Gravitational wave polarization modes and the kinematical tensors in general relativity and beyond
Cynthia Maldonado, Francisco Nettel, Pedro A. Sánchez · 2025
Read Gravitational wave polarization modes and the kinematical tensors in general relativity and beyond by Cynthia Maldonado, Francisco Nettel, Pedro A. Sánchez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10567.txt.
Introduction
Cynthia Maldonado, Francisco Nettel, and Pedro A. Sánchez connect two languages for describing spacetime motion: the kinematical tensors of expansion, shear, and vorticity, and the polarization modes of gravitational waves. Their analysis works within metric theories of gravity and watches freely falling test particles.
After establishing exact relations, they turn to slowly moving particles in a weak field and study linearized plane waves for theories from a general second-order Lagrangian, including general relativity itself. A clean pattern emerges: transverse shear tracks the tensor polarization mode, expansion tracks the scalar modes, and the mixed shear and vorticity components track the vector mode. The authors say these links give a new physical reading of wave polarizations and may open a fresh angle on their phenomenology.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cynthia Maldonado, Francisco Nettel, Pedro A. Sánchez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10567
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational wave polarization modes and the kinematical tensors in general relativity and beyond Cynthia Maldonado, Francisco Nettel, Pedro A. Sánchez Abstract Interrelationships between the expansion, the shear, and the vorticity—the kinematical tensors—on the one hand, and the polarization modes of gravitational waves on the other hand, are studied by considering freely falling test particles. After studying exact relations, we consider slowly moving particles under the influence of a weak gravitational field. Linearized plane waves of metric theories of gravity representative of those determined by a general second order Lagrangian, including General Relativity, are shown to exemplify the following interconnections: between the transverse components of the shear and the transverse tensor polarization mode; between the expansion, and both the transverse scalar and the longitudinal polarization modes; and between the longitudinal-transverse components of the shear and the vorticity, and the vector polarization mode. I Introduction At the heart of General Relativity (GR) and other metric theories of gravity, lies Einstein’s equivalence principle (cf., e.g., chapter 2 of Will 2018 ). It establishes an equivalence between the outcomes of local experiments, thus making nonlocal experiments essential to probe the gravitational field. Simple but physically rich nonlocal experiments can be conceived with a cloud of freely falling test particles, for instance by studying the kinematics and dynamics of their relative separation. Within a metric theory of gravity, neighboring particles with separation vector \xi are predicted to have a relative velocity \frac{D\xi^{a}}{\mathrm{d}\tau}=\frac{\theta}{3}\xi^{a}+{\sigma_{b}}^{a}\xi^{b}+{\omega_{b}}^{a}\xi^{b}, (1) where \tau is the proper time of the particles; and \theta , \sigma , and \omega are their expansion, shear, and vorticity, respectively. Moreover, these neighboring particles are predicted to experience a relative, or tidal, acceleration given by the equation of geodesic deviation \frac{D^{2}\xi^{a}}{\mathrm{d}\tau^{2}}={K_{b}}^{a}\xi^{b}, (2) written here in terms of the tidal tensor K . Then, measurements of the relative velocity between the particles reveals information about the kinematical tensors, namely \theta , \sigma , and \omega , from which some aspects about the gravitational field could be inferred. Similarly, measuring the relative acceleration reveals information about the part of the Riemann tensor encoded in the tidal tensor—its so-called electric part. Some gravitational fields have a distinctive tidal tensor, as the following examples arising in GR illustrate (cf., e.g., Szekeres 1965 ). A cloud of particles falling radially in a Schwarzschild spacetime, experiences a tidal acceleration that tends to elongate it in the radial direction and compress in the transverse directions. On the other hand, a cluster of galaxies in a spatially homogeneous and isotropic universe, tends to expand accelerating equally in all directions. Contrastingly, a cloud of test particles is affected by a plane gravitational wave, such that only particles separated in directions transverse to the wave spatial propagation direction accelerate while preserving the transverse area of the cloud. For a general gravitational field, the six independent components of the tidal tensor have different effects on a cloud of test particles. This is particularly relevant to detect a gravitational wave. Given a wave with definite propagation direction, the tidal tensor is uniquely decomposed into its purely longitudinal, mixed longitudinal-transverse, and purely transverse parts, the latter being further decomposed into its tensor and scalar parts. These constitute the polarization modes of the wave Eardley et al. 1973 ; Will 2018 . GR predicts that a vacuum propagating wave has only the two polarization modes of the transverse tensor part, but many other metric theories of gravity allow more polarization modes (cf. §11.4.2 of Will 2018 , and Dong et al. 2024 ). Likewise, the study of the relative velocity of neighboring particles has its own relevance for some types of gravitational fields, standing out cosmological models for which it has been a key element in their construction (cf. §5.1 of Ellis 1971 ; *ellis2009republication and §9.1 of Ellis et al. 2012 ). However, it is not so common in the description of gravitational waves, with notable exceptions Herrera and Hernández Pastora 2000 ; Bini and de Felice 2000 ; Seraj and Oblak 2022 . Intuition leads one to expect that the kinematical tensors of a cloud of test particles subject to the effects of a gravitational wave are interrelated with the polarization modes of the wave. Concretely, one expects (at least) the following interrelationships: between the transverse components of the shear and the transverse tensor polarization modes; between the longitudinal component of the shear and the longitudinal polarization mode; and between the expansion and the transverse scalar polarization mode. In the present work we analyze this interrelationship for gravitational waves with a definite propagation direction, within the context of GR and other metric theories of gravity, both in the strong and in the weak field regime. This paper is organized as follows. In § II we review the definitions and the physical meaning of the kinematical tensors, the tidal tensor, and the polarization modes for a cloud of freely falling test particles. Additionally, we write the polarization modes in terms of the kinematical tensors on the one hand, and in terms of the irreducible parts of the Riemann tensor on the other hand. Then, in § III we specialize the analysis to slowly moving particles in a weak gravitational field, obtaining expressions for both the kinematical tensors and the polarization modes at the considered order. Next, in § IV we evaluate the obtained expressions on linearized gravitational plane waves of a selection of metric theories representative of those determined by a Lagrangian that is a general function of the Riemann tensor, and compare them with GR. In appendix A we write exact expressions for the polarization modes in terms of the Newman-Penrose curvature scalars. The conventions used in this work are the following. The mostly plus signature is used. Spacetime indices are denoted by a,b,c,d,e,f ; while spatial indices are denoted by i,j,k,l,m . The summation convention will be adopted for pairs of repeated indices, both spacetime and spatial. The Riemann tensor is defined such that Ricci identities yield {R^{a}}_{bcd}X^{b}=2\nabla_{[c}\nabla_{d]}X^{a} , and the Ricci tensor is defined as R_{ab}={R^{c}}_{acb} . For a world-line with proper time \tau and 4-velocity u , we use the notation D/\mathrm{d}\tau=u^{a}\nabla_{a} . The convention used for the wedge and symmetrized tensor products is such that \mathrm{d}x^{a}\wedge\mathrm{d}x^{b}=2\mathrm{d}x^{[a}\otimes\mathrm{d}x^{b]} and \mathrm{d}x^{a}\otimes_{\mathrm{s}}\mathrm{d}x^{b}=\mathrm{d}x^{(a}\otimes\mathrm{d}x^{b)} , respectively. Total and partial derivatives with respect to coordinate time are denoted by \mathrm{d}f/\mathrm{d}t and \dot{f}=\partial_{t}f , respectively. For a weak gravitational wave propagating in the z direction, indices I,J,K,L will be used to denote the transverse spatial coordinates, namely (x^{I})=(x,y) . Units for which the speed of light in vacuum is unitary are used. II General gravitational field 1 Cloud of freely falling test particles Consider spacetime to be modeled by a Lorentzian manifold (\mathcal{M}^{4},g) , with its Levi-Civita connection \nabla , whose metric g satisfies covariant field equations. We shall refer to this framework as a metric theory of gravity. Let us consider a cloud of freely falling---subject only to the influence of gravity---collisionless test particles, 1 1 1 One might think of the cloud representing the test masses of a laser interferometer experiment, the fluid elements of a gas, or the atoms of a resonant bar. hence moving along geodesics. Then their 4-velocity field u satisfies \displaystyle u^{a}\nabla_{a}u_{b}=0, \displaystyle\nabla_{a}u_{b}\,u^{b}=0. (3) The expansion \theta , the