Opinion formation at Ising social networks

Kristina Bukina (∗), Dima L. Shepelyansky · 2025

Read Opinion formation at Ising social networks by Kristina Bukina (∗), Dima L. Shepelyansky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-12786.txt.

Introduction

Kristina Bukina and Dima L. Shepelyansky model how opinions spread through a scientific collaboration network using the Ising model from physics. Each researcher is a spin pointing up or down, red or blue, standing for one of two opinions. A few elite nodes hold fixed, opposite opinions. Everyone else flips by majority influence of neighbors, only when it passes a conviction threshold.

The simulation shows a phase transition. While the crowd's influence amplitude stays low, the elite opinion dominates the network. Past a critical strength, the crowd's own opinion takes over and the elite can no longer impose its view. The paper reads the network as a model of elite influence on public opinion. It was published in the journal Information, and it gives a crisp, physics-style account of when prestige stops being persuasive.

Catalog record

CREATORKristina Bukina (∗), Dima L. Shepelyansky
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-12786

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Opinion formation at Ising social networks Kristina Bukina (∗), Dima L. Shepelyansky Abstract We study the process of opinion formation in an Ising social network of scientific collaborations. The network is undirected. An Ising spin is associated with each network node being oriented up (red) or down (blue). Certain nodes carry fixed, opposite opinions whose influence propagates over the other spins, which are flipped according to the majority-influence opinion of neighbors of a given spin during the asynchronous Monte Carlo process. The amplitude influence of each spin is self-consistently adapted, and a flip occurs only if this majority influence exceeds a certain conviction threshold. All non-fixed spins are initially randomly distributed, with half of them oriented up and half down. Such a system can be viewed as a model of elite influence, coming from the fixed spins, on the opinions of the crowd of non-fixed spins. We show that a phase transition occurs as the amplitude influence of the crowd spins increases: the dominant opinion shifts from that of the elite nodes to a phase in which the crowd spins’ opinion becomes dominant and the elite can no longer impose their views. 1 Introduction Social networks now exert a significant influence on human society, and as a result, their properties are actively investigated by the scientific community (see e.g., fortunato09 ; dorogovtsev10 ; newmanbook ). Recently their impact has been argued to extend specifically to opinion formation and even to affect political elections soc1 ; soc2 . This very problem of opinion formation in a group of electors is actively investigated in the field of sociophysics, using diverse models and methods (see e.g. galam82 ; galam86 ; sznajd00 ; sood05 ; watts07 ; galam08 ; kandiah12 ; eom15 ). Usually in these studies there are two competing opinions of electors, often modeled as network nodes, governed by a local majority rule whereby an elector’s opinion is determined by the majority opinion of its linked neighbors. Thus, each node has red or blue color (or an Ising spin up or down), and the system represents an Ising network of spin halves with N nodes and a huge space of N_{conf}=2^{N} configuration states (see e.g., galam08 ). An opinion, or spin polarization, of nodes is determined by an asynchronous Monte Carlo process in a system of spins described by an Ising Hamiltonian on a network. A similar Monte Carlo process is used in the models of associative memory memory1 ; memory2 . Recently it was proposed that such an opinion formation process can also describe a country’s preference to trade in one currency or another (e.g. USD or hypothetical BRICS currency) brics . An important new element introduced in brics , and then extended in inof ; ising25 , is that the opinion of certain network nodes is considered to be fixed (spin always up or down) and not affected by opinions of other nodes. In addition, in such an Ising Network of Opinion Formation (INOF) model inof ; ising25 it is assumed that at the initial stage only fixed nodes have a given fixed spin polarization, while all other nodes are white (zero spin) thus producing no influence on the opinions (spins) of other nodes. However, these white nodes are getting their spin polarization up or down during the asynchronous Monte Carlo process of opinion formation on the Ising network. All the above studies have been done for directed networks with the INOF approach of fixed and white nodes applied to Wikipedia Ising Networks (WIN) considering contests between different social concepts inof , companies, political leaders and countries ising25 . When we consider a contest between two political leaders like Trump and Putin in WIN, it is rather natural to assume that all other nodes (Wikipedia articles) have no specific opinion on these two figures at the initial stage of the Monte Carlo process of INOF, so that they are considered as white nodes. However, it may be important to understand the influence of initial random opinions of non-fixed nodes on the contest results. Beyond this, the INOF approach can be applied to social networks, which in many cases are undirected, such as Facebook. We note that the properties of the Ising model on complex networks were studied previously (see e.g. dorogovtsev ; bianconi ), but the opinion formation process was not studied there. To this end, in this work we apply the INOF approach to a social network of scientists studied by Newman newman2001 ; newman2006 with data sets from his database newmannets ; newman2006ref84 . On the basis of this undirected network we study the process and features of opinion formation and analyze the effects of randomized opinions of non-fixed nodes on this process. The paper is organized as follows: In Section 2 we describe the data sets and the Generalized INOF (GINOF) model; Section 3 presents the results, starting with the original INOF model and then analyzing the phase transition in the GINOF model; a discussion of the results and conclusions are provided in Section 4. Certain data sets are also available at ourwebpage . 2 Data sets and model description For our studies we choose the social collaborative network of N=379 scientists (nodes), analyzed in newman2001 ; newman2006 , taken from newmannets . The network image is available in Fig. 8 at newman2006 and in newman2006ref84 , where the network nodes are given with the names of scientists. This is an undirected network with weighted symmetric adjacency matrix A_{ij}=A_{ji} with the number of links N_{\ell}=1828 ; the weight of links changes from a minimal a_{min}=A_{ij}=0.125 to a maximal a_{max}=4.225 value; there are no isolated communities in this network. The average number of links per node is \kappa=N_{\ell}/N\approx 4.8 . The effects of nonlinear perturbation and dynamical thermalization in this network were recently studied in fpu70 . The full list of network links and node names is available at newmannets ; newman2006ref84 and ourwebpage . As in fpu70 , we construct the Google matrix of the network defined in a standard way meyer ; fpu70 as G_{ij}=\alpha S_{ij}+(1-\alpha)/N where S_{ij} is the matrix of Markov transitions obtained from A_{ij} by normalizing to unity all matrix elements in each column. We use here the standard value of damping factor \alpha=0.85 . There are no dangling nodes in this network. The PageRank vector P_{i} is the solution of the equation GP=\lambda P at \lambda=1 ; its elements are positive and give a probability to find a random surfer on a node i meyer . By ordering all nodes by a decreasing order of P_{i} , we obtain the PageRank index K changing from K=1 at the maximal P(K) to K=379 at the minimal P(K) . The top 10 PageRank nodes from K=1 to 10 are: Barabasi, Newman, Sole, Jeong, Pastorsatorras, Boccaletti, Vespignani, Moreno, Kurths, Stauffer fpu70 . All links A_{ij} and PageRank indexes with names are available at ourwebpage . The INOF procedure of opinion formation on Ising networks is described in detail in ising25 . It assumes that there is a group of fixed red nodes (spin \sigma_{i}=1 ) and another group of fixed blue nodes (spin \sigma_{i}=-1 ); all other nodes are white ( \sigma_{i}=0 ) at the

Read the complete text