Nonlocal action in Everettian Quantum Mechanics For the volume: Local Quantum Mechanics: Everett, Many Worlds, and Reality (Oxford University Press, forthcoming)

Mordecai Waegell, Kelvin J. McQueen · 2025

Read Nonlocal action in Everettian Quantum Mechanics For the volume: Local Quantum Mechanics: Everett, Many Worlds, and Reality (Oxford University Press, forthcoming) by Mordecai Waegell, Kelvin J. McQueen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-12403.txt.

Introduction

Mordecai Waegell and Kelvin J. McQueen argue that Everettian quantum mechanics, often praised as a local theory, in fact involves nonlocal action. In the Everett view the universe never collapses, and acting on one system cannot change the reduced state of a distant entangled partner. That fact is usually taken to prove locality.

The authors reply that such an action does change the global state shared with the remote partner, and that change should count as nonlocal. They reject a defense based on calling the change merely extrinsic, arguing that line cannot bear the weight placed on it. When the global state serves as an essential explanatory tool, they conclude, changing it at a distance is nonlocal action.

Catalog record

CREATORMordecai Waegell, Kelvin J. McQueen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-12403

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nonlocal action in Everettian Quantum Mechanics For the volume: Local Quantum Mechanics: Everett, Many Worlds, and Reality (Oxford University Press, forthcoming) Mordecai Waegell, Kelvin J. McQueen Abstract According to a common view, Everettian quantum mechanics (EQM) is a local theory because it avoids nonlocal action at a distance, and this is an important point in EQM’s favor. Unlike collapse theories, EQM does not allow an action on one system to change the reduced density matrix (RDM) of a remote entangled system—a clear case of nonlocal action. However, EQM does allow an action on one system to change the global state of the system and its remote entangled partners. We argue that such changes should also count as nonlocal actions, meaning EQM is not local after all. First, we consider an argument to the contrary, which deems such global changes to be mere extrinsic changes, whereas nonlocal action requires intrinsic changes to the remote system. We respond that the intrinsic-extrinsic distinction is problematic and cannot hold the weight of this argument. We then try to clarify when actions that change global states count as nonlocal actions. We argue that it is when the global states are essential explanatory mechanisms of the theory. In EQM, the global state is needed to explain why, in an anti-correlated Bell state, Alice’s measuring spin-up ensures that she encounters only the branch where Bob measures spin-down. 1 Introduction According to a common view, Everettian quantum mechanics (EQM) is a local theory because it avoids nonlocal action at a distance. 1 1 1 47 ; 2 ; 16 ; 61 ; 48 ; 51 ; 11 ; 41 ; 18 , and several chapters in this volume. This is often taken to count in EQM’s favor, with locality being a desirable feature of a physical theory. In this paper, we raise doubts about this view, and argue that while EQM avoids the nonlocal action indicative of wavefunction collapse, it still seems committed to other kinds of nonlocal action, which affect certain global states. For example, in an anti-correlated Bell state, Alice measuring her particle is an action that nonlocally changes the global state that includes Bob’s remote particle. The global state changes in a way that ensures her successor who saw spin-up will be in a branch where, if Bob measured along the same axis, his successor saw spin-down. We think this is nonlocal because the altered global state plays an essential explanatory role in EQM, in the sense that it is used to determine the outcome seen by each Bob, and thus to assure the proper entanglement correlations with the Alices. Therefore, we will argue that while EQM avoids one specific type of nonlocal action, it does not avoid nonlocal action in general. In collapse theories, a local measurement on one part of an entangled system can instantaneously change the reduced density matrix (RDM) of the remote system. To illustrate, consider a pair of qubits prepared in the Bell state: \ket{\Psi}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{0}_{A}\ket{1}_{B}-\ket{1}_{A}\ket{0}_{B}). (1) Suppose an observer, Alice, measures qubit A in the computational basis \{\ket{0},\ket{1}\} . In a collapse theory, upon measurement, the wavefunction collapses to either \ket{0}_{A}\ket{1}_{B} or \ket{1}_{A}\ket{0}_{B} with equal probability. Consequently, the RDM of qubit B , obtained by tracing out system A , transitions from a maximally mixed state: \rho_{B}=\frac{1}{2}\ket{0}\bra{0}+\frac{1}{2}\ket{1}\bra{1} (2) to a pure state, either \ket{0}\bra{0} or \ket{1}\bra{1} , depending on Alice’s outcome. This is an instance of nonlocal action: Alice’s measurement performed in one region instantaneously alters the remote system’s RDM. By contrast, in EQM, wavefunction collapse does not occur. Instead, the measurement leads to branching, where both outcomes exist in superposition, each correlated with a different copy of the observer: \ket{\Psi^{\prime}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{0}_{A}\ket{1}_{B}\ket{\text{Alice}_{0}}-\ket{1}_{A}\ket{0}_{B}\ket{\text{Alice}_{1}}). (3) Here, Alice herself undergoes a branching process, with one copy observing 0 and another observing 1 . Since both branches coexist and there is no collapse, the reduced density matrix of qubit B remains unchanged at (2). Thus, EQM avoids the nonlocal action at a distance involved in wavefunction collapse, because no single outcome is realized globally—rather, all outcomes exist in a superposition of branches, and the RDM remains invariant. The above contrast may make it seem that EQM is a local theory that avoids nonlocal action at a distance. But all that has been shown is that EQM avoids one type of nonlocal action, one that involves changes in remote RDMs. But what is so special about RDMs? EQM may still entail nonlocal actions that make real changes in something else. It seems to us that EQM allows other forms of nonlocal actions. In particular, ones that change certain global states of the measured system and its remote entangled partners. An example is the transition from (1) to (3), where as a result of Alice’s action, qubit B ’s quantum state is described by a global state that includes Alice. This change in B ’s global state does not change B ’s RDM. Since B ’s RDM encodes the probabilities of the outcomes of measurements of local observables of B , such measurements cannot reveal any change in B . But we think that B has still undergone a real change. For this change makes a difference when Alice meets Bob. It ensures that whenever Bob (after measuring B ) is ready to meet Alice, Bob 0 will meet Alice 1 and Bob 1 will meet Alice 0 . To illustrate, imagine that Bob, unaware of Alice’s measurement, measures his qubit in the same computational basis. This results in: \ket{\Psi^{\prime\prime}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{0}_{A}\ket{1}_{B}\ket{\text{Alice}_{0}}\ket{\text{Bob}_{1}}-\ket{1}_{A}\ket{0}_{B}\ket{\text{Alice}_{1}}\ket{\text{Bob}_{0}}). (4) The reduced density matrices for Alice and Bob’s respective qubits remain invariant, ensuring that local measurement statistics remain the same. However, the global state has changed in a way that ensures a perfect correlation when Alice and Bob meet. On the face of it, this is a form of nonlocal action: Alice’s local measurement has restructured the global wavefunction in such a way that Bob’s future interaction with Alice is guaranteed to align with the correct branch. In the next section (section 2 ), we consider an influential argument to the contrary, which aims to show that there is no nonlocal action in EQM. A key premise of the argument is that Alice’s action makes no real change to B , because it does not change any intrinsic properties of B . The idea is that only changes to intrinsic properties matter when it comes to nonlocal actions, and while RDMs are intrinsic properties (of remote entangled subsystems), global states are not. In response, we note that these arguments lack a clear definition for the central notion of ‘intrinsic’. We show that the intuitive notion does not apply in a clear way even to classical metaphysics, let alone quantum mechanics, making its use in categorizing physical theories as local or not questionable. Ultimately, we concur with 33 , who, after extensive analysis of the literature on the intrinsic-extrinsic distinction, conclude that “Unfortunately, when we look more closely at the intuitive distinction, we find reason to suspect that it conflates a few related distinctions, and that each of these distinctions is somewhat resistant to analysis.” We consider several of these related distinctions and conclude that they fail to unambiguously yield the result that RDMs are intrinsic. The

Read the complete text