Prospects for a Solid-State Nuclear Clock

Steven M. Girvin, Leo Radzihovsky · 2025

Read Prospects for a Solid-State Nuclear Clock by Steven M. Girvin, Leo Radzihovsky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-13017.txt.

Introduction

Steven M. Girvin and Leo Radzihovsky review the case for a clock that ticks with a nucleus instead of an atom. Atomic clocks define modern timekeeping, and the authors first survey their technology, physics, and limits. A nuclear clock would use an unusual transition in thorium-229, only eight point four electron volts above the ground state. Low enough for lasers to reach, with a lifetime of hundreds of seconds when the thorium is doped into calcium fluoride crystals.

Realizing one means confronting questions across nuclear, atomic, and solid-state physics at once. The central obstacle the review identifies is inhomogeneous broadening: strains and electric field gradients from the dopants and from crystal defects smear the transition differently for each nucleus, blurring the tick. Minimizing that broadening is the path to a working clock.

Catalog record

CREATORSteven M. Girvin, Leo Radzihovsky
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-13017

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Prospects for a Solid-State Nuclear Clock Steven M. Girvin, Leo Radzihovsky Abstract Motivated by recent experimental breakthroughs toward a realization of a solid-state Thorium-229 nuclear clock, we review the technology, basic physics motivation, and limitations of the present generation of atomic clocks. We then discuss prospects for a new generation of clocks based on an anomalous low-energy 8.4 eV nuclear transition in Th-229, with an extremely long lifetime of 641 seconds when doped into CaF 2 crystals. To realize such solid-state nuclear clocks one must confront basic nuclear, AMO, and solid state physics questions. Key challenges are understanding and minimizing the effects of inhomogeneous broadening, associated with strains and electric field gradients due to both the Th dopants and intrinsic crystal defects. I Introduction and motivation An exciting new development in the quest for ever greater precision in measurement of time and frequency is the possibility of replacing current atomic clocks with a nuclear clock based on anomalously low-energy nuclear isomeric excitation lines in 229 Th Peik_2003 ; Tiedau_2024 ; Elwell_2024 ; zhang_frequency_2024 . Typical electromagnetic excitations of nuclei correspond to x-ray and \gamma -ray energies ( 10^{4}-10^{6} eV). However, 229 Th has long been expected to have a very low-energy excitation somewhere below \sim 20 eV. After a decades-long search, recent breakthrough experiments Tiedau_2024 ; Elwell_2024 have finally located the extremely narrow optical resonance of the nucleus in the vacuum ultraviolet region near 8.4 eV and directly excited it with laser light. While this excitation energy is an order of magnitude higher than that of optical clocks, it is still within the reach of modern (state of the art) lasers. Indeed, a recent experiment zhang_frequency_2024 based on a precision optical comb (with coherent high-harmonic generation) has directly connected the frequency of UV laser light near 8.4 eV to the JILA 87 Sr clock and has determined the 229 Th absolute excitation frequency (of the center of a particular (I_{\text{g}},5/2)\rightarrow(I_{\text{iso}},3/2) spectral line within the multiplet of transitions) to be 2,020,407,298.727(4) MHz. As we will discuss below, this nuclear isomeric transition has numerous advantages for use in precision timekeeping and quantum sensing, provided that complications associated with having the nuclei in a solid-state host can be overcome: • The clock ‘ticks’ faster because the isomeric transition frequency is high relative to traditional microwave and optical clocks. • The transition matrix element is extremely weak, leading to a long lifetime for the excited state to spontaneously emit a photon (in free space) of T_{1}\sim 2,000s . [The index of refraction in the CaF 2 host crystal lowers the speed of light and thus increases the density of states for photons, reducing the measured lifetime zhang_frequency_2024 to \sim 641\pm 4 s.] One thus expects an extremely narrow (a few millihertz out of \sim 2 petahertz) intrinsic spectral width, which would yield extremely good frequency resolution. • The nucleus is very small in size, and its energy levels are only weakly perturbed by stray electric fields and other spurious effects that lead to systematic errors in traditional atomic clocks. • Small numbers of Th 3+ ions can be stored and manipulated in an ion trap (using now-standard technology), providing a very clean environment to minimize spurious effects. • Huge numbers of Th 4+ ions can be incorporated into solid-state crystals, offering potentially enormous increases in signal-to-noise ratios for precision measurements (if systematic errors due to spurious solid-state effects, discussed below, can be controlled). It took many decades of effort to eliminate the sources of systematic errors in optical clocks Ludlow_2015_RevModPhys.87.63 ; Aeppli_2024_optical_clock . If the same can be achieved for a nuclear clock, we can anticipate breakthroughs in GPS, metrology, and the exploration of fundamental physics through tabletop experiments. Extreme precision in the measurement of time and frequency could potentially one day be used for the detection of primordial gravitational waves and perhaps even allow us to explore quantum effects in gravity. The exceptionally low nuclear isomeric excitation energy of \sim 8.4 eV in 229 Th is the result of an accidental cancellation between two very large energy scales (both of which are on the order of \sim 50 keV): the decrease in Coulomb energy and the increase in strong-force energy as the nucleons rearrange upon ground-to-isomer state excitation. The large values of these energies and their near cancelation make the 229 Th nucleus an excellent testing ground to look for time variation in the fine structure constant (which would affect the Coulomb energy) or to search for interactions with dark matter (which might affect the strong-force energy). Ref. beeks_fine-structure_2025 shows that 229 Th has sensitivities to these ‘beyond Standard Model’ effects, which are enhanced by four orders of magnitude due to the large but canceling energy scales involved in the nuclear excitation. II Brief Background on Atomic Clocks Atomic clocks suffer from three classes of limitations: • The first is the finite lifetime T_{1} of the excited atomic state due to spontaneous emission of photons. The time-frequency uncertainty relation guarantees that this produces a finite linewidth for the transition that is not less than \delta\omega=\frac{1}{2T_{1}} . This can be remedied by selecting a quasi-forbidden (i.e., not electric-dipole-allowed) atomic transition, which thus has a long T_{1} . • The second is \sqrt{N} shot noise associated with the finite number (typically N\sim 10^{4}-10^{5} ) of atoms that are being interrogated. • The third class of limitations consists of a myriad of subtle systematic perturbations resulting from stray electric and magnetic fields, black-body radiation, and many-body effects associated with weak interactions among the atoms (e.g., dipolar coupling). Such effects can cause dephasing of the clock transition (homogeneous broadening) as well as inhomogeneous broadening because of frequency shifts that vary with the positions of individual atoms. It has taken a substantial effort over the last decade to find ways to suppress systematic errors associated with many-body effects in optical atomic clocks so that the number of atoms can be scaled up to reduce the shot noise. Such many-body effects are expected to be smaller in nuclear clocks due to the small size of the nucleus. The microwave excitation of Cs, associated with the hyperfine interaction, has long been used to construct extremely precise atomic clocks ( \sim 10^{-16} at 1 second, which corresponds to losing 1 second in 100 million years!) and is currently used to define the second in the SI system of units. The lifetime of the Cs excited hyperfine state is effectively infinite in practical experiments; therefore, the frequency uncertainty is limited by the interrogation time ( \sim 1 s in ‘fountain’ clocks). Modern atomic clocks Ludlow_2015_RevModPhys.87.63 ; Aeppli_2024_optical_clock based on optical transitions in atoms held (for long periods) in optical lattices have interrogation times limited by the spontaneous emission lifetime of the excited state. Optical transitions possess much higher frequencies but typically have much shorter spontaneous emission lifetimes of tens of nanoseconds. However, by using states with quasi-forbidden optical transitions, long lifetimes ( T_{1}\sim 10-100 s) can be achieved. The combination of a high oscillation frequency and a long lifetime provides optical clocks with a significant natural advantage in timekeeping. 87 Sr optical clocks Aeppli_2024_optical_clock are approaching precisions of 10^{-20} and are so precise that the gravitational redshift associated with a height difference

Read the complete text