Dilation and Model Theory for Pairs of Contractions with a Twisted Commutation Relation

Sourav Ghosh · 2025

Read Dilation and Model Theory for Pairs of Contractions with a Twisted Commutation Relation by Sourav Ghosh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14239.txt.

Introduction

Sourav Ghosh grows a classic tool of operator theory from one operator to a pair. The Sz.-Nagy-Foias theory treats a single contraction, a map that shrinks lengths, by placing it in a larger space where its acts become clear. Ghosh's note builds the same kind of theory for two such maps at once, both their dilation side and their model side.

The pair does not swap order in the plain way. The two maps obey a twisted swap rule, scaled by a phase factor q of length one, a rule called q-commutation. Results in that twisted case widen the known one-map picture. They let the same model tools treat pairs whose swap rule is braided rather than plain.

Catalog record

CREATORSourav Ghosh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE105 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14239

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dilation and Model Theory for Pairs of Contractions with a Twisted Commutation Relation Sourav Ghosh Abstract . In this note, we develop a parallel theory of the classical Sz.-Nagy–Foias dilation and model theory for a single contraction operator in the setting of pairs of q q -commuting contraction operators for a unimodular complex number q q . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 47A13; Secondary: 47A20, 47A25, 47A56, 47A68, 30H10 1. Introduction A celebrated theorem by Sz.-Nagy [ 16 ] states that every contraction on a Hilbert space admits a co-isometric extension. More precisely, for any contraction T acting on a Hilbert space \mathcal{H} , there exists an isometry V acting on a Hilbert space \mathcal{K} that contains \mathcal{H} , such that T^{*}=V^{*}|_{\mathcal{H}} . A similar result for a pair of commuting contractions was provided in a seminal paper by Andô [ 1 ] , which shows that any pair (T_{1},T_{2}) of commuting contractions on a Hilbert space \mathcal{H} has a commuting isometric pair (V_{1},V_{2}) on a Hilbert space {\mathcal{K}} containing {\mathcal{H}} as a co-isometric extension. Although the extension of Andô’s theorem to more than two variables is no longer valid (see [ 14 ] ), it has inspired numerous generalizations across various frameworks. This note is concerned with the extension of Andô’s Theorem in the non-commutative setting. Sebestyén [ 15 ] obtained the first non-commutative generalization of Andô’s theorem, focusing on the anti-commutative case. He showed that if (T_{1},T_{2}) is a contractive pair which is anti-commuting , i.e., T_{1}T_{2}=-T_{2}T_{1} , then there is an anti-commuting isometric lift (V_{1},V_{2}) of (T_{1},T_{2}) . Extending Sebestyén’s work, Keshari and Mallick showed in [ 11 ] that if (T_{1},T_{2}) is a contractive pair which is q -commuting i.e., T_{1}T_{2}=qT_{2}T_{1} for some unimodular complex number q , then there is a q -commuting isometric lift (V_{1},V_{2}) of (T_{1},T_{2}) . However, these dilations are far from canonical, a fact that seems to rule out a coherent model theory. The methods in the works cited above are based on arguments leading to an existential proof. The main contributions of this paper are as follows: (1) We give two constructive proofs of the lifting theorem by Keshari and Mallick with an emphasis on the function-theoretic interpretation. See the forward directions of Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.5 for the explicit constructive proofs. (2) We show by a concrete example (see Example 5.4 ) that a q -commuting contractive pair may have two minimal q -commuting isometric lifts which are not unitarily equivalent. (3) We describe all q -commuting isometric lifts of a given q -commuting contractive pair; See the converse directions of Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.5 for the descriptions in two different models. (4) In what follows, for a contraction operator T acting on a Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}} , we shall denote by D_{T}=(I_{\mathcal{H}}-T^{*}T)^{\frac{1}{2}}\quad\mbox{and}\quad{\mathcal{D}}_{T}=\overline{\operatorname{Ran}D_{T}} the defect operator and the defect space for T , respectively. The explicit functional model of the isometric lifts makes it possible to develop a functional model for pairs of q -commuting contractions. See the results in Section 5 . The functional model has three key components: the Sz.-Nagy–Foias characteristic function \Theta_{T}(z)=-T+zD_{T^{*}}(I-zT^{*})^{-1}D_{T}|_{{\mathcal{D}}_{T}}:{\mathcal{D}}_{T}\to{\mathcal{D}}_{T^{*}} for the product contraction T=T_{1}T_{2}=qT_{2}T_{1} , a q -commuting unitary pair (W_{1},W_{2}) canonically constructed in Subsection 4.1 from a q -commuting contractive pair, and a novel notion of fundamental operators for q -commuting contractive pairs introduced in Subsection 5.3 . These three components constitute what is called a characteristic triple for a q -commuting contractive pair. It is shown in Theorem 5.9 that the characteristic triple serves as a complete unitary invariant for q -commuting contractive pairs whose product is completely non-unitary ( cnu , for short). (5) We then introduce a notion of admissible triple \Xi=((G_{1},G_{2}),(W_{1},W_{2}),\Theta) consisting of an operator pair (G_{1},G_{2}) , a q -commuting unitary pair (W_{1},W_{2}) and a contractive analytic function \Theta so that the characteristic triple for the model q -commuting contractive pair (T_{1,\Xi},T_{2,\Xi}) corresponding to \Xi coincides with the admissible triple \Xi in an appropriate sense. In this way, we arrive at an exact analogue of Sz.-Nagy–Foias model theory for contractive operators in the case of q -commuting contractive pairs. There has been considerable interest in q -commuting operators from various perspectives within operator theory; see, for example, [ 4 ] , [ 12 ] , [ 19 ] . For further developments and generalizations to Q -commuting contractions, where Q is a unitary operator, we refer the reader to [ 5 ] , [ 13 ] , and the references therein. 2. Preliminaries We begin with the preliminaries. Let (T_{1},T_{2}) be a pair of q -commuting contractions on a Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}} , and let T=T_{1}T_{2}=qT_{1}T_{2} . Then we have the following relations among the defect operators: (2.1) \displaystyle D_{T}^{2}=I-T^{*}T \displaystyle=I-T_{2}^{*}T_{2}+T_{2}^{*}T_{2}-T_{2}^{*}T_{1}^{*}T_{1}T_{2}=D_{T_{2}}^{2}+T_{2}^{*}D_{T_{1}}^{2}T_{2} (2.2) \displaystyle=I-T_{1}^{*}T_{1}+T_{1}^{*}T_{1}-T_{1}^{*}T_{2}^{*}T_{2}T_{1}=D_{T_{1}}^{2}+T_{1}^{*}D_{T_{2}}^{2}T_{1}. Then the map \Lambda:\mathcal{D}_{T}\to\mathcal{D}_{T_{1}}\oplus\mathcal{D}_{T_{2}} , defined by (2.3) \displaystyle\Lambda D_{T}h=D_{T_{1}}T_{2}h\oplus D_{T_{2}}h\quad\text{for every }h\in{\mathcal{H}}, is an isometry as \displaystyle\|\Lambda D_{T}h\|^{2}=\|D_{T_{1}}T_{2}h\|^{2}+\|D_{T_{2}}h\|^{2} \displaystyle=\|T_{2}h\|^{2}-\|T_{1}T_{2}h\|^{2}+\|h\|^{2}-\|T_{2}h\|^{2} \displaystyle=\|h\|^{2}-\|Th\|^{2}=\|D_{T}h\|^{2}. Moreover, the map U:\operatorname{Ran}\Lambda\to\mathcal{D}_{T_{1}}\oplus{\mathcal{D}}_{T_{2}} , defined by (2.4) \displaystyle U(D_{T_{1}}T_{2}h\oplus D_{T_{2}}h)=D_{T_{1}}h\oplus D_{T_{2}}T_{1}h\quad\text{for }h\in{\mathcal{H}}, is also an isometry as can be checked by a similar computation. If required, by adding a direct copy of {\mathcal{H}} to {\mathcal{D}}_{T_{1}}\oplus{\mathcal{D}}_{T_{2}} , we can extend U to a unitary operator on {\mathcal{D}}_{T_{1}}\oplus{\mathcal{D}}_{T_{2}}\oplus{\mathcal{H}} , still denoted by U . The isometry and unitary operators defined above will play a pivotal role in what follows. We give them a name for reference. Definition 2.1 . Given a pair of q -commuting contractions (T_{1},T_{2}) on a Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}} , the tuple ({\mathcal{F}};\Lambda,P,U) , as constructed above, is called a special Andô tuple for (T_{1},T_{2}) , where {\mathcal{F}}={\mathcal{D}}_{T_{1}}\oplus{\mathcal{D}}_{T_{2}}\oplus{\mathcal{E}} (with the understanding that {\mathcal{E}} may possible be trivial), \Lambda:{\mathcal{D}}_{T}\to{\mathcal{F}} is the isometry as in ( 2.3 ), U acting on {\mathcal{F}} is the unitary as defined in ( 2.4 ), and P is the orthogonal projection of \mathcal{F} onto the first component, i.e., \mathcal{D}_{T_{1}}\oplus\{0\}\oplus\{0\} . Remark 2.2 . If (T_{1},T_{2}) is a pair of q -commuting operators then so is (T_{1}^{*},T_{2}^{*}) . The special Andô tuple for (T_{1}^{*},T_{2}^{*}) will be denoted by (\mathcal{F}_{*};\Lambda_{*},P_{*},U_{*}) , where \mathcal{F}_{*}=\mathcal{D}_{T_{1}^{*}}\oplus\mathcal{D}_{T_{2}^{*}}\quad\mbox{or}\quad{\mathcal{F}}_{*}=\mathcal{D}_{T_{1}^{*}}\oplus\mathcal{D}_{T_{2}^{*}}\oplus{\mathcal{H}}, \Lambda_{*}:\mathcal{D}_{T^{*}}\to{\mathcal{F}}_{*} is an isometry defined as: \Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}h=D_{T_{1}^{*}}T_{2}^{*}h\oplus D_{T_{2}^{*}}h\oplus 0\quad\mbox{for all }h\in\mathcal{H}, P_{*} is the orthogonal projection of {\mathcal{F}}_{*} onto the first component \mathcal{D}_{T_{1}^{*}}\oplus\{0\}\oplus\{0\} , and with a slight abuse of notation, U_{*} is the unitary extension on {\mathcal{F}}_{*} of the map U_{*}:\operatorname{Ran}\Lambda_{*}\to{\mathcal{F}}_{*} , explicitly defined as: U_{*}(D_{T_{1}^{*}}T_{2}^{*}h\oplus D_{T_{2}^{*}}h\oplus 0)=D_{T_{1}^{*}}h\oplus D_{T_{2}^{*}}T_{1}^{*}h\oplus 0\quad\mbox{for all }h\in\mathcal{H}. For Hilbert spaces {\mathcal{H}} and {\mathcal{K}} , we shall use the direct sum notations {\mathcal{H}}\oplus{\mathcal{K}}\quad\mbox{and}\quad\begin{bmatrix}{\mathcal{H}}\\ {\mathcal{K}}\end{bmatrix} interchangeably; similar convention is used for an element in the direct sum, i.e., for vectors h\in{\mathcal{H}} and k\in{\mathcal{K}} , the notations h\oplus k and \left[\begin{smallmatrix}h\\ k\end{smallmatrix}\right] mean the same vector in the direct sum of {\mathcal{H}} and {\mathcal{K}} . We note some properties of special Andô tuples below which are crucial for later developments. Lemma 2.3 . Let (T_{1},T_{2}) be a q -commuting pair of contractions on {\mathcal{H}} , and ({\mathcal{F}};\Lambda,P,U) and ({\mathcal{F}}_{*};\Lambda_{*},P_{*},U_{*}) be the special Andô tuples for (T_{1},T_{2}) and (T_{1}^{*},T_{2}^{*}) , respectively. Then we have (2.5) \displaystyle\begin{cases}&T_{1}^{*}T_{1}+D_{T}\Lambda^{*}U^{*}PU\Lambda D_{T}=I_{{\mathcal{H}}},\quad T_{2}^{*}T_{2}+D_{T}\Lambda^{*}P^{\perp}\Lambda D_{T}=I_{{\mathcal{H}}}\\ &PU\Lambda D_{T}T_{2}+P^{\perp}\Lambda D_{T}=\Lambda D_{T}=U^{*}(P^{\perp}\Lambda D_{T}T_{1}+PU\Lambda D_{T});\end{cases} and (2.6) \displaystyle\begin{cases}&\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}T_{1}^{*}=P_{*}^{\perp}U_{*}\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}+P_{*}U_{*}\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}T^{*}\\ &\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}T_{2}^{*}=U_{*}^{*}P_{*}\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}+qU_{*}^{*}P_{*}^{\perp}\Lambda_{*}D_{T^{*}}T^{*}.\end{cases} Proof. The first equality in ( 2.5 ) follows from the simple inner product computation for every h,h^{\prime}\in\mathcal{H} : \displaystyle\langle D_{T}\Lambda^{*}U^{*}PU\Lambda D_{T}h,h^{\prime}\rangle=\langle PU\Lambda D_{T}h,PU\Lambda D_{T}h^{\prime}\rangle=\langle D_{T_{1}}h\oplus 0,D_{T_{1}}h^{\prime}\oplus 0\rangle=\langle D_{T_{1}}^{2}h,h^{\prime}\rangle. The second equality in

Read the complete text