Beyond Elicitation: Provision-based Prompt Optimization for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks
Yunzhe Xu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Zhe Liu · 2025
Read Beyond Elicitation: Provision-based Prompt Optimization for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks by Yunzhe Xu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Zhe Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10465.txt.
Introduction
Yunzhe Xu, Zhuosheng Zhang, and Zhe Liu argue that prompt tuning for language models hits a wall on knowledge-heavy tasks. Standard prompt optimization searches for wording that draws out what a model already knows. Specialized fields, though, need facts, exact terms, and reasoning patterns the model may simply not have inside it.
Their framework, KPPO, treats prompt optimization as knowledge supply rather than knowledge elicitation. It finds knowledge gaps and fills them, and judges candidate prompts in batches for both gains and stability. It also prunes supplied knowledge to save tokens, cutting inference usage by up to twenty-nine percent. Across fifteen knowledge-intensive benchmarks it beat elicitation-based methods by about six percent on average, at similar or lower token cost.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yunzhe Xu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Zhe Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10465
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond Elicitation: Provision-based Prompt Optimization for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks Yunzhe Xu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Zhe Liu Abstract While prompt optimization has emerged as a critical technique for enhancing language model performance, existing approaches primarily focus on elicitation-based strategies that search for optimal prompts to activate models’ capabilities. These methods exhibit fundamental limitations when addressing knowledge-intensive tasks, as they operate within fixed parametric boundaries rather than providing the factual knowledge, terminology precision, and reasoning patterns required in specialized domains. To address these limitations, we propose Knowledge-Provision-based Prompt Optimization (KPPO), a framework that reformulates prompt optimization as systematic knowledge integration rather than potential elicitation. KPPO introduces three key innovations: 1) a knowledge gap filling mechanism for knowledge gap identification and targeted remediation; 2) a batch-wise candidate evaluation approach that considers both performance improvement and distributional stability; 3) an adaptive knowledge pruning strategy that balances performance and token efficiency, reducing up to 29% token usage. Extensive evaluation on 15 knowledge-intensive benchmarks from various domains demonstrates KPPO’s superiority over elicitation-based methods, with an average performance improvement of ~6% over the strongest baseline while achieving comparable or lower token consumption. Code at: https://github.com/xyz9911/KPPO . I Introduction Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved unprecedented performance across diverse natural language processing tasks through sophisticated prompt engineering techniques [ 2 ] . The field has evolved from manual prompt design approaches [ 36 , 51 ] to automated optimization frameworks [ 27 , 39 , 35 , 42 ] , where optimizer LLMs iteratively refine prompts to maximize task performance. These automated approaches, collectively termed elicitation-based optimization , operate under the fundamental assumption that optimal prompts can unlock latent capabilities within pre-trained model parameters through strategic reformulation of instructions, exemplars, or reasoning templates. However, elicitation-based optimization encounters fundamental limitations when applied to knowledge-intensive domains that require specialized expertise beyond the model’s parametric knowledge. Consider tasks in specialized scientific domains, emerging technologies, or domain-specific applications where factual accuracy, terminology precision, and specialized reasoning patterns are paramount. In such contexts, the assumption that optimal prompts can elicit non-existent knowledge becomes untenable. Fig. 1: Comparative analysis of prompt optimization performances on 15 knowledge-intensive tasks from various domains. Traditional elicitation-based methods achieve marginal or even negative improvements, while KPPO demonstrates substantial improvements (average +6%) while achieves comparable or enhanced efficiency. Fig. 2: Visualization of the failure of elicitation-based prompt optimization to fill LLM’s knowledge gap in specific domains. Despite achieving improved accuracy on the validation split, the optimized prompt fails to provide sufficient domain knowledge, resulting in continued errors on the original failure cases. The optimized prompts capture surface-level patterns rather than providing the substantive domain knowledge required to resolve the failure cases. We analyze the performance of traditional methods across 15 knowledge-intensive question-answering benchmarks spanning multiple domains. As demonstrated in Figure 1 , traditional methods achieve marginal or even negative improvements when a clear task instruction is provided. Figure 2 reveals that elicitation-based optimization fails to address underlying knowledge gaps, instead producing shallow improvements that do not resolve the fundamental knowledge deficiencies. Our systematic analysis of this phenomenon reveals two critical deficiencies: 1) Knowledge Poverty : optimized prompts lack sufficient domain-specific information to address knowledge gaps, instead focusing on superficial reformulations that fail to provide substantive content. 2) Optimization Ineffectiveness : even when prompts incorporate relevant information, the optimization process lacks effective validation mechanisms to ensure the knowledge gap is mitigated. To address these fundamental deficiencies, we must shift from elicitation to provision by directly integrating domain-specific knowledge rather than attempting to activate non-existent parametric knowledge. However, this introduces three challenges: How can we identify missing domain knowledge and generate targeted prompts to fill these gaps? How can we ensure selected prompts reliably address knowledge gaps rather than achieving spurious validation score? How can we balance comprehensive knowledge provision with token efficiency constraints as knowledge accumulates iteratively? We propose Knowledge-Provision-based Prompt Optimization (KPPO) , a principled framework that addresses these challenges through three corresponding innovations. Rather than attempting to elicit non-existent knowledge through linguistic manipulation, KPPO explicitly provides the factual content, terminology, and reasoning patterns required for task success. First, an analysis framework examines failure cases to identify specific knowledge deficiencies and generates candidate prompts incorporating targeted domain content. Second, we introduce batch-wise dual-objective evaluation that jointly optimizes for performance improvement on recent failures and distributional stability, inspired by trust region methods [ 29 ] . Third, we design an adaptive pruning mechanism that identifies structural inefficiencies through local degree and global balance constraints, maintaining essential domain information while reducing token consumption. Extensive evaluation across 15 knowledge-intensive benchmarks demonstrates KPPO’s effectiveness. Our method achieves average improvements of 6.1% and 6.0% on Llama 3.1 [ 9 ] and Qwen 2.5 [ 38 ] respectively, compared to the strongest baselines. Notably, the pruning variant significantly reduces token usage by up to 29% while outperforming baselines. These results establish a new direction for prompt optimization research, extending beyond the parametric boundaries of pre-trained models to systematically incorporate external knowledge. This paradigm shift has significant implications for deploying LLMs in specialized domains where tuning approaches are computationally prohibitive or data-limited, opening new avenues for practical knowledge-intensive applications. The contributions of this work are threefold: • We propose KPPO, a framework that systematically integrates domain-specific knowledge into prompts, achieving significant improvements across knowledge-intensive tasks spanning various domains. • The technical innovations include: knowledge gap filling with targeted gap identification, dual-objective batch-wise evaluation ensuring both performance gains and optimization robustness, and adaptive pruning that maintains effectiveness while reducing token consumption. • We establish provision-based optimization as a viable paradigm for knowledge-intensive applications, addressing knowledge poverty and optimization ineffectiveness of traditional methods and providing an alternative for domain-specific tasks. II Related Works II-A Prompt Optimization Prompt engineering has emerged as a critical technique for enhancing LLM performance, with research spanning multiple optimization dimensions including prompt design [ 36 , 51 ] , exemplar selection [ 47 , 33 ] , and exemplar ordering [ 21 ] . Early approaches relied on manual prompt crafting [ 50 ] , but recent work has shifted toward automated optimization to reduce engineering effort. One direction focuses on test-time prompt modification [ 6 , 44 , 15 , 34 ] , which refines user inputs to improve task understanding, either through auxiliary models [ 17 , 16 , 4 ] trained for prompt rewriting or through direct optimization. In contrast, automatic prompt optimization operates without auxiliary models during inference, employing only an optimizer LLM [ 52 , 39 , 41 , 40 ] for iterative prompt refinement, offering greater practical efficiency. Current approaches primarily focus on comprehensive search algorithms, employing beam search [ 27 , 40 ] , Monte Carlo tree search [ 35 ] , and evolutionary algorithms [ 12 , 13 ] to generate diverse mutations [ 26 , 10 ] with bandit-based selection on validation sets [ 30 ] . These methods collectively constitute elicitation-based optimization, seeking optimal prompts to unlock latent model capabilities. Recent extensions have broadened the scope to multi-turn scenarios [ 5 ] , label-free optimization [ 46 ] , exemplar-focused refinement [ 20 , 1 , 8 ] , and advanced techniques incorporating multi-agent learning [ 43 ] , meta-learning [ 7 ] , and probabilistic optimization