The relationship between warm and hot has-phase metallicity in massive elliptical galaxies and the influence of AGN feedback

Valeria Olivares, Yuanyuan Su, Pasquale Temi, Ryan Eskenasy, Helen Russell, Massimo Gaspari, Philippe Salome, Francoise Combes, Ming Sun, Ezequiel Treister, Kevin Fogarty, Ana Jimenez-Gallardo, Patricio Lagos · 2025

Read The relationship between warm and hot has-phase metallicity in massive elliptical galaxies and the influence of AGN feedback by Valeria Olivares, Yuanyuan Su, Pasquale Temi, Ryan Eskenasy, Helen Russell, Massimo Gaspari, Philippe Salome, Francoise Combes, Ming Sun, Ezequiel Treister, Kevin Fogarty, Ana Jimenez-Gallardo, Patricio Lagos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10587.txt.

Introduction

Valeria Olivares and twelve co-authors compare the chemical makeup of two gas phases at the centers of massive elliptical galaxies. Warm ionized gas, at about ten thousand degrees, is common in these galaxies and likely feeds their central black holes, yet where it comes from is still debated.

Combining MUSE optical data with Chandra X-ray observations for 13 galaxies, the team measured metal content in both the warm gas and the million-degree hot gas. The two metallicities rise and fall together across the sample. They span roughly a third to one and a half times the Sun's value, which points to cooling and mixing linking the phases. Ionization sources vary from galaxy to galaxy, and in some the warm gas metallicity drops toward the center.

Catalog record

CREATORValeria Olivares, Yuanyuan Su, Pasquale Temi, Ryan Eskenasy, Helen Russell, Massimo Gaspari, Philippe Salome, Francoise Combes, Ming Sun, Ezequiel Treister, Kevin Fogarty, Ana Jimenez-Gallardo, Patricio Lagos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10587

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The relationship between warm and hot has-phase metallicity in massive elliptical galaxies and the influence of AGN feedback Valeria Olivares, Yuanyuan Su, Pasquale Temi, Ryan Eskenasy, Helen Russell, Massimo Gaspari, Philippe Salome, Francoise Combes, Ming Sun, Ezequiel Treister, Kevin Fogarty, Ana Jimenez-Gallardo, Patricio Lagos Abstract Context. Warm ionized gas is ubiquitous at the centers of X-ray bright elliptical galaxies. While it is believed to play a key role in the feeding and feedback processes of supermassive black holes, its origins remain under debate. Existing studies have primarily focused on the morphology and kinematics of warm ionized gas. Aims. This work aims to provide a new perspective on warm ( ∼ \sim 10,000 K) ionized gas and its connection to X-ray-emitting hot gas ( > > 10 6 K) by measuring and comparing their metallicities. Methods. We conducted a joint analysis of 13 massive elliptical galaxies using MUSE/VLT and Chandra observations. Emission-line ratios, including [ OIII ] / H ​ β \rm[OIII]/H\beta , [ NII ] / H ​ α \rm[NII]/H\alpha , and [ SII ] / H ​ α \rm[SII]/H\alpha , were measured for the warm ionized gas using MUSE observations. These ratios were used to infer the ionization mechanisms and derive metallicities of the warm ionized gas using HII, LINER/LIER, and AGN calibrations. We also computed the warm phase metallicity using X-ray/EUV, and pAGB stars models. For two sources at higher redshift, direct T e T_{e} method was also used to measure warm gas metallicities. The metallicity of the hot gas was measured using Chandra X-ray observations. Results. Our observations reveal that most sources exhibit composite ionization, with contributions from both star formation and LINER-like emission. The four sources with the lowest star formation rates in our sample—Centaurus, M87, M84, Abell 496—are dominated by LINER emission. A positive linear correlation was found between the gas-phase metallicities of the warm and hot phases, ranging from 0.3 to 1.5 Z ⊙ Z_{\odot} . In some sources the warm gas metallicity shows a central drop. A similar radial trend has been reported for the hot gas metallicity in some galaxy clusters. Conclusions. The ionization mechanisms of cooling flow elliptical galaxies are diverse, suggesting multiple channels for powering the warm ionized gas. The positive correlation found in warm and hot gas metallicities suggest the intimate connection between the two gas phases, likely driven by gas cooling and/or mixing. The large variation in the warm gas metallicity further suggests that cold gas mass derived under the assumption of solar metallicity for the CO-to-H 2 conversion factor needs to be revised by approximately an order of magnitude. 1 Introduction Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) feedback may play a crucial role in quenching star formation and enriching the surrounding medium with metals through expanding X-ray cavities via jets and outflows in the surrounding hot halo ( McNamara et al. 2000 ; Gitti et al. 2010 ; Fabian 2012 ; Olivares et al. 2022b ; Gaspari et al. 2020 ) . The clearest observations of such AGN feedback mechanisms appear in massive elliptical galaxies at the centers of clusters and groups. These galaxies typically show extended multiphase filaments—a mix of inflowing and outflowing gas forming a circulating flow. These filaments likely emerge from thermally unstable cooling of the hot intracluster medium (ICM), triggered by AGN feedback ( McDonald et al. 2010 ; McDonald et al. 2012 ; Conselice et al. 2001 ; Hamer et al. 2016 ; Salomé & Combes 2003 ; Salomé et al. 2011 ; Edge 2001 ; Russell et al. 2019 ; Vantyghem et al. 2019 ; Temi et al. 2018 ; Jimenez-Gallardo et al. 2021 ; Vigneron et al. 2024 ; Ubertosi et al. 2023 ; Olivares et al. 2023 ; Tamhane et al. 2023 ; Gingras et al. 2024 ; Olivares et al. 2025 ) . Metal content in multiphase gas, as an important component of this “baryon cycle”, remains poorly understood. The abundance of the X-ray emitting hot gas has been studied for different chemical elements at the center of clusters and some massive groups ( Su & Irwin 2013 ) . X-ray observations from Chandra and XMM-Newton satellites show that the intracluster medium and intragroup medium is rich in metals that are synthesized by supernovae (SNe) explosion ( Mernier et al. 2016 ; Mernier et al. 2017 ; Mernier et al. 2018 ; de Plaa et al. 2017 ; Fukushima et al. 2023 ) . Studies of central cluster galaxies show that X-ray cavities formed by AGN feedback can lift metals in their wake ( Kirkpatrick et al. 2009 ) . This process creates higher hot gas-phase metallicity along the jet axis compared to the perpendicular direction ( Liu et al. 2019 ) —a finding also supported by hydrodynamical simulations of AGN outflows/jets ( Gaspari et al. 2011b ; Gaspari et al. 2011a ). Yet questions remain about how different gas phases interact and how AGN feedback influences metal distribution around the central galaxy. Despite the rich availability of new deep integral field spectroscopy (IFU) observations ( Olivares et al. 2019 ; Tremblay et al. 2018 , e.g.,) , measurements of the metallicity of the colder phase of the gas, e.g., warm-phase gas, are extremely limited, with only a handful of objects derived through Oxygen abundance (O/H) measurements ( Lagos et al. 2022 ; Ciocan et al. 2021 ) . Measuring metallicity is crucial for calculating accurate cold gas masses from CO emission lines, since the CO-to-H2 conversion factor depends heavily on it ( Bolatto et al. 2013 ) . To date, all ALMA studies of massive cluster galaxies ( Salomé et al. 2011 ; Olivares et al. 2019 ; Russell et al. 2019 ) have assumed solar metallicity. This assumption may underestimate the cold gas mass by up to an order of magnitude if the actual cold gas metallicity is 0.5 Z \odot ( Amorín et al. 2016a ) . Yet measurements of metallicity in the colder phases of these massive systems remain virtually non-existent. In this paper, we present metallicity measurements of warm and hot gas phases in 13 massive galaxies located in cluster and group centers using MUSE/VLT and Chandra observations. These measurements help us understand the connection between different gas phases and the effect of AGN feedback on metallicity. In Section 2 , we describe our sample sources. In Section 3 , we detail our observations. Section 4 explains our metallicity measurement methods for both temperature gas phases. We present our findings in Section 5 , discuss them in Section 6 , and summarize our conclusions in Section 7 . 2 Sample Table 1: Summary of the sample 1 1 1 References. (1) Mittal et al. 2015 ; (2) Tremblay et al. 2015 ; (3) O’Sullivan et al. 2018 Source name z SFR \rm M_{\star} References ( \rm M_{\odot}\,yr^{-1} ) ( \rm 10^{11}\,M_{\odot} ) 2A0335+096 0.03634 0.46 \pm 0.66 5.33 \pm 0.26 (1,2) Abell 2597 0.08210 5 - 12 3.24 \pm 0.31 (1,2) Abell S1101 0.05639 1.02 \pm 2.57 6.13 \pm 0.55 (1,2) Abell 1795 0.06326 3.45 \pm 5.01 6.99 \pm 0.52 (1,2) Abell 1835 0.25200 117.48 \pm 1.58, 138 5.7 - 7.69 (1,2) Abell 496 0.03301 .. 1.85 .. Centaurus (NGC4696) 0.01016 0.2 \pm 0.1 6.15

Read the complete text