A congestion-dependent imbalance pricing mechanism for regions allowing passive balancing

Hang Thanh Nguyen, Bart Van Der Holst, Phuong Hong Nguyen, Koen Kok · 2025

Read A congestion-dependent imbalance pricing mechanism for regions allowing passive balancing by Hang Thanh Nguyen, Bart Van Der Holst, Phuong Hong Nguyen, Koen Kok (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-13873.txt.

Introduction

Hang Thanh Nguyen, Bart Van Der Holst, Phuong Hong Nguyen, and one co-author tackle grid balancing in power systems with growing renewable supply. Some countries reward firms that passively adjust their power use to help the grid, but profit-driven responses can bunch up and strain the link between transmission and distribution networks. The authors build a two-stage model of this behavior under price uncertainty.

They compare three existing pricing schemes for imbalances, then propose a new one that depends on congestion. Their design keeps the reward for helpful passive balancing while respecting grid limits. A test on part of the Dutch distribution grid shows the scheme cuts the unexpected strain that older pricing rules allow.

Catalog record

CREATORHang Thanh Nguyen, Bart Van Der Holst, Phuong Hong Nguyen, Koen Kok
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-13873

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A congestion-dependent imbalance pricing mechanism for regions allowing passive balancing Hang Thanh Nguyen, Bart Van Der Holst, Phuong Hong Nguyen, Koen Kok Abstract Maintaining system balance becomes increasingly challenging as market design and grid capacity enhancement lag behind the growing share of renewables, requiring greater effort from both the transmission system operator (TSO) and the Balance Responsible Parties (BRPs). An actor can support balancing actively by bidding into reserve markets, or passively by adjusting its portfolio in line with system needs. In some countries, BRPs are incentivized to engage in passive balancing when their deviations support overall system stability. However, BRPs focus on profit maximization rather than minimizing portfolio discrepancies, which can cause simultaneous responses to price signals and create issues at the transmission–distribution interface. This research provides a two-stage stochastic model that captures BRP dynamic behavior and their impact on the grid under day-ahead and balancing market price uncertainty across three imbalance pricing mechanisms: the single, dual, and two-price. Then, a congestion-dependent imbalance pricing mechanism is proposed that maintains incentives for passive balancing while satisfying the grid constraint. A proof of concept is provided via the simulation with a part of the Dutch distribution grid. Results show that the proposed method mitigates the unexpected peak flow issue in congested areas while preserving passive balancing contributions from other BRPs in non-congested areas. † † graphicalabstract: † † highlights: A congestion-dependent imbalance pricing mechanism is proposed for regions that allows passive balancing by BRPs to address congestion in an economically efficient manner. Providing a proof of concept via the simulation with a part of the Dutch distribution network. Investigating the behavior of the balance responsible party (BRP) under different imbalance pricing mechanisms (IPMs) and considering its impact on the distribution grid. Results show that the proposed mechanism effectively mitigates the peak flow issue in congested areas while still accepting the passive balancing in non-congested areas. Providing recommendations for policymakers to enhance TSO-DSO coordination and consider the proposed imbalance pricing mechanism. 1 INTRODUCTION Energy trading and wholesale markets are not new concepts, however, they remain relatively young compared to the electricity system and continue to evolve rapidly. Since 1996, five legislation packages have been introduced in Europe to promote the liberalization of the electricity sector, support the development of a new market design, and align with the EU’s net-zero climate ambitions [ 29 , 5 ] . Liberalizing the electricity market brings economic benefits by lowering entry barriers for new participants and increasing competition, which is particularly emphasized in the Third Energy Package [ 5 ] . However, this increased competition also introduces greater complexity in maintaining real-time system balance. Besides, with the growing penetration of renewable energy sources (RES) and the ongoing electrification, system balancing becomes increasingly challenging due to the inherent unpredictability of RES and the volatility of electricity prices. As a result, system operators expect greater contributions from balance responsible parties (BRPs). The BRP is financially responsible for the deviation from its own portfolio [ 32 ] , which is submitted to the transmission system operator (TSO) in the form of an e-program. To mitigate the deviation, BRP can (1) improve the forecast of power output accuracy beforehand, (2) buy/sell in the intraday market or via bilateral contract with other supplier/consumer to internally correct their deviation in real-time, or (3) leverage flexibility through coordination with other actors like virtual power plants, flexibility service providers [ 39 , 14 ] . Meanwhile, the TSO performs the corrective actions and settles the BRP’s deviation afterward using the imbalance price [ 13 ] . The imbalance pricing mechanism (IPM), which is the backbone of the balancing market, will thereby influence the behavior of the BRP. This pricing mechanism is the method implemented in the settlement period to determine the price applied for the actual deviation of the BRP from its prognosis. There is still no consensus on the point of view of the system operator among different countries and within a country itself at different times on choosing a suitable IPM for their system [ 25 , 2 , 29 ] . Some have concluded that allowing BRPs to optimize their passive balancing operations could contribute to their profits and effectively improve system stability, rather than inhibiting their influence [ 19 , 15 ] . BRPs can also create additional income streams by performing passive balancing [ 42 , 18 , 29 ] . However, alongside the economic benefits, the passive balancing action from multiple BRPs reacting simultaneously may lead to local congestion [ 23 ] . This arises because BRPs are unaware of their own deviation and the actions of other BRPs and the TSO, while the TSO also lacks visibility into the current and future reactions of BRPs [ 4 ] . As a result, these uncoordinated actions counteract the re-dispatch for congestion management and cause an unexpected peak flow in the connected distribution grid if assets in the distribution grid are used for balancing purposes. Recently, the congestion has become more and more severe in the distribution network in Nordic countries, the United Kingdom, Germany, and the Netherlands, etc. [ 6 , 28 ] . Particularly, the system operators in the Netherlands have observed various unexpected peak flows in the connection point between the transmission network (TN) and the distribution network (DN). According to records from the TSO and the DSO, in the second half of 2023 to early 2024, many unexpected peak flows occurred at several substations lasting from 1 program time unit (PTU) to several hours, with the overload level reaching over 100% of the nominal value. There are several main causes of this situation. Firstly, this problem may come from the utilization of balancing services by TSO, provided by resources connected to the DN, without the DSO having visibility into those actions. Secondly, this issue might come from the inaccurate forecast of BRP or their internal balancing actions. Thirdly, multiple BRPs try to help the system via passive balancing actions. The first cause can be addressed by enhancing coordination and transparency between the TSO and DSO, as demonstrated in our previous work [ 21 ] . This study, however, focuses on the second and third causes: Congestion resulting from the BRP actions. This situation will become increasingly serious both in frequency and severity as more distributed flexibility services are exploited and the pace of grid upgrades and policy changes does not keep up with the growth of electricity demand and electrification. The above discussion poses a question: How can passive balancing contributions from BRPs be effectively maintained and promoted without compromising the distribution grid constraint? To explore this, our study focuses on the existing balancing market design, investigates the behavior of BRPs under different IPMs, as well as their impacts on the distribution grid. Thereby, a solution is proposed to better align BRP incentives with grid constraints. 2 RESEARCH BACKGROUND 2.1 Electricity market in the Netherlands 2.1.1 Spot market Similar to most other countries with a liberalized electricity market, the Netherlands has both long-term and short-term electricity markets. The long-term markets include forward and futures markets, where electricity is traded up to four years in advance and as close as one month before delivery, either via

Read the complete text