reported 19 ; 27 ; 6 ; 21 . In Ref. 19 , the effective viscosity of a dense, weakly fluidized granular system was investigated experimentally and numerically by varying the driving amplitude A and frequency f under a fixed confining load. It was found that \eta decreases monotonically with A , whereas its dependence on f is non-monotonic: the viscosity decreases until a minimum at a frequency f^{*} that shifts to lower values as the dissipative properties of the medium increase. A subsequent work 27 showed that these trends are linked to the behavior of the average kinetic energy of the system (i.e. the granular temperature, see Sec. II A for its definition), which exhibits a maximum at f^{*} . In Fig. 1 , we show the granular temperature as a function of f and A obtained extending the numerical dataset of Ref. 27 . It increases monotonically with A when the frequency is fixed and exhibits a non-monotonic trend with f when the amplitude is fixed, which correlates with the behavior of the effective viscosity obtained in experiments 19 . These results suggest that rheology is primarily controlled by the efficiency with which the medium absorbs energy from external vibration. As discussed in 27 , while the non-monotonic dependence on f resembles a resonance phenomenon, the fact that f^{*} depends on dissipation rules out a standard resonance, in which the peak position is fixed by the elastic properties of the system. The proposed interpretation instead attributes the non-monotonicity to the competition between the energy injected by the vibration mechanism, and the dissipation rate of the medium (which is related to the grain-grain collision rate). Indeed, both these competing effects are enhanced by the driving frequency, producing a non-monotonic trend. Figure 1: Granular temperature as a function of the oscillation amplitude A and frequency f . The granular temperature increases monotonically as a function of A at any fixed frequency. Meanwhile, for any fixed value of A , it exhibits a non-monotonic behavior, reaching a maximum at an intermediate frequency. This plot is obtained by extending the numerical results of Ref. 27 to a broader range of A and f values. More recently, Clark et al. 6 examined the friction coefficient \mu(A,f,p) and observed a similar non-monotonic trend with frequency. However, rather than focusing on the frequency dependence, they analysed the behavior of the minimum friction coefficient \mu_{\min}(A,p) which was found to be controlled by the variable A^{2}/p . This scaling was motivated by the idea that friction weakening requires vibration amplitudes large enough to disrupt the underlying force network: while shaking at sufficiently high acceleration is enough to break individual contacts, an additional threshold in A^{2}/p is necessary to destabilize mesoscale structures such as force chains. In our study we go beyond this interpretation, based on the evidence that, regardless of whether the thresholds in shaking acceleration and A^{2}/p are exceeded, friction weakening is always lost at sufficiently high f . Following the interpretation of 27 , we highlight that the driving frequency governs the efficiency of energy transfer into the granular medium, which in turn controls the system’s rheological properties. The centrality of energy transfer has also been evidenced in more recent studies, focusing on local rheological responses 21 . We therefore emphasize that any comprehensive description of friction weakening must include a detailed analysis of a wider frequency range. In this article, we build on these findings to provide a unified framework for understanding the interplay between dissipation, energy injection, and rheological response in realistic vibrated granular systems. In Sec. II we describe our numerical setup which is a realistic in silico reproduction of the experimental system for vane rheometry studied in 19 ; 27 . In the same section we also provide an overview of the rheological response for different shaking parameters and confining pressures. This is done by discussing the behavior of the effective viscosity \eta(A,f,p) . This analysis is complemented by the introduction of a minimal model (detailed in Appendix C ), which accounts for the combined effect of shaking amplitude and confining pressure. In Sec. III , we show that the key variable controlling \eta involves the ratio between the average kinetic energy of the grains and the confining pressure. There

Read the complete text