Delayed Wind Onset in Pa 30, the Remnant of Type Iax SN 1181
Takatoshi Ko, Ryosuke Hirai, Taiga Sasaoka, Toshikazu Shigeyama · 2025
Read Delayed Wind Onset in Pa 30, the Remnant of Type Iax SN 1181 by Takatoshi Ko, Ryosuke Hirai, Taiga Sasaoka, Toshikazu Shigeyama (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14829.txt.
Introduction
Takatoshi Ko, Ryosuke Hirai, Taiga Sasaoka, and Toshikazu Shigeyama explain a puzzle in Pa 30, the leftover cloud of a supernova seen in the year 1181. A fast wind blows from the central white dwarf and slams into surrounding material, lighting a shock front. The size of that shocked region says the wind began centuries after the explosion, not right away.
The team proposes that fallen-back carbon-rich debris slowly gathered on the dwarf and ignited late, switching the wind on. Matching a delay of several centuries requires a fairly hot core left over from the blast. The result supports the picture of Pa 30 as a rare Type Iax remnant with a surviving star.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Takatoshi Ko, Ryosuke Hirai, Taiga Sasaoka, Toshikazu Shigeyama |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14829
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Delayed Wind Onset in Pa 30, the Remnant of Type Iax SN 1181 Takatoshi Ko, Ryosuke Hirai, Taiga Sasaoka, Toshikazu Shigeyama Abstract Pa 30 is the recently identified remnant of the historical supernova SN 1181, likely a Type Iax event, and a nebula surrounding the central white dwarf launching a fast wind ( ∼ 10 9 cm s − 1 \sim 10^{9}~\mathrm{cm}~\mathrm{s}^{-1} ) is observed in optical and infrared bands. X-ray observations show that this wind collides with the surrounding material and produces a termination shock, and the observed extent of the shock indicates that the wind started blowing centuries after 1181 A.D. rather than immediately after the SN explosion. We propose that the wind is triggered by delayed ignition of fallback carbon-rich material on the WD surface and investigate the conditions that reproduce such delayed ignition. We show that producing delays of several centuries requires a relatively hot post-explosion WD core with a temperature T c ≃ 6 × 10 8 K T_{c}\simeq 6\times 10^{8}~\mathrm{K} . This supports the pure-deflagration progenitor scenario for Type Iax SN 1181, which implies the presence of a He star companion inside Pa 30; we also discuss why such a potential He star has not been detected and its prospects for discovery by future observations. \Received \Accepted \KeyWords supernovae: individual (SN 1181) — supernovae: general — white dwarfs — accretion — hydrodynamics 1 Introduction Since ancient times, supernovae (SNe) have been recorded in historical documents across the world, occurring roughly once every few centuries at distances close enough to be visible to the naked eye. Their remnants (historical SNRs) have therefore been studied extensively. SN 1006 is the brightest historical event; SN 1054 is identified with the Crab Nebula, a prototypical pulsar-wind nebula; SN 1572 is known as Tycho’s SN; and SN 1604 as Kepler’s SN. Owing to their brightness, these remnants have been recognized and investigated since the 1920s–1930s (see [ 9 ] , for a review). Among historical SNRs, the most recent identification concerns the SN recorded in 1181. 37 reported the infrared nebula Pa 30 (also IRAS 00500+6713) roughly in the location of the historical SN, and from its expansion velocity ( \sim 1000~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} ) and size ( \sim 1 pc) inferred an age of \sim 1000 yr, making Pa 30 the leading candidate counterpart to the SN 1181 remnant. At its center lies a peculiar object that drives an optically thick wind with a terminal velocity \sim 1.5\times 10^{4}~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} and a mass-loss rate of \sim 10^{-6}~M_{\odot}~\mathrm{yr^{-1}} , as inferred from optical spectra ( 10 ; 25 ) . The photospheric composition, combined with the wind velocity, suggests that an oxygen–neon (ONe) white dwarf (WD) ( 10 ; 17 ; 25 ) exists inside. Historical records indicate that SN 1181 reached a brightness comparable to Saturn, implying a peak absolute magnitude of roughly -14 to -12.5 ( 37 ) 1 1 1 This estimate is based on a Japanese record Azumakagami , and is independently supported by an Arabic poem that describe ”a new bright star” appears in 1181 to 1182 A.D. in Cassiopeia brighter than any fixed star in that constellation ( 7 ) ; the accounts are mutually consistent. . Pa 30 is also observed in X-rays with XMM-Newton and Chandra ( 31 ; 20 ) , and two thermal components are detected. Modeling of its X-ray emission yields an ejecta mass of 0.2 – 0.5~M_{\odot} and an explosion energy of \sim 10^{48}~\mathrm{erg} . These values are consistent with low-energy Type Iax explosions and support the identification of Pa 30 as the SN 1181 remnant ( 20 ) . Type Iax SNe are a subclass of thermonuclear SNe characterized by low peak luminosities (absolute magnitudes \sim-13 to -18 ), slow expansion velocities ( \sim 6000 – 7000~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} at maximum light), and the absence of the near-infrared secondary maximum seen in normal SNe Ia (see 14 , for a review). They are often categorized into “bright” and “faint” groups (see Fig. 1 ). The leading theoretical model invokes a pure-deflagration in a WD: the flame does not transition to a detonation and propagates subsonically, yielding lower explosion energies and typically a bound remnant. Pure-deflagration models of CO WDs reproduce many observed properties of the bright Iax events ( 15 ; 21 ; 6 ; 24 ) , while hybrid CONe WDs can account for bright events and some faint ones ( 22 ; 5 ) . In this framework, the deflagration is triggered by accretion of He-rich material from a He star. HST pre-explosion imaging of the type Iax SN 2012Z revealed a He-rich companion candidate ( 28 ) , and the source persists after the explosion ( 29 ) , consistent with being a surviving donor. However, reproducing the faintest SNe Iax within pure-deflagration models often requires very small ejecta masses, in tension with SN 2021fcg—the faintest Iax yet observed—whose inferred ejecta mass is comparable to that of brighter events ( 16 ) . An alternative channel is an ONe + CO WD merger in which only the CO component detonates, leaving the ONe WD as the remnant ( 18 ) ; this pathway generally does not reproduce light curves and spectra of SNe Iax as well as pure-deflagration models. Moreover, recently identified intermediate-luminosity events such as SN 2019muj ( 2 ; 19 ; 26 ) , SN 2022xlp ( 1 ) , SN 2024pxl ( 42 ; 11 ; 23 ) and SN 2025qe ( 27 ) show features overlapping with those of both the bright and faint groups, suggesting a continuous character rather than two discrete subclasses. Taken together, these considerations keep the progenitor systems of SNe Iax under active discussion. Recent work further argues that in single-degenerate systems a deflagration–detonation transition may often fail, favoring Iax-like, low-energy outcomes over normal SNe Ia ( 30 ) . Clarifying the progenitors of SNe Iax is therefore central to the broader SN Ia progenitor problem. Figure 1: Decline rate \Delta m_{15} versus peak absolute magnitude M for normal SNe Ia and for the “bright” and “faint” subclasses of SNe Iax (reproduced from Fig. 11 of 43 ; filled/open symbols denote r / R ). The red region marks SN 1181; its values are not measured in r/R but inferred from historical visual (naked-eye) estimates: a peak M\simeq-12.5 to -14 mag ( 37 ) . The SN 1181 region is placed on the r/R plane for comparison only. Several recently studied SNe Iax remnants show optically thick winds (e.g., 8 ; 4 ; 40 ), as seen in Pa 30, likely powered by delayed radioactive decays of 56 Ni and 56 Co ( 41 ) . Their characteristic velocities ( \sim 500 – 1000~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} ) are, however, far below the extreme wind inferred for the central WD in Pa 30. To account for this exceptionally fast wind, 17 proposed a model involving a rapidly rotating, strongly magnetized WD that accelerates a carbon-ash outflow where the main energy source is shell carbon burning; the evolutionary pathway to such a configuration has not been systematically explored. In the SN 1181 remnant, the fast wind from the central WD collides with the SN ejecta and produces the termination shock detected