The Birman–Solomyak theorem revisited: a novel elementary proof, generalisation, and applications

V. Bach, A.F.M. ter Elst, J. Rehberg · 2025

Read The Birman–Solomyak theorem revisited: a novel elementary proof, generalisation, and applications by V. Bach, A.F.M. ter Elst, J. Rehberg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-11058.txt.

Introduction

V. Bach, A. F. M. ter Elst, and J. Rehberg revisit the Birman-Solomyak theorem. The theorem concerns Hilbert-Schmidt operators. These are operators whose size can be summed in a square sense. The authors give a new short proof that uses only basic steps. They also widen the result beyond its first form. As a use case, they apply it to a Schrödinger-Poisson system. That system couples quantum particles with their own field.

Catalog record

CREATORV. Bach, A.F.M. ter Elst, J. Rehberg
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-11058

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Birman–Solomyak theorem revisited: a novel elementary proof, generalisation, and applications V. Bach, A.F.M. ter Elst, J. Rehberg Abstract We provide a new short proof for the Birman–Solomyak theorem for Hilbert–Schmidt operators and give an application to a Schrödinger–Poisson system. MSC: 47B10, 47A55. Keywords: Birman–Solomyak theorem, Schrödinger–Poisson system, trace class operators. 1 Introduction About sixty years ago, Birman and Solomyak developed their calculus of double operator spectral integrals, see [ BS1 ] [ BS2 ] [ BS3 ] and derived, among other results, estimates of the form \|f(A)-f(B)\|_{\mathcal{S}_{p}}\leq L(f)\,\|A-B\|_{\mathcal{S}_{p}}, (1.1) where A,B are bounded, self-adjoint operators, f\colon\mathds{R}\to\mathds{R} is a function from an adequate class, L(f)<\infty is a suitable constant depending only on f , and \|\cdot\|_{\mathcal{S}_{p}} is a Schatten norm. A directly accessible case of ( 1.1 ) is p=2 , where the Lipschitz property of f is sufficient for ( 1.1 ), with L(f) being the Lipschitz constant of f . Birman and Solomyak remarked in [ BS4 ] page 156 that, in spite of this simple characterisation, an elementary proof of ( 1.1 ) for p=2 was lacking for a long time, and it was eventually given by Gesztesy, Pushnitski and Simon more than forty years later in [ GPS ] . Their approach is based on a classical theorem of Löwner [ Löw ] for finite-dimensional operators complemented by suitable limit arguments. We became interested in ( 1.1 ) when one of us applied it in [ KR1 ] [ KR2 ] for the derivation of estimates for particle density operators in the Kohn–Sham system. The first aim of this paper is to give an elementary proof of ( 1.1 ) for p=2 , which is quite different from the one in [ GPS ] and to generalise ( 1.1 ) for the case p=2 to arbitrary unbounded self-adjoint operators, provided f\colon\mathds{R}\to\mathds{R} is (globally) Lipschitz continuous. More precisely, we prove the following theorem, in which, for a given Hilbert space \mathcal{H} , we denote by \mathcal{L}_{\rm HS}(\mathcal{H}) the Hilbert space of all Hilbert–Schmidt operators and Hilbert–Schmidt norm \|\cdot\|_{\rm HS} . Theorem 1.1 . Let A,B be two self-adjoint operators in a Hilbert space H . Let C\in\mathcal{L}_{\rm HS}(H) and suppose that A=B+C . Let f\colon\mathds{R}\to\mathds{R} be a Lipschitz continuous function with Lipschitz constant L . Then D(A)=D(B)\subset D(f(A))=D(f(B)) and the operator f(A)-f(B) extends to a Hilbert–Schmidt operator, by abuse of notation still denoted by f(A)-f(B) , such that \|f(A)-f(B)\|_{\rm HS}\leq L\,\|C\|_{\rm HS}. (1.2) In our proof of Theorem 1.1 we first assume that f is bounded and that A and B have pure point spectrum, which includes all compact operators and those with compact resolvent. In contrast to [ GPS ] our proof only requires Parseval’s identity. Having this at hand, we employ an argument quite similar to one in [ GPS ] to carry this over to the class of all self-adjoint operators A,B , still with the Hilbert–Schmidt condition. Finally, an approximation argument allows us to eliminate the boundedness assumption for f . While our proof of ( 1.1 ) in case that p=2 does not generalise to other Schatten classes with p\neq 2 , we note that Peller [ Pel ] succeeded in proving ( 1.1 ) for p\neq 2 by using double and triple sums instead of the calculus of double spectral integrals. Secondly, we deduce from ( 1.2 ) estimates of the form \|f(A)-f(B)\|_{\rm HS}\leq K\,\|(A+\lambda)^{-1}-(B+\lambda)^{-1}\|_{\rm HS}, (1.3) where K>0 depends on the Lipschitz constant of f and \lambda . For smooth functions f with a certain decay the estimate ( 1.3 ) is also in [ GN ] (3.5) for general Schatten classes. The proof in [ GN ] involves the Helffer–Sjöstrand calculus, which is much more complicated. The importance of ( 1.3 ) lies in the fact that, e.g., for Schrödinger operators, the difference of A=-\dive\bigl(\mathfrak{m}^{-1}\nabla\bigr)+U and B=-\dive\bigl(\mathfrak{m}^{-1}\nabla\bigr)+V is usually not a Hilbert–Schmidt operator, but the difference of their resolvents often is. Note that for the validity of ( 1.3 ) only Lipschitz continuity of f is required. In particular, f does not need to be smooth, nor compactly supported and no almost analytic extension of f is required. We further remark that an estimate similar to ( 1.3 ) was derived and used in [ KR1 ] and [ KR2 ] for the estimation of density matrices with respect to Schrödinger potentials. The third part of the paper is devoted to an application of the Birman–Solomyak theorem in density functional theory, namely, in the investigation of the Schrödinger–Poisson system. The connection to the Birman–Solomyak theorem is the following. Let \Omega\subset\mathds{R}^{d} , with d\in\{1,2,3\} , be a bounded Lipschitz domain and f\colon\mathds{R}\to(0,\infty) a strictly decreasing differentiable function with suitable asymptotics at \infty . Let H=-\dive\bigl(\mathfrak{m}^{-1}\nabla\bigr) be the unperturbed Schrödinger operator with mixed boundary conditions on \partial\Omega . If U\in L_{2}(\Omega,\mathds{R}) , then the spectrum of the Schrödinger operator H+U on L_{2}(\Omega) is purely discrete with sufficiently rapidly growing eigenvalues, hence for all \mu\in\mathds{R} the operator f(H+U-\mu) defines a density matrix, that is a positive trace-class operator, and the diagonal of its Schwartz kernel defines a particle density \mathcal{N}(U)\in L_{2}(\Omega,\mathds{R}) . More precisely, viewing a bounded function W as a multiplication operator, one can show that the map W\mapsto{\mathop{\rm tr\,}}\big(f(H+U-\mu)\,W\big) extends to a continuous linear functional on L_{2}(\Omega) , which can be represented by a function \mathcal{N}(U)\in L_{2}(\Omega) . In physics, the number \mu\in\mathbb{R} is a Lagrange multiplier called the Fermi level. It ensures the normalisation condition {\mathop{\rm tr\,}}(f(H+U-\mu))=N , where N>0 is the particle number. In many applications, U=V_{0}+V is a small perturbation of a fixed reference potential V_{0}\in L_{2}(\Omega) . Since the Schrödinger–Poisson system can be written as one single equation (see [ Nie ] ) -\nabla\cdot\varepsilon\nabla V-\mathcal{N}(V_{0}+V)=q, (1.4) one is interested in the functional analytic properties of the map U\mapsto\mathcal{N}(U) from L_{2}(\Omega) into L_{2}(\Omega) and from W^{1,2}(\Omega) into W^{-1,2}(\Omega) , see also [ WPH ] Subsection 3.5. In [ Nie ] it was proved that the operator from W^{1,2}(\Omega) into W^{-1,2}(\Omega) is antimonotone and locally Lipschitz continuous, so that the standard monotone theory with the Browder-Minty theorem applies. Unfortunately, the proofs in [ Nie ] are technically involved. We will use the Birman–Solomyak theorem to prove that U\mapsto\mathcal{N}(U) is locally Lipschitz continuous from L_{2}(\Omega) into L_{2}(\Omega) . In [ KNR ] , however, the monotonicity of U\mapsto\mathcal{N}(U) from L_{2}(\Omega) into L_{2}(\Omega) and from W^{1,2}(\Omega) into W^{-1,2}(\Omega) was established by an abstract operator-theoretic principle, without using specific properties of the concrete Schrödinger operators which are involved. Moreover, the proof in [ KNR ] is fairly simple. Concerning the continuity properties, in [ KR1 ] and [ KR2 ] local Lipschitz continuity of the map U\mapsto\mathcal{N}(U) from L_{2}(\Omega) into L_{2}(\Omega) was established, which implies, trivially, the local Lipschitz continuity from W^{1,2}(\Omega) into W^{-1,2}(\Omega) . These two properties, (anti)monotonicity and local Lipschitz continuity, are the key ingredients for an adequate investigation of the Schrödinger–Poisson system ( 1.4 ). Since the latter is a fundamental model in modern physics (see [ POM ] for a recent overview), we recall the essentials of the analysis for this system. This includes both a derivation of the local Lipschitz continuity for the particle density operator and a description of the foundation of a numerical procedure,

Read the complete text