Made-to-Measure Outperforms Schwarzschild’s Method
Richard J. Long · 2025
Read Made-to-Measure Outperforms Schwarzschild’s Method by Richard J. Long (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-12425.txt.
Introduction
Richard J. Long compares two long-used methods for modeling the dynamics of stars in galaxies: the made-to-measure method of Syer and Tremaine, and Schwarzschild's orbit superposition method. Both build a model galaxy from stellar orbits and adjust their weights to match observations. Long tests how they perform with a modest number of orbits.
Using eight thousand orbits with varied datasets and starting conditions, both methods reproduce the observed data well. The made-to-measure process, however, runs several times faster, which makes it attractive for large galaxy surveys. The two methods give similar orbit classifications overall, yet the orbits behind them differ, and their weights differ even for shared orbits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Richard J. Long |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-12425
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Made-to-Measure Outperforms Schwarzschild’s Method Richard J. Long Abstract Syer and Tremaine’s made-to-measure method and Schwarzschild’s orbit superposition method are well-known within the field of stellar dynamical modeling. This research is concerned with assessing and comparing the operational capabilities of the two methods and, in particular, the impact on observable reproduction, orbit classifications and computer elapsed times when using low orbit numbers (8000 orbits) with different observational data sets and initial conditions. Both methods are able to reproduce observed data with mean χ 2 ≈ 1 \chi^{2}\approx 1 or less. However, the made-to-measure process does so three to five times faster than the orbit superposition method, and this starts to make the made-to-measure process attractive for analysing galaxy surveys. For a given set of initial conditions, both methods produce similar orbit classifications but the orbits behind the classifications are not the same. Orbits which are common do not have the same weights. Different initial conditions result in different classifications. keywords galaxies: kinematics and dynamics – galaxies: structure – methods: numerical 1 Introduction Syer and Tremaine’s made-to-measure method ( 17 ) (M2M) and Schwarzschild’s orbit superposition method ( 16 ) (SCHW) are well-known within the field of stellar dynamical modeling. Of the two, SCHW has more citations (885) at the time of preparing this article (mid-2025) than M2M (168). M2M and SCHW have been compared previously in 10 where M2M and SCHW were shown to be able to produce similar estimates of galaxy mass-to-light ratios. It is now appropriate that a further comparison is made. Three factors are relevant. 1. Data sizes have increased both in terms of the numbers of galaxies being surveyed and the numbers of spaxels being used to capture galaxy data, and will continue to increase. Internally, because of its orbit weighting mechanism, SCHW is not well structured to deal with the increases expected. M2M is much better positioned. 2. Galaxy surveys would benefit from being analyzed by methods such as M2M and SCHW with their abilities to handle data from multiple surveys, data of different types (spaxel and discrete), chemical data, population synthesis data and orbit classification constraints. However both M2M and SCHW appear to be too slow to handle survey scale activities. 3. An improved understanding of what methods such as M2M and SCHW are capable of doing, or not doing. For example, M2M and SCHW can only weight the orbits that have been provided to reproduce the observed data. At best, the models produced may only be illustrative of what the real galaxy might be like. At worst, the models are non-physical. This article will not address the third factor: this may be better left to machine learning. The first two factors will be considered further. At the time of the first comparison, the accepted assessment was that M2M, with its ability to use significantly more orbits (numbers of 10^{5} to 10^{6} were not uncommon), must of course be producing the better models. SCHW by comparison was claimed to model real galaxies with only a few hundred orbits. The question being posed in this article is how does M2M compare with SCHW when run using fewer orbits, for example \approx 10^{4} . The objective of this research therefore is to assess and compare the operational capabilities of M2M and SCHW, in particular the impact on observable reproduction, orbit classifications and computer elapsed times, when using low orbit numbers. The article’s structure is as follows. Section 2 summarizes at a top level the approach taken in the investigation. The observational data are described in Section 3 , with methods and techniques in Section 4 . Results and subsequent discussion are in Sections 5 and 6 , with conclusions in Section 7 . The main abbreviations used are defined in Table 1 . Table 1 : Abbreviations Abbreviation Meaning 3I three integral initial conditions ATLAS 3D relating to the ATLAS 3D survey GPU graphics processing unit hmdtu half mass dynamical time unit (galaxy specific time unit) IFU integral field unit M2M relating to the made-to-measure method MDJV ‘match density Jeans velocities’ initial conditions MGE multi-Gaussian expansion MPI message passing interface M/L mass-to-light NNLS non-negative least squares PC personal computer SCHW relating to Schwarzschild’s method 2 Approach The Introduction, Section 1 , sets the context and describes what is to be investigated. This Approach section describes how the investigation is performed. In this case, the approach is straightforward: it is just a simple combinatorial problem of running a number of models using different methods, initial conditions, and data sets. The results required for comparison purposes are \bullet the observable mean \chi^{2} values indicating how well the model has reproduced its observational data, \bullet the computer elapsed time for the modeling runs, and \bullet the orbit classifications giving the weighted hot, warm, cold and counter-rotating orbit fractions supporting reproduction of the observables. The assessment of the performance of M2M relative to SCHW will be based on these comparisons. Gravitational potentials and initial conditions are specific to the observational data, and are only calculated once since they will be reused whenever the observational data are used. Data layouts (for example, using a polar grid or Voronoi cells) are not changed except for one set of very specific tests. For other parameters, such as the duration of model runs, their values are kept the same for both the M2M and SCHW runs. In outline, there are \bullet two methods, M2M and SCHW; \bullet two sets of initial conditions, theoretically based (3I) and observationally based (MDJV); and, \bullet two top level data sets, real galaxy data ( ATLAS 3D ) and simulated galaxy data (IllustrisTNG). More information is provided in Sections 3 and 4 . It is not intended that the behavior and performance of all the capabilities of M2M will be compared with all the capabilities of SCHW but only the core capabilities concerned with luminosity and kinematical data reproduction. Features such as discrete data handling, or chemical modeling, or orbit classification constraints are out of scope, as is parameter estimation using the methods. Note also that only axisymmetric (oblate) models are utilized: the investigations are not affected by choice of gravitational potential. The kinematical observables are varied so that both velocity moments and Gauss-Hermite coefficients are modeled - see Section 3 . The earlier comparison in 10 used Gauss-Hermite coefficients only. SCHW requires the use of NNLS software to create orbit weights, We choose NNLS software that implements the Lawson and Hanson active set method ( 7 ) since it appears from the literature to be the most used NNLS implementation for SCHW. The active set algorithm deliberately zeroises the weights of any orbits it chooses not to use in reproducing the observed data, and this is taken into account in the analysis software used. Model selection frameworks such as 8 and 18 are not used. Some use is made of an experimental Gaussian processes approach to M2M hyper-parameter determination. Other than to compare M2M and SCHW orbit classifications for IllustrisTNG data with 20 , no external comparisons of models are made. 3 Observational Data The observational data sets used in this article are the same as those used in 13 . The data tables here are modified versions of