Energy-Containing Electrons in Solar Flares: Improving Hard X-Ray and EUV Diagnostics
Yingjie Luo (骆英杰), Eduard P. Kontar, Debesh Bhattacharjee · 2025
Read Energy-Containing Electrons in Solar Flares: Improving Hard X-Ray and EUV Diagnostics by Yingjie Luo (骆英杰), Eduard P. Kontar, Debesh Bhattacharjee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14077.txt.
Introduction
Yingjie Luo, Eduard P. Kontar, and Debesh Bhattacharjee improve estimates of the electrons that carry most of a solar flare's energy. Flares accelerate electrons that then radiate in X-rays, radio, and ultraviolet light. Because the electron spectrum falls steeply, the numerous low-energy electrons dominate the energy budget, yet they are the hardest to measure.
The authors apply a warm-target X-ray model with a kappa-form electron distribution to two well-observed M-class flares, using EUV data to pin down the hot plasma. The model constrains electron properties from a few to tens of kilo-electronvolts, even below the RHESSI instrument's threshold. Results show the approach holds up under uncertainties that earlier studies left unaddressed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yingjie Luo (骆英杰), Eduard P. Kontar, Debesh Bhattacharjee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14077
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Energy-Containing Electrons in Solar Flares: Improving Hard X-Ray and EUV Diagnostics Yingjie Luo (骆英杰), Eduard P. Kontar, Debesh Bhattacharjee Abstract Solar flares effectively accelerate particles to non-thermal energies. These accelerated electrons are responsible for energy transport and subsequent emissions in HXR, radio, and UV/EUV radiation. Due to the steeply decreasing electron spectrum, the electron population and consequently the overall flare energetics, are predominantly influenced by low-energy non-thermal electrons. However, deducing the electron distribution in this energy-containing range remains a significant challenge. In this study, we apply the warm-target HXR emission model with kappa-form injected electrons to two well-observed GOES M-class flares. Moreover, we utilize EUV observations to constrain the flaring plasma properties, which enables us to determine the characteristics of accelerated electrons across a range from a few keV to tens of keV. We demonstrate that the warm-target model reliably constrains the properties of flare-associated electrons, even accounting for the uncertainties that had previously been unaddressed. The application of a kappa distribution for the accelerated electrons allows for meaningful comparisons with electron distributions inferred from EUV observations, specifically for energy ranges below the detection threshold of RHESSI. Our results indicate that the accelerated electrons constitute only a small fraction of the total electron population within the flaring region. Moreover, the physical parameters, such as electron escape time and acceleration time scale, inferred from both the warm-target model and the EUV observations further support the scenario in which electrons undergo thermalization within the corona. This study highlights the effectiveness of integrating the warm-target model with EUV observations to accurately characterize energy-containing electrons and their associated acceleration and transport processes. I Introduction Solar flares are the most explosive energy-release events in the solar system. During solar flares, a massive amount of magnetic energy is converted into kinetic energy, leading to the acceleration of electrons to nonthermal energies ( 47 ; 32 ; 26 ) , and into thermal energy through plasma heating processes ( 17 ; 52 ; 7 ; 58 ; 35 ; 64 ; 56 ) . These energy-containing electrons play a crucial role in the processes of energy release, transport, and transformation during solar flares ( 4 ; 12 ) , and are associated with radiation across multiple wavelengths, including radio, hard X-rays (HXR), and ultraviolet/extreme ultraviolet (UV/EUV) bands ( 29 ; 66 ) . Considering the nonthermal electron spectrum decreases rapidly—typically with a power-law index greater than 4 ( 32 ; 37 ; 59 ) —electrons at relatively low energies play a dominant role in determining the total nonthermal energy budget and are critical for assessing flare energy release mechanisms ( 26 ; 54 ; 39 ) . However, constraining the distribution of these energy-containing electrons, particularly at low energies, remains challenging. A key difficulty lies in the fact that electrons at different energies are best detected using different instruments operating at different wavelengths, creating a diagnostic gap. High-energy nonthermal electrons are primarily observed via hard X-ray (HXR) and radio diagnostics. HXR spectroscopy is particularly effective for determining nonthermal electron distributions, as the bremsstrahlung emission is proportional to electron number density and relatively unaffected by transport effects ( 37 ; 32 ) . Nonetheless, accurately determining the electron distribution in the energy range where thermal emission dominates remains difficult due to instrumental limitations—such as spectral resolution, pile-up effects, and the use of attenuators that affect low-energy response ( 37 ; 63 ) . At lower temperatures, UV/EUV observations, such as those from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly ( 45 , AIA,) on board the Solar Dynamics Observatory ( 57 , SDO,) , are sensitive to thermal plasma below \sim 20 MK. However, these observations are insensitive to high-energy nonthermal electrons and provide limited constraints on suprathermal tails ( 2 ) . Moreover, combining multi-wavelength diagnostics introduces additional complexity due to differences in temporal, spatial, and spectral coverage, making it difficult to reconstruct a complete and continuous electron energy spectrum ( 66 ) . Several studies ( 11 ; 34 ; 53 ; 10 ) have attempted to combine HXR and EUV observations to better constrain electron distributions across a broader energy range. HXR spectral analysis using different emission models, such as isothermal fits, cold-target thick-target bremsstrahlung, and warm-target models, can provide insights into both thermal and nonthermal electron distributions. Meanwhile, multi-channel observations from SDO/AIA enable the reconstruction of the differential emission measure (DEM) as a function of temperature, allowing thermal plasma diagnostics in the range of approximately 0.1 to 20 MK ( 15 ; 2 ) through various inversion algorithms ( 31 ; 22 ) . 11 compared the mean electron flux spectra derived independently from Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager ( 46 , RHESSI;) HXR spectra and AIA-based DEMs, and found significant discrepancies—particularly at low energies—highlighting the difficulty in constructing a consistent electron distribution across instruments. Further studies ( 53 ; 34 ; 10 ) performed simultaneous forward-fitting on spatially consistent RHESSI and AIA data using instrument response functions. These efforts showed that combined fitting can improve constraints on the electron distribution, primarily for thermal plasma parameters, but still provide limited information about the nonthermal electron population at low energies (below \sim 20 keV). This limitation arises mainly because the commonly used cold-target model does not reliably constrain nonthermal electrons in flare conditions. The cold-target model assumes E\gg k_{\text{B}}T , where k_{\text{B}} is the Boltzmann constant and T is the plasma temperature. However, this condition is not always satisfied in flare loops, where temperatures often exceed 10^{7} K, rendering the cold-target approximation invalid for electrons with energies around 10–20 keV. As a result, the cold-target model fails to accurately describe the physical processes governing electron transport at these energies, making it ineffective for constraining the low-energy portion of the nonthermal electron spectrum ( 32 ) —precisely the region most crucial for flare energetics. To address this limitation, the warm-target model (WTM) was developed ( 40 ; 41 ) . This model accounts for the thermalization of accelerated electrons in hot, dense coronal plasma and incorporates collisional diffusion under warm-target conditions ( E\sim k_{\text{B}}T ), offering a more realistic treatment of electron energy loss and transport. 41 showed that this approach allows accurate determination of the power-law-form electron spectrum, especially the low-energy cutoff of the nonthermal electron distribution which is key to the accurate estimation of electron power. A good understanding of these parameters is also necessary to better characterize the time evolution of flare-accelerated electrons ( 13 ) . Furthermore, 50 applied a kappa-form electron distribution within the warm-target framework to characterize flare-accelerated electrons. The kappa distribution, often interpreted as the result of stochastic acceleration processes ( 14 ; 1 ) , provides a physically motivated description of flare-accelerated electrons that naturally spans over the thermal-to-nonthermal transition. The utilization of the kappa-form electron distribution in HXR spectral analysis has been demonstrated to be successful ( 36 ; 54 ; 55 ; 11 ; 25 ; 50 ) . Once determined by the observed HXR spectrum, the kappa distribution specifies the electron distribution across the full energy range, including below the instrument’s observation range (e.g., \sim 3 keV for RHESSI, depending on attenuator state). In this way, it also naturally covers the range accessible to EUV diagnostics.