Affective Color Scales for Colormap Data Visualizations

Halle C. Braun, \authororcid Kushin Mukherjee0000-0001-5013-6983, \authororcid Seth R. Gorelik0000-0002-9186-1767, and \authororcid Karen B. Schloss0000-0003-4833-4117 · 2025

Read Affective Color Scales for Colormap Data Visualizations by Halle C. Braun, \authororcid Kushin Mukherjee0000-0001-5013-6983, \authororcid Seth R. Gorelik0000-0002-9186-1767, and \authororcid Karen B. Schloss0000-0003-4833-4117 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-14009.txt.

Introduction

Halle C. Braun, Kushin Mukherjee, Seth R. Gorelik, and one co-author study how colormaps can carry feelings as well as data. Color strongly shapes a chart's emotional tone, and lightness drives much of that effect: light reads positive, dark reads negative. But maps that encode values with color need lightness contrast to show fine spatial detail, which seems to block a clear mood.

The team found colormaps can do both: keep strong contrast for structure while still signaling a clear emotional tone. The tone depended on the color scales chosen and on how often each color appeared, which the underlying data controls. Their results argue for data-aware design that plans emotion and legibility together.

Catalog record

CREATORHalle C. Braun, \authororcid Kushin Mukherjee0000-0001-5013-6983, \authororcid Seth R. Gorelik0000-0002-9186-1767, and \authororcid Karen B. Schloss0000-0003-4833-4117
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-14009

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Affective Color Scales for Colormap Data Visualizations Halle C. Braun, \authororcid Kushin Mukherjee0000-0001-5013-6983, \authororcid Seth R. Gorelik0000-0002-9186-1767, and \authororcid Karen B. Schloss0000-0003-4833-4117 Abstract Research on affective visualization design has shown that color is an especially powerful feature for influencing the emotional connotation of visualizations. Associations between colors and emotions are largely driven by lightness (e.g., lighter colors are associated with positive emotions, whereas darker colors are associated with negative emotions). Designing visualizations to have all light or all dark colors to convey particular emotions may work well for visualizations in which colors represent categories and spatial channels encode data values. However, this approach poses a problem for visualizations that use color to represent spatial patterns in data (e.g., colormap data visualizations) because lightness contrast is needed to reveal fine details in spatial structure. In this study, we found it is possible to design colormaps that have strong lightness contrast to support spatial vision while communicating clear affective connotation. We also found that affective connotation depended not only on the color scales used to construct the colormaps, but also the frequency with which colors appeared in the map, as determined by the underlying dataset (data-dependence hypothesis). These results emphasize the importance of data-aware design, which accounts for not only the design features that encode data (e.g., colors, shapes, textures), but also how those design features are instantiated in a visualization, given the properties of the data. \onlineid 0 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype please specify \authorfooter Halle C. Braun is with the University of Wisconsin–Madison. E-mail: [email protected] Kushin Mukherjee is with Stanford University. E-mail: [email protected] Seth R. Gorelik is with Woodwell Climate Research Center. E-mail: [email protected] Karen B. Schloss is with the Univeristy of Wisconsin–Madison. E-mail: [email protected] \teaser Example colormaps from Exp. 1, which represent raster data of aboveground live woody biomass [ 23 ] . The color scales shown below each colormap were generated in Color Crafter [ 72 ] by adjusting hue (red, yellow, green, and blue), lightness (light or dark), and chroma (high chroma or low chroma) within the tool. Here, all 16 color scales were applied to the same underlying dataset, but in the experiment, participants saw each color scale applied to a unique dataset (balanced across participants). Introduction keywords Visual reasoning, visual communication, color cognition, affective science, emotion, scalar field, data-aware design In colormap data visualizations, gradations of magnitude are mapped onto gradations of color to illustrate spatial patterns within a dataset. A large body of research on colormap (a.k.a. heatmap) design has focused on which kinds of color scales (a.k.a. color ramps) are most effective for revealing patterns in data [ 3 , 12 , 43 , 46 , 72 , 11 , 56 , 58 , 57 , 59 , 60 , 90 , 88 ] and how to assign the endpoints of color scales (e.g., light vs. dark) to endpoints of data magnitude (e.g., low vs. high) to help observers interpret the meaning of colors in colormaps [ 14 , 42 , 65 , 71 , 69 , 73 ] . The aforementioned work focused on people’s ability to detect and analyze patterns of data, stemming from the general emphasis in visualization research on accuracy, conciseness, and clarity (c.f. [ 36 ] ). However, another aspect of visualization design has received a recent surge of attention—affective, or emotional, aspects of design [ 6 , 2 , 9 , 62 , 87 , 70 , 34 , 35 , 37 , 89 ] —which can influence engagement, recall, and aesthetic response (see Lan et al. [ 36 ] for a review). In the domain of color, previous work has focused on understanding affect of color palettes (i.e., discrete colors to visualize categorical data) [ 6 , 2 , 9 ] , and explored using palettes from paintings to imbue colormaps with affective connotations [ 62 ] . Here, we aimed to understand factors that influence affective connotation of colormaps for visualizing continuous data. The discussion of affect in visualization is often couched in terms of whether a design is embellished to be ‘emotional’ or kept minimalistic to be ‘neutral’ (c.f. [ 36 ] ), but an alternative lens is that all designs can be situated in a continuous space of affective connotation. After all, seemingly neutral ‘minimalistic’ grayscale visualizations are reportedly linked to negative emotions [ 9 , 89 ] . From this perspective, research on affective visualization design aims to understand factors that link emotion and design. These links can take two possible forms: affective connotations —associations observers have between the design and emotional concepts or affective state —emotions observers feel when they look at visualizations. Evidence suggests that color is among the strongest features linking emotion to visualization, compared to other features such as data patterns (e.g., positive/negative slope) or chart type (e.g., scatterplot, bar chart) [ 9 ] . Previous work on links between color and emotion has largely focused on individual colors [ 13 , 20 , 82 , 32 , 80 , 75 , 83 ] (see Jonauskaite and Mohr [ 28 ] for a review), color pairs [ 48 , 49 ] , faces/scenes [ 78 , 51 ] , or color palettes for visualizations of categorical data [ 6 , 2 , 9 ] , but less so on visualizations of continuous data [ 62 , 89 ] . A general theme across prior studies is that color-emotion links are largely driven by lightness and chroma. For example, positive colors are light and high in chroma, negative colors are dark and low in chroma, and calm or less angry colors are light and low in chroma [ 6 , 68 , 20 , 84 , 15 , 26 ] . Although hue plays a role to some extent (and for some emotions more than others), many hues have similar affective connotation, especially if the colors are light [ 6 , 68 ] . The strong link between lightness and emotion has interesting implications for visualization design. For visualizations of categorical data (e.g., bar charts), in which data magnitude is encoded using spatial channels (e.g., position, length) and categories are encoded using color, colors of similar lightness may signal strong affective connotation without harming the observer’s ability to find key patterns in the data. For example, comparing the heights of the bars in Fig. 1 A (low lightness contrast) seems as easy as in Fig. 1 B (high lightness contrast). But, for visualizations of continuous data, in which data magnitude is encoded using dimensions of color, minimizing lightness variability can pose problems because lightness contrast is important for spatial vision. For example, observing spatial structure in the low lightness contrast colormap in Fig. 1 A is harder than in the high lightness contrast colormap Fig. 1 B. This difficulty is because the visual system relies on variation in lightness to detect spatial structure in data [ 81 ] , particularly for high spatial frequencies [ 59 ] (e.g., fine details in a geographical map). Generally, spatial vision (e.g., contrast sensitivity in high spatial frequencies, orientation sensitivity, pattern and shape recognition) is worse when colors are isoluminant [ 19 , 18 , 59 , 33 , 40 ] . Yet, introducing

Read the complete text