Darts Analysis
2025
Read Darts Analysis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14537.txt.
Introduction
Ayham Makhamra, Yelyzaveta Satynska, and Michael Weselcouch compare five math models for predicting amateur darts games. The models forecast the winner at the start and update as the score changes. Data come from games among students, faculty, and staff at Roanoke College. Models range from a score only null model to regression and simulation methods.
A new variant of the Massey model that updates with the live score performs best overall. The team judge models by Brier scores and by head to head betting tests. Checks are done both at game start and at each round start. The score aware Massey approach wins under both evaluation styles.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14537
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Darts Analysis Abstract In this paper we examine the effectiveness of five mathematical models used to predict the outcomes of amateur darts games. These models not only predict the outcomes at the start of the game, but also update their estimations as the game score changes. The models were trained and tested on a dataset consisting of games played by amateur players involving students, faculty, and staff at Roanoke College. The five models are: the null model, which is based only on the live scores, a logistic regression model, a basic simulation model, a time-adjusted simulation model, and a new variation of the Massey model which updates based on the current score. We evaluate these models using two approaches. First, we compare their Brier scores. Second, we conduct head-to-head comparisons in a betting game in which one model sets the betting odds while the other places bets. In both cases, model performance is assessed not only at the start of the game but also at the start of each round. Across both evaluation methods, the score-dependent Massey model performs the best. We conclude by illustrating how this score-dependent Massey model framework can be adapted to other competitive settings beyond darts. \VolumeNo 2 \IssueNo 2 \Year 2021 \addauthor Ayham MakhamraA1 \addauthor Yelyzaveta SatynskaA1 \addauthor *Michael WeselcouchA1 \addlocation 1School of Health, Science, and Sustainability, Roanoke College, Salem, VA keywords darts, linear algebra, simulation, logistic regression, predictive modeling, betting games, simulation modeling, sports analytics 1 Introduction Every spring, the Roanoke College math department hosts a semester-long sports tournament called the Minton Invitational, named after Professor Emeritus and sports enthusiast, Roland Minton. The sport that is played in the Minton Invitational changes from year to year, but there are certain things that have stayed consistent throughout the years. The Minton Invitational is separated into two parts: the regular season and the postseason. The games in the regular season do not follow a set schedule. Players, who can be either students, faculty, or staff, create their own schedule and automatically qualify for the postseason once their first game is recorded. In the postseason, players can still schedule matches freely, but an elimination bracket is also introduced, creating a mix of self-scheduled and bracket-determined matchups. We will not be differentiating between self-scheduled and bracket-determined games in this article. To record the results of the games, a website was created that allows players to submit their scores anytime of the day and night. The purpose of the Minton Invitational is to help build a sense of community between the students, faculty and staff, and to give students a hands-on experience with sports analytics as the datasets created from the Minton Invitational can be used for student research projects. If you need help organizing a tournament at your school, do not hesitate to contact the third author. The game played for the spring 2025 Minton Invitational was a variation of darts, called Darts 271 . 1.1 Darts 271 Darts 271 is played with a traditional dartboard. A dartboard has 20 numbered sectors, plus a bullseye (see Figure 1 ). Each numbered sector contains three sub-regions: the outer ring, the inner ring, and the areas in between. In Figure 1 , the outer ring and inner ring are both colored in red and green. A dart that lands in the outer ring of a numbered sector scores double the number’s value. A dart that lands in the inner ring of the a numbered sector scores triple that number’s value. A dart that lands anywhere else in the numbered sector scores that number’s value. The outer bullseye (colored in green in Figure 1 ) is worth 25 points and the inner bullseye is worth 50 points. Since most players competing in the Minton Invitational have never thrown a dart before, it was not uncommon for a dart to miss the dartboard completely. In that case, the throw results in 0 points. Figure 1 : A traditional dartboard. In a traditional darts game, players compete head-to-head by taking turns throwing three darts each to earn points. In order to win, a player must finish with exactly 501 points with the last dart landing in the outer ring. Darts 271 has a lot of the same rules as traditional darts. Like traditional darts, players compete head-to-head by taking turns throwing three darts to earn points. Once both players throw their three darts, the round ends and the next round begins. A major difference between traditional darts and Darts 271 is that, in Darts 271, the games are played to 271 points and players do not have to score exactly 271 points, they can surpass this value. Additionally, players do not need to end the game by landing in the outer ring. In Darts 271, scores are updated after each round, meaning that the points are tallied after all six darts (three from each player) are thrown. Consequently, it is possible for a game to be tied with both players above the 271 point threshold. In that case, rounds continue to be played until one of the players takes the lead. Unlike innings in a baseball game or ends in a curling match, the number of rounds in a Darts 271 game varies depending on the abilities of the players. If both players have a hard time scoring points, the game can last many rounds. Conversely, a game can have only a few rounds if even just one of the players consistently throws their darts into high value regions. 1.2 Modeling Framework and Evaluation The world of sports analytics has changed a lot in recent years due to the overwhelming presence of sports betting. No longer is it the case that all bets must be placed before the games begin. Many sports books now let you bet during the game and they update the odds based on a number of factors. However, many of the classical sports ranking systems (Massey, Colley, Elo, etc.) are used to compare teams or competitors only at the start of games. For an overview of the classical sports ranking methods, see the fantastic book “Who’s #1?" by [ 6 ] . In this article, we provide five models that estimate the probability of a player winning a Darts 271 game based off two factors: the players involved and the live score of the game. The five models are: the null model which is based only on the live score, a logistic regression model, a basic simulation model, a time-adjusted simulation model, and a score-dependent variation of the Massey model. We evaluate these models using two approaches. First, we compare their Brier scores. Second, we conduct head-to-head comparisons in a betting game in which one model sets the betting odds while the other places bets. Further details on these evaluation methods are provided in Section 2 . In both cases, model performance is assessed not only at the start of the game but also at the start of each round. 1.3 Outline This paper is organized as follows: in Section 2 , we discuss the dataset that we used, summary statistics calculated from the dataset, and the methods used to evaluate the models; in Section 3 , we discuss