On the utility problem in a market where price impact is transient

Lóránt Nagy, Miklós Rásonyi · 2025

Read On the utility problem in a market where price impact is transient by Lóránt Nagy, Miklós Rásonyi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-12093.txt.

Introduction

Lóránt Nagy and Miklós Rásonyi study a financial market problem in discrete time, where buying or selling a risky asset moves its price, but that impact fades over time. An investor seeks a strategy that maximizes expected utility under this transient impact. Earlier work placed strong limits on how market depth and recovery could behave.

The authors show the utility problem still has a solution after those unnatural limits are removed. The task is not standard, because the set of portfolio values an investor can reach may fail to be convex, a property many proofs rely on. Handling that failure is a central part of the argument.

Catalog record

CREATORLóránt Nagy, Miklós Rásonyi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-12093

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the utility problem in a market where price impact is transient Lóránt Nagy, Miklós Rásonyi Abstract We consider a discrete-time model of a financial market where a risky asset is bought and sold with transactions having a transient price impact. It is shown that the corresponding utility maximization problem admits a solution. We manage to remove some unnatural restrictions on the market depth and resilience processes that were present in earlier work. A non-standard feature of the problem is that the set of attainable portfolio values may fail the convexity property. Keywords: price impact; market friction; optimal investment; dynamic programming; nonconvex domain of optimization MSC 2020: Primary: 93E20, 91B70, 91B16; secondary: 91G10, 28B20 1 Introduction Investors’ actions move market prices and make large position changes costly. More or less realistic models for this price impact phenomenon have been worked out in the mathematical finance literature. One of the principal questions is the study of optimal investment in the presence of these (nonlinear) transaction costs. Price impact may be assumed instantaneous if it affects the investor only at the moment of his/her portfolio rebalancing. This assumption leads to a relatively simple market dynamics, see [ 5 , 2 ] . At the other extreme, price impact may be permanent , in which case the investor’s action pushes the price in a direction and this effect pertains to the whole future. The most accurate description of reality is probably in between: price impact should be transient , with a gradually fading effect for the future, see [ 1 , 3 ] . The speed at which these effects disappear is characterized by market resilience : if r is resilience then the bid-ask spread is diminished by a factor of e^{-r} in one unit of time. The size of the disturbance caused by trading a unit amount of the asset is described by market depth : if \delta is market depth then 1/\delta is the effect on the bid-ask spread of trading one unit of the risky asset. In the present article we prove that the uility maximization problem in discrete time for an agent trading with transient price impact is well-posed: it admits a solution. The problem under consideration has a complex, non-linear dynamics involving all previous strategies at a given time. Moreover, the domain of optimization is non-convex , which is a highly unusual feature. A continuous-time model with instantaneous price impact was considered in [ 5 ] : they proved in their Theorem 5.1 that the utility maximization problem (with a concave utility function) admits a solution under mild conditions. In [ 3 ] a more advanced model with transient price impact was treated where the markets’ resiliance and depth were both assumed constant. Theorem 3.3 of [ 3 ] proved the existence of an optimal investment strategy in such a setting. In [ 1 ] market resilience and depth were both allowed to be stochastic processes but a related monotonicity condition was imposed in their Assumption 2.4 which implies that the set of attainable portfolio values is convex. That condition holds for constant resilience and depth but otherwise it is rather restrictive. The paper [ 1 ] did not provide a general existence theorem for optimizers but a superreplication result (Theorem 3.2 in [ 1 ] ) with a dual characterization of contingent claims that can be superhedged from a given initial position. They also proved a verification result (Corollary 3.5 in [ 1 ] ): a sufficient condition implying that a given strategy is optimal. In the present work we are dealing with the discrete-time version of the model of [ 1 ] . Our purpose is to prove the existence of an optimal strategy for a utility maximizer while removing the stringent monotonicity assumption of [ 1 ] on market resilience and market depth, see Theorem 2.4 and Remark 2.6 below. Section 2 presents the technical details of our model, the main result (Theorem 2.4 ) and some discussions about the lack of convexity and its implications. Proofs will then be provided starting with Section 3 . Section 4 deals with the one-step case while Section 5 provides the dynamic programming argument. Further reflections are given in Section 6 . 2 Setup and results For x\in\mathbb{R} we denote by x^{+},x^{-} the positive and negative parts of x . Fix a probability space (\Omega,\mathcal{F},\mathbb{P}) once and for all, together with a discrete-time filtration \mathcal{F}_{t} , t=0,\ldots,T where \mathcal{F}_{0} coincides with \mathbb{P} -null sets. Mathematical expectation with respect to \mathbb{P} will be denoted by \mathbb{E}[\,\cdot\,] , \mathbb{E}_{t}[\,\cdot\,] stands for \mathcal{F}_{t} -conditional expectation. L^{0} is the set of all real-valued random variables. \mathbf{1}_{A} denotes the indicator function of a set A . We now present the discrete-time version of the model in [ 1 ] . The time horizon of the investor will be some T\in\mathbb{N} . In the T th step the investor must liquidate her position in the risky asset hence genuine decisions are made only at the previous times t=1,\ldots,T-1 . To have a nontrivial problem we thus need to assume T\geq 2 . The risky asset’s midprice (that is, the middle point of the bid-ask spread) is described by an adapted real-valued process P_{t} , t=0,\ldots,T . This is the price followed when there is no trading from the part of the investor in consideration. Position in the risky asset at time t is denoted by X_{t} , t=0,\ldots,T , we assume X_{0}:=0 . At each time t the investor makes a portfolio adjustment based on previous information (before the new price P_{t} is revealed) hence X_{t} is assumed \mathcal{F}_{t-1} measurable, that is, the strategy process X_{t} , 1\leq t\leq T is predictable. We follow the convention X_{-1}:=0 . The set of all strategies is denoted by \mathcal{A} . We define \mathcal{A}_{0}:=\{X\in\mathcal{A}:X_{T}=0\}, the set of strategies that liquidate the position in the risky asset by the end of the time horizon. We note here, that due to the dynamics utilized in the paper, presented below, maximization of the utility of the terminal wealth \xi_{T}^{X} in X is economically meaningful only over the set of strategies \mathcal{A}_{0} . Outside of \mathcal{A}_{0} , an investor could attain a position in the bank account with favourable expected utility while having large negative positions, and we would need to deal with liquidation value: such scenarios will be excluded. We model liquidity with two primitives, resilience rate, and market depth: market resilience is described by a non-negative adapted process denoted by r_{t}\geq 0 , t=0,\ldots,T-1 , and market depth is a positive adapted process \delta_{t}>0 , t=1,\ldots,T . The half-spread follows a linear dynamics, namely \zeta^{X}_{t+1}=e^{-r_{t}}\zeta^{X}_{t}+\frac{1}{\delta_{t+1}}|X_{t+1}-X_{t}|,\ 0\leq t\leq T-1, (1) starting from an initial value \zeta_{0}^{X}:=\zeta_{0}\geq 0 . Finally, the cash account at time t=1,\ldots,T , considering that the investor pays the spread when trading, is calculated as \xi^{X}_{t+1}-\xi_{t}^{X}=-P_{t+1}(X_{t+1}-X_{t})-\zeta^{X}_{t+1}|X_{t+1}-X_{t}|,\ 0\leq t\leq T-1. (2) Setting \xi^{X}_{0}:=0 for simplicity, with initial capital z\in\mathbb{R} , the investor has a wealth of z+\xi_{T}^{X} at time T . The above model is the discrete-time counterpart of the model introduced in [ 1 ] : except that in our setup only transient impact is modeled. We further assume that the investor may possibly receive a random

Read the complete text