The Last Vote: A Multi-Stakeholder Framework for Language Model Governance
Subramanyam Sahoo, Aditi Chhawacharia · 2025
Read The Last Vote: A Multi-Stakeholder Framework for Language Model Governance by Subramanyam Sahoo, Aditi Chhawacharia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-13432.txt.
Introduction
Subramanyam Sahoo and Aditi Chhawacharia propose a shared framework for governing language models in democratic societies. Powerful AI now presses on core democratic values, and single-actor oversight cannot cover the full range of risks. Their plan joins public participation, civil society input, and existing global governance ideas.
Three new pieces anchor the framework. First, a seven-part taxonomy sorts these risks from personal harms to system-level threats. Second, an Incident Severity Score adapts to group views and local context. Third, a phased rollout admits that deep institutional change takes time. Together they aim for oversight that is both broad and workable.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Subramanyam Sahoo, Aditi Chhawacharia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-13432
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Last Vote: A Multi-Stakeholder Framework for Language Model Governance Subramanyam Sahoo, Aditi Chhawacharia Abstract As artificial intelligence systems become increasingly powerful and pervasive, democratic societies face unprecedented challenges in governing these technologies while preserving core democratic values and institutions. This paper presents a comprehensive framework to address the full spectrum of risks that AI poses to democratic societies. Our approach integrates multi-stakeholder participation, civil society engagement, and existing international governance frameworks while introducing novel mechanisms for risk assessment and institutional adaptation. We propose: (1) a seven-category democratic risk taxonomy extending beyond individual-level harms to capture systemic threats, (2) a stakeholder-adaptive Incident Severity Score (ISS) that incorporates diverse perspectives and context-dependent risk factors, and (3) a phased implementation strategy that acknowledges the complex institutional changes required for effective AI governance. Keywords: AI Governance, Democratic Risks, ISS Score 1 Introduction Language model governance remains marked by technocratic reductionism, privileging compliance-oriented risk taxonomies and existential mitigation logics while occluding the constitutive politicality of AI as a socio-technical infrastructure that redistributes epistemic authority and encodes normative commitments 5 . This depoliticized framing produces legitimacy deficits across both state-centric regulatory instruments and industry self-regulation, which operationalize governance as a problem of optimization rather than democratic authorization. Contemporary interventions, exemplified by the 20 ’s AI Act and recent U.S. executive orders, largely delimit governance to individualized harms and discrete technical risk vectors, thereby neglecting structural modalities through which scaled generative systems destabilize democratic legitimacy 21 . Such systems, by virtue of their cascading and path-dependent societal effects, engender forms of procedural erosion that elude capture by extant risk assessment methodologies, underscoring the need for governance architectures attuned to systemic threats beyond the technical-compliance paradigm 22 ; 19 . Democratic AI Governance Framework: We formalize AI governance as an optimization problem where democratic integrity is the primary objective, not a side-constraint 15 . This formulation remedies three deficits in existing paradigms: (i) Risk Assessment: shifting from local fairness metrics to systemic analyses of AI–democracy interactions; (ii) Legitimacy: replacing technocratic exclusivity with participatory, binding authority for civil society and affected stakeholders; (iii) Implementation: supplying concrete institutional and procedural mechanisms that instantiate democratic principles as operational rules rather than aspirational norms 11 ; 6 (For more – Follow Section 3). Key Contributions: We extend AI governance literature by (i) introducing a seven-category taxonomy of democratic risks spanning individual exclusion to systemic fragility, (ii) formalizing a stakeholder-adaptive Incident Severity Score (ISS) that aggregates heterogeneous utilities into mathematically rigorous governance signals, (iii) proposing a four-phase, six-year implementation roadmap transitioning from voluntary coordination to binding democratic oversight, and (iv) operationalizing deliberative democratic theory through institutionalized co-governance, citizen panels, and sovereignty zones. Paper Structure: Section 2 positions our work relative to existing frameworks. Section 3 presents our democratic risk taxonomy. Section 4 details the multi-stakeholder governance architecture. Section 5 outlines phased implementation. Section 6 covers monitoring and adaptation. The mathematical ISS framework is detailed in the appendix, providing computational tools for operationalizing democratic oversight. Section 7 and 8 gives a clear-cut horizon for Limitations and Future works correspondingly. Additional technical details and responses to methodological critiques appear in Appendices. 2 Background and Related Work 46 demonstrates that technologies are not neutral tools but embody political values and redistribute power within society. The work done by 38 on the co-production of science and social order shows how technological systems and political institutions mutually constitute each other. This perspective reveals why purely technical approaches to AI governance fail to address AI’s constitutive political effects on democratic institutions 29 . Current Governance Limitations: Existing governance frameworks predominantly address individual-level harms through fairness constraints and safety protocols 39 . The EU AI Act employs risk stratification by application domain but lacks systematic treatment of systemic democratic effects 65 . Industry focused partnerships also largely prioritize individual accountability over collective institutional impacts 48 . While previous work has addressed group fairness in machine learning through demographic parity and equalized odds metrics, these approaches still operate within individual-level harm frameworks rather than addressing structural democratic threats 24 . Our work extends beyond both individual and group fairness to examine AI’s impact on democratic institutions themselves. Our Positioning: We position this work at the intersection of AI governance literature on technology’s constitutive political effects and computational democracy research emphasizing participatory institutional design. Our framework diverges from prevailing approaches by treating democratic integrity as a primary optimization objective 56 rather than a constraint, contributing a formal risk taxonomy that extends algorithmic governance theory through operationalizable metrics for democratic impact assessment. 3 A Comprehensive Risk Taxonomy for Democratic Societies Building on the domain structure of 43 ; 59 , we extend existing risk taxonomies to systematically address AI’s threats to democratic institutions. Our taxonomy, derived from democratic theory and historical institutional threats, captures both direct process-level risks and indirect institutional interactions, spanning harms from individual exclusion to systemic collapse 10 . Discrimination & Democratic Exclusion. Beyond individual unfair treatment, AI systems can systematically exclude entire communities from democratic participation. This includes algorithmic discrimination in voting access, civic service delivery, and representation in democratic processes, creating structural barriers to political equality. 34 showed GPT-based resume screening tools systematically exclude candidates based on linguistic patterns associated with minority communities, institutionalizing bias at scale. 32 Privacy Erosion & Democratic Surveillance. AI-assisted surveillance enables unprecedented monitoring of citizen activities, communications, and political associations, potentially chilling free expression and opposition organizing. 17 This extends privacy concerns into the realm of democratic participation rights. 1 ; 41 Curated evidence from China’s social credit system demonstrates how surveillance can systematically constrain democratic participation by monitoring and scoring citizen behavior, creating chilling effects on dissent and political organization. Corporate surveillance systems in democracies create similar risks through political tracking and behavioral scoring. 25 Electoral Misinformation & Discourse Degradation. Current models enable computational propaganda, hyper-personalized misinformation campaigns, and systematic degradation of civic discourse quality. 4 Unlike general misinformation, these threats specifically target electoral processes and democratic deliberation. Bots powered by model weights 44 can be used to conduct targeted surveys, build voter profiles, infer political preferences from conversational data, and deliver personalized propaganda. Democratic Manipulation & Malicious Interference. Sophisticated actors can weaponize model weights for large-scale electoral interference, voter suppression, and systematic manipulation of democratic processes. This extends beyond individual fraud to coordinated attacks on democratic institutions. 36 documents bot networks amplifying divisive political content, synthetic media campaigns targeting specific voter demographics, and automated systems designed to suppress turnout through coordinated disinformation campaigns. 58 ; 12 Civic Participation & Human Agency Loss. Algorithmic curation of information environments affects civic engagement through echo-chamber reinforcement, filter-bubble creation, and the delegation of civic decision-making to automated systems, reducing meaningful human participation in democracy. 16 Language-model–assisted recommendation systems can promote increasingly extreme political content and create radicalization pathways that undermine democratic discourse norms. 36 Democratic Power Concentration. The capital and data requirements for advanced AI concentrate power among a few actors, enabling democratic capture through regulatory influence and technological dependency. 55 shows how democratic institutions can become dependent on private entities for critical functions. Foundation-model concentration creates dependencies when governments adopt these systems for public services, potentially delegating consequential democratic decisions to unaccountable private entities. 51 ; 23 Systemic Democratic Fragility. Complex interactions among