Curve Stitching and Dancing Planets

Frances Herr · 2025

Read Curve Stitching and Dancing Planets by Frances Herr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14828.txt.

Introduction

Frances Herr turns a classic classroom craft into a research question about curves and motion. In curve stitching, straight threads strung between points on a circle trace out a smooth-looking envelope curve. Herr fixes equally spaced points on the circle, picks a multiplier, and joins each point to the point reached by multiplying its label, all modulo the count.

The stitched designs raise a sharp question: what envelope will a given multiplier produce? Herr links the discrete stitch graph to a continuous-time dynamical system and studies it with topological tools. The bridge between a hands-on activity and dynamics gives teachers and students a rare case where a craft pattern can be fully explained.

Catalog record

CREATORFrances Herr
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14828

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Curve Stitching and Dancing Planets Frances Herr Abstract Curve stitching is a classic educational activity where one constructs elegant curves from a family of straight lines. We perform curve stitching around a circle to make a modular stitch graph . Take m m points equally spaced around a circle, choose an integer multiplier a a , and draw a chord from point p p to a ​ p mod m ap\mod m . What design will appear as the envelope of these chords? We connect these discrete objects to a continuous-time dynamical system and apply a topological perspective to understand the answer to this question. 1 Modular Curve Stitching Start by drawing a circle. Carefully place 12 evenly spaced points around the perimeter and label them 0 to 11 . Now, add lines to the picture by following a simple rule: for each point p , draw a line between p and 2p , taking 2p modulo 12 if needed. What design appears? Increase the number of points around the circle and repeat the experiment; can you see the shape emerging? Figure 1 shows the result for 12 points, 30 points, and finally 100 points. Figure 1 : Increasing values for the modulus m with multiplier a=2 . From left to right, m=12,\>30,\>100 . Mary Everest Boole experimented in this same way almost 200 years ago. Around 1840, a young Boole began lacing thread through holes in punched cards, a process she called curve stitching . In her 1909 book, Philosophy and Fun of Algebra [ 1 ] , she recommends this craft for teaching geometry to children. Thanks to Boole, in the 21 {}^{\text{st}} century geometry classroom, many children enjoy the same surprise that we saw in Figure 1 : an elegant curve appears from carefully drawn straight lines! This kind of drawing may already be familiar to the reader. Such objects appear throughout recreational mathematics and go by many names— “string art”, “light caustics”, or “spirographs”, to name a few. One popular appearance is in a YouTube video by the channel Mathologer , “Times Tables, Mandelbrot, and the Heart of Mathematics” [ 8 ] . We will call these objects modular stitch graphs to honor Boole’s influence in this history. Given a positive integer m (the modulus ) and another integer a (the multiplier ), we define the modular stitch graph \MMT(m,a) to be a discrete set of directed chords in the circle. For m evenly spaced points around the circle labeled 0 through m-1 , connect p to ap\mod m with a directed chord. Then \MMT(m,a) is the set of all these chords. Although a can be any integer, note that \MMT(m,a_{1}) and \MMT(m,a_{2}) have the same set of chords if a_{1}\equiv a_{2}\mod{m} . Hence, we typically choose multipliers a with 0\leq a<m . Big Question. Given values for m and a , what design will \MMT(m,a) create? Before reading on, I encourage the reader to explore these objects for themselves. It only takes a little experimenting to stumble upon the zoo of designs showcased in Figure 2 . To generate these pictures, I recommend a tool by Mathias Lengler [ 7 ] . My own code to draw these objects is available online [ 5 ] . (a) \MMT(200,21) (b) \MMT(50,25) (c) \MMT(100,34) (d) \MMT(100,51) (e) \MMT(90,31) (f) \MMT(400,115) (g) \MMT(100,49) (h) \MMT(206,21) Figure 2 : Modular stitch graphs with various values for the modulus m and the multiplier a . 1.1 Some first patterns What do we mean by the “design” of a modular stitch graph? One candidate for a concrete mathematical notion is an envelope . Definition 1.1 (Envelope) . An envelope of a collection of lines L in the plane is a planar curve C such that each \ell\in L is tangent to C at some point. By this definition, a collection of lines can possibly have many envelopes. Sometimes, an envelope curve for a modular stitch graph can strongly resemble its design. Other times, however, it is not a good representation of the graph’s appearance. We can see this phenomenon with some examples. Just like our first experiment, we will fix a small value for the multiplier a and increase the modulus m . When a=2 , we see a heart-shaped curve called a cardioid (Figure 1 ). This cardioid is an envelope of the chords in \MMT(m,2) for all m . Repeating the process with a=3,4,5,\dots , we notice that for large modulus, \MMT(m,a) resembles a curve with a-1 petals between a-1 cusps (Figure 3 ). These curves are called epicycloids ; we will return to them in more detail in the next section. (a) \MMT(200,2) (b) \MMT(200,3) (c) \MMT(200,4) (d) \MMT(200,5) (e) \MMT(200,6) (f) \MMT(200,7) Figure 3 : Modular stitch graphs with modulus 200 and increasing multipliers. Fact 1.2 . The epicycloid with a-1 petals is an envelope for the family of lines in \MMT(m,a) . This fact will follow from a more general statement given later in the paper (Proposition 2.3 ). Assuming this for now, we can ask a more specific version of the Big Question: For a large enough modulus m , is the epicycloid with a-1 petals always a good visual representation for the design of \MMT(m,a) ? Experimenting with small multipliers (approximately less than 20 ), we might be led to believe that the answer is “yes”. But this is a hasty conclusion. Modular stitch graphs with higher multipliers introduce the variety of designs showcased in Figure 2 which are much stranger than the basic curves in Figure 3 . We begin to suspect that the numerical relationship between m and a plays a key role in determining the design. Question 1 . The three families of tables \MMT(2a,a) , \MMT(2a-2,a) , and \MMT(2a+2,a) each have a representative in Figure 2 . Can you explain why these designs appear? Remark 1.3 . Although it is often useful to think about modular stitch graphs as combinatorial objects, it will also be helpful for our purposes to define them geometrically. Parameterize the unit circle in \mathbb{C} by e^{2\pi it} for t\in[0,1] . Then \MMT(m,a) is the set of chords with initial point e^{2\pi it_{k}} and terminal point e^{2\pi iat_{k}} with t_{k}=\frac{k}{m} for all k\in\{0,\dots,m-1\} . 1.2 Envelopes An epicycloid is a curve given by rolling one circle on the outside of another fixed circle and tracking a point on the boundary of the outer circle. To construct the epicycloid with a-1 petals, take the moving circle to have radius \frac{1}{a+1} and the fixed circle to have radius \frac{a-1}{a+1} . See Figure 4 . Figure 4 : Constructing an epicycloid and a hypocycloid by rolling circles. (left) This epicycloid is formed by a circle of radius \frac{1}{5} rolling outside a circle of radius \frac{3}{5} . (right) This hypocycloid is formed by a circle of radius \frac{4}{3} rolling inside a circle of radius \frac{5}{3} . A hypocycloid is similar to an epicycloid but the rolling circle is on the inside of the fixed circle. We can realize both these curves with the following parametric equations. \displaystyle\begin{split}x(t)&=\frac{\alpha\cos(\beta t)+\beta\cos(\alpha t)}{\alpha+\beta}\\ y(t)&=\frac{\alpha\sin(\beta t)+\beta\sin(\alpha t)}{\alpha+\beta}\end{split} (1) If \alpha and \beta are both positive real numbers, then equations ( 1 ) describe an epicycloid.

Read the complete text