Market competition and poverty dynamics: Short and long run effects across financial development levels

Mohamed Chaouch, Thanasis Stengos · 2025

Read Market competition and poverty dynamics: Short and long run effects across financial development levels by Mohamed Chaouch, Thanasis Stengos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-13875.txt.

Introduction

Mohamed Chaouch and Thanasis Stengos study how stronger market competition affects poverty over time. Using yearly data from 48 countries between 1991 and 2017, they apply function-based regression methods that let effects unfold across years rather than landing at once. Poverty headcount rates are linked to market concentration and other broad economic measures.

Across the full sample, tougher competition first raised poverty during years of structural adjustment, but that harm faded after 2010 as economies adapted. Effects often lasted about five years. Grouping countries by market size shows a delayed pro-poor effect in low and middle groups, while rich-market countries saw little or slightly negative impact. The work argues that moving effects need moving methods.

Catalog record

CREATORMohamed Chaouch, Thanasis Stengos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-13875

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Market competition and poverty dynamics: Short and long run effects across financial development levels Mohamed Chaouch, Thanasis Stengos Abstract . This paper investigates how market competition influences poverty dynamics using a functional econometric framework that captures both contemporaneous and lagged effects. Using annual data for 48 countries from 1991–2017, we estimate function-on-function regressions linking poverty headcount ratios to market concentration and other macroeconomic indicators. The results show that, based on the entire sample, stronger competition initially increased poverty during structural adjustment phases, but its adverse impact weakened after 2010 as economies adapted and efficiency gains emerged. The estimated bivariate surfaces reveal that the effect of competition on poverty often persists over multiple years (around 5 years), highlighting the importance of intertemporal transmission. Then, functional clustering based on market capitalization (MCAP) uncovers strong heterogeneity: pro-poor 5-years lagged effect of competition in low- and medium-MCAP economies, while it remains insignificant to weakly negative in high-MCAP countries. Overall, the findings underscore the value of functional data methods in uncovering evolving and lag-dependent poverty–competition linkages that static panel models fail to capture. JEL classification: C33, E60, I32 Keywords : Competition, Functional data analysis, Poverty. 1. Introduction Reducing poverty and promoting shared prosperity remain central objectives of development policy, yet the channels through which structural reforms influence poverty dynamics are still imperfectly understood. Over the past three decades, many low- and middle-income countries have implemented product-market liberalization, privatization, and deregulation, often combined with trade opening, in ways that have substantially strengthened competition in domestic markets. These reforms are typically justified on efficiency grounds: by reducing market power and barriers to entry, stronger competition is expected to compress markups, reallocate resources toward more productive firms, stimulate innovation, and ultimately support higher growth. Whether such efficiency gains translate into lower poverty, however, depends on how the gains and losses from competition are distributed across households and along the income distribution. Competition affects poor households through several intertwined channels. On the consumption side, lower markups and reduced market power can generate substantial price reductions in markets for food, energy, transport, medicines, and other basic goods. Because poor households devote a large share of their budgets to these necessities, even modest price cuts can have large welfare effects ( 2 ; 10 ; 11 , e.g.) . On the production side, increased competition can spur entry and expansion of more efficient firms, raise aggregate productivity, and potentially increase labor demand and wages. At the same time, competitive pressure can displace incumbent firms, destroy jobs in previously protected sectors, compress wages in segments with weak bargaining power, and push marginal producers into low-productivity informal activities. In environments characterized by pervasive informality, limited access to finance, and weak social protection, these transitional costs can be large and may dominate the longer-run efficiency gains in the short and medium run ( 3 ) . Recent theoretical work has sharpened this ambiguity by embedding competition into general-equilibrium frameworks with heterogeneous agents, imperfect labor markets, and explicit ownership structure. In a vertically differentiated setting with consumers who can be workers and shareholders, 7 show that moving from monopoly to duopoly can either reduce or increase the headcount poverty rate, depending on the position of the poverty line, the dispersion of preferences and productivities, and the share of profits accruing to poor versus rich households. When ownership of firms is concentrated among richer households and the poor obtain most of their income from wages and informal earnings, intensified competition tends to reduce profits for the rich while lowering prices and sometimes raising wages, so that poverty can fall. When poor households also rely on small-scale business profits that are threatened by more efficient entrants, or when labor-market adjustment is slow, poverty may instead increase. This literature emphasizes that the impact of competition on poverty is inherently state-dependent and mediated by the distribution of assets, the structure of labor and product markets, and the depth of financial systems, rather than being unconditionally pro-poor. A parallel policy-oriented literature reaches similar conclusions using case studies and distributional simulations. World Bank and OECD reports document that a lack of competition in markets for essential goods disproportionately harms poor consumers, whereas tackling cartels or anti-competitive regulations in sectors such as food, transport, and pharmaceuticals can generate meaningful poverty reductions through the price channel ( 3 ) . For South Africa, for example, 2 simulate that dismantling just four cartels in wheat, maize, poultry, and pharmaceuticals could have reduced the national poverty headcount by 0.4 percentage points, with income gains for the bottom decile more than three times larger than for the top decile. Similar evidence from Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa shows that cartels and regulatory restrictions in food and transport markets have raised prices by 30–50%, with disproportionate impacts on poor households ( 3 ) . Despite this growing interest, empirical evidence that directly links competition to poverty outcomes remains relatively limited and fragmented. Much of the existing work either focuses on sector-specific price effects or treats competition as part of broader trade and regulatory reforms. Moreover, most empirical analyses rely on static or near-static frameworks—typically reduced-form panel regressions—that link annual poverty indicators to contemporaneous or one-period-lagged measures of competition, imposing constant effects over long periods of time. Such specifications are ill-suited to capture the idea that both competition and poverty evolve gradually as part of longer-term development trajectories, and that the impact of competition on poverty may change sign along the reform process. For example, reforms that intensify competition may initially raise poverty through job losses and business closures but later reduce it as efficiency gains are passed on to consumers and as labor markets and institutions adjust. The timing and magnitude of these effects are likely to differ systematically across countries depending on their level of financial development and their institutional capacity to manage structural change. In this paper we contribute to this debate by studying how competition affects poverty over time and across levels of financial development in a large cross-country setting. Using annual data for 48 countries over the period 1991–2017, we combine internationally comparable poverty headcount ratios at different international poverty lines with a Herfindahl–Hirschman index (HHI) of market concentration as a proxy for product-market competition and a set of macroeconomic controls, including GDP per capita, government expenditure, trade openness, inflation, and growth, as well as a measure of financial development (market capitalization over GDP). We model poverty and competition as smoothly evolving trajectories and estimate how their relationship varies both over calendar time and across lags. We further ask whether the competition–poverty relationship differs across clusters of countries with low, medium, and high financial development, recognizing that the ability of poor households to benefit from competition depends critically on access to credit, the breadth of asset ownership, and the existence of mechanisms to insure against shocks. In doing so, we speak directly to recent theoretical work on competition and poverty and to policy debates on competition policy as an instrument for inclusive growth. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents a literature review about the relationship between competition and poverty. Section 3 describes the data and main variables used in the analysis. Section 4 outlines the functional data

Read the complete text