Observation of critical scaling in the Bose gas universality class
Leon Kleebank, Frank Vewinger, Arturo Camacho-Guardian, Victor Romero-Rochín, Rosario Paredes, Martin Weitz, Julian Schmitt · 2025
Read Observation of critical scaling in the Bose gas universality class by Leon Kleebank, Frank Vewinger, Arturo Camacho-Guardian, Victor Romero-Rochín, Rosario Paredes, Martin Weitz, Julian Schmitt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14754.txt.
Introduction
Leon Kleebank, Frank Vewinger, and five co-authors report the first observed critical scaling for the ideal Bose gas class of phase changes. Near a phase transition, key quantities blow up in patterns set by the system's universality class. Interacting quantum gases share the XY model class, but theory predicts a noninteracting Bose gas forms a class of its own.
The team studies a two-dimensional gas of photons that barely interact, held in a microcavity and cooled through contact with a dye reservoir. By measuring how correlations stretch near the condensation point, they extract the key exponent. The value tests a long-standing prediction that had never met an experiment before.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Leon Kleebank, Frank Vewinger, Arturo Camacho-Guardian, Victor Romero-Rochín, Rosario Paredes, Martin Weitz, Julian Schmitt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14754
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Observation of critical scaling in the Bose gas universality class Leon Kleebank, Frank Vewinger, Arturo Camacho-Guardian, Victor Romero-Rochín, Rosario Paredes, Martin Weitz, Julian Schmitt Abstract Critical exponents characterize the divergent scaling of thermodynamic quantities near phase transitions and allow for the classification of physical systems into universality classes. While quantum gases thermalizing by interparticle interactions fall into the XY model universality class, the ideal Bose gas has been predicted to form a distinct universality class whose signatures have not yet been revealed experimentally. Here, we report the observation of critical scaling in a two-dimensional quantum gas of essentially noninteracting photons, which thermalize by radiative contact to a reservoir of molecules inside a microcavity. By measuring the spatial correlations near the condensation transition, we determine the critical exponent for the correlation length to be ν = 0.52 ( 3 ) \nu=0.52(3) . Our results constitute a first experimental test of the long-standing scaling predictions for the Bose gas universality class. Phase transitions play a pivotal role in nature, from quark-gluon plasmas inside nuclei, over superconductors in solid-state materials, to the formation of the early universe in cosmology 45 ; 53 ; 20 . Near the phase transition at a critical temperature T_{\text{c}} , where the thermodynamic state variables ( e.g. , pressure or density) change continuously upon varying the temperature T , the response of the system to external parameter variations ( e.g. , specific heat or compressibility) is drastically amplified. Large, correlated fluctuations of the order parameter occur, causing a divergence of the correlation length \xi\sim t^{-\nu} (1) as a function of the reduced temperature t=(T-T_{\text{c}})/T_{\text{c}} with a certain critical exponent \nu 25 . Such critical behavior is seen, for example, as critical opalescence in classical gas-liquid mixtures 58 , or near the phase transition to superfluids in liquid helium 34 ; 42 , ultracold atoms 39 ; 26 ; 32 ; 9 , or exciton-polaritons 2 ; 14 . As the correlation length \xi diverges at the phase transition ( i.e. , at t=0 ), intrinsic length scales of the system cease to be relevant. Phase transitions in this way reveal universal similarities between systems, which may be very different at the microscopic scale ( e.g. , superfluids and spin systems). Theoretically, it has been established that all systems within the same universality class display identical sets of critical exponents and scaling functions 18 ; 28 ; 12 , with renormalization group methods providing their calculation from first principles 55 . Experimental studies have confirmed these predictions for interacting quantum many-body systems. For example, measurements of the critical exponent for the correlation length of \nu=0.67(13) in ultracold atomic gases near the Bose-Einstein condensation phase transition 9 ; 39 , or determinations of the specific heat in superfluid helium and high- T_{\text{c}} superconductors 34 ; 42 ; 41 , show good agreement with theory and firmly establish these systems as belonging to the XY universality class 6 . Remarkably, the ideal Bose gas of noninteracting particles, which was the system originally considered by Einstein in his proposal paper on Bose-Einstein condensation 11 , forms a distinct universality class, characterized by critical exponents that differ from Landau theory 19 ; 46 ; 50 . In the homogeneous three-dimensional (3D) gas, for instance, one expects an algebraic divergence of the correlation length at T_{\text{c}} with a critical exponent \nu=1 31 ; 7 ; 49 ; 44 , which differs from the (beyond-) mean-field results for interacting systems. Yet despite its fundamental importance, an experimental confirmation of these predictions has so far not been reported, largely because quantum gases are never perfectly noninteracting. As the low-temperature behavior of quantum gases depends sensitively on the density of states of low-lying excitations, even weak interactions modify density fluctuations near the critical point 21 , causing these systems to fall into the XY rather than the Bose universality class. Furthermore, critical behavior also depends on dimensionality. In a homogeneous two-dimensional (2D) gas, where condensation is suppressed 36 , only the interaction-driven Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition with an exponential divergence of \xi is expected 22 ; 27 . Notably, 2D Bose-Einstein condensates have been observed in confined systems, specifically, harmonically trapped gases of atoms, exciton-polaritons, and photons 13 ; 29 ; 35 ; 17 ; 3 . Harmonic confinement however comes at the cost of an inhomogeneous density which limits systematic studies of \xi . The more recent realizations of Bose-Einstein condensates in box potentials have opened a promising route to controlled studies of critical phenomena in samples with uniform density 39 ; 15 ; 5 ; 8 . In contrast to atomic realizations, where interactions are required for thermalization, optical quantum gases allow one to reach the regime of nearly vanishing interactions. Here we report the observation of critical behavior in a 2D photon gas near the phase transition to a Bose-Einstein condensate. The experiment is carried out in a box trap, where a phase transition in the thermodynamic limit is expected even for a gas with nearly uniform density, as well understood from a theoretical description using a Pöschl-Teller potential. Experimentally, the algebraic divergence of the correlation length obtained upon reaching the critical point provides a demonstration of critical scaling in the 2D Bose gas universality class. This physical setting is realized by harnessing a thermalization mechanism, which occurs by radiative contact to a molecule reservoir inside an optical cavity in the near absence of photon interactions. Our experimental result for the critical exponent for the correlation length of \nu=0.52(3) is in good agreement with theoretical predictions. Furthermore, the measurements illustrate the physical significance of criticality in finite-size systems, thereby contributing to the notion of phase transitions in mesoscopic systems that are still far from the thermodynamic limit 51 ; 16 ; 24 ; 52 . Fig. 1: | Critical behavior in a uniform 2D Bose gas. (A) Experimental system and measurement principle. Photons are trapped and thermalize in a dye-filled microcavity formed by a plane and a nanostructured mirror realizing a nearly uniform 2D Bose gas; the imprint on the mirror forms a confining square shaped box potential. The far-field angular intensity distribution, which corresponds to the photon momentum distribution n_{k}(k_{x},k_{y}) , is related to g^{(1)}(s_{x},s_{y}) by a Fourier transform (see text). (B) Top panel: Horizontal cut through one of the experimentally used trap potentials with depth U_{\mathrm{D}}=1.4k_{\text{B}}T ; the potential energy is calculated from the surface height profile of the mirror. Bottom panel: Zoom-in view on the data in the bottom part of the trap (symbols) shows the slightly softened edges as compared to a rigid box (dashed green line), well described by a Pöschl-Teller potential with \alpha=1.5 (solid black line). (C) Surface density of a quantum degenerate photon gas with phase-space density n\lambda^{2}=4.8(5) in a box of L=$80\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ . (D) First-order correlations g^{(1)}(s_{x}) , for increasing (decreasing) particle number N (reduced temperature t ). The correlation length \xi (red line; see insets) grows algebraically with a critical exponent \nu and diverges at the phase transition. Our 2D quantum gas of photons is created in a dye-filled optical microcavity, see Fig. 1 (A), formed by two highly reflecting dielectric mirrors spaced by D_{0}\approx$1.6\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ , as described in earlier work 5 . Due