Correlations of ALMA CO(2-1) with JWST mid-infrared fluxes down to scale of ≲ \lesssim 100 parsec in nearby star-forming galaxies from PHANGS Facilities: JWST(MIRI, NIRCam), VLT(MUSE), ALMA Python3 ( 60 ) , NumPy ( 24 ) , Matplotlib ( 25 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 1 ; 2 ) , SciPy ( 61 ) , reproject ( 53 ) ,

Tao Jing, Cheng Li · 2025

Read Correlations of ALMA CO(2-1) with JWST mid-infrared fluxes down to scale of ≲ \lesssim 100 parsec in nearby star-forming galaxies from PHANGS Facilities: JWST(MIRI, NIRCam), VLT(MUSE), ALMA Python3 ( 60 ) , NumPy ( 24 ) , Matplotlib ( 25 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 1 ; 2 ) , SciPy ( 61 ) , reproject ( 53 ) , by Tao Jing, Cheng Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10464.txt.

Introduction

Tao Jing and Cheng Li compare cold gas emission with mid-infrared light in 19 nearby star-forming galaxies from the PHANGS survey. Their maps combine ALMA observations of carbon monoxide with JWST images tracing dust and large carbon molecules called PAHs, reaching scales below 100 parsecs.

Using a new regression method designed to handle uncertainties and outliers, they find that the gas and infrared emissions follow log-log linear relations for most regions. The relations shift with local ionization conditions and vary from galaxy to galaxy, mainly through an intercept that shows a clear two-group pattern tied to star formation activity. The coupling also changes with measurement scale, and the brightest regions flatten away from the main relation.

Catalog record

CREATORTao Jing, Cheng Li
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10464

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Correlations of ALMA CO(2-1) with JWST mid-infrared fluxes down to scale of ≲ \lesssim 100 parsec in nearby star-forming galaxies from PHANGS Facilities: JWST(MIRI, NIRCam), VLT(MUSE), ALMA Python3 ( 60 ) , NumPy ( 24 ) , Matplotlib ( 25 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 1 ; 2 ) , SciPy ( 61 ) , reproject ( 53 ) , raddest ( 29 ) , LINMIX ( 32 ) Tao Jing, Cheng Li Abstract We investigate the correlations of CO (2-1) emission ( I CO {I_{\rm CO}} ) with PAH ( I F770W , PAH {I_{\rm F770W,PAH}} and I F1130W {I_{\rm F1130W}} ) and dust ( I F2100W {I_{\rm F2100W}} ) emission down to scales of ≲ \lesssim 100 pc, by applying raddest , a novel regression technique recently developed by 29 that effectively handles uncertainties and outliers in datasets, to 19 nearby star-forming galaxies in the PHANGS sample. We find that for the majority of the data points in all galaxies, the scaling of I CO {I_{\rm CO}} with I F770W , PAH {I_{\rm F770W,PAH}} , I F1130W {I_{\rm F1130W}} , and I F2100W {I_{\rm F2100W}} can be well described by log-linear relations, though with substantial dependence on ionization conditions (i.e., H ii -like, composite-like, and AGN-like). Under given ionization conditions, significant galaxy-to-galaxy variations are identified, and are primarily attributed to variations of intercept b b , which exhibits clear bimodality. This bimodality is related to the overall host galaxy star formation strength. The differences in slope k k and intrinsic scatter σ \sigma across different MIR bands ( I F770W , PAH {I_{\rm F770W,PAH}} , I F1130W {I_{\rm F1130W}} , and I F2100W {I_{\rm F2100W}} ) are minor compared to their galaxy-to-galaxy variations. All parameters ( k k , b b , and σ \sigma ) depend on the spatial scale of measurement, suggesting that the coupling among CO, PAH, and dust is regulated by different mechanisms at varying scales. We identify non-log-linear behaviors in the brightest regions, where deviations are primarily characterized by flattening of slope. No significant (3 σ \sigma ) correlations are found between global properties and the best-fit parameters. We discuss the comparison to previous studies and plausible physics behind the statistical results obtained in this work. show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction A central pursuit in modern galaxy evolution studies is to understand the coevolution of the multiphase interstellar medium (ISM), which is an ecosystem of molecular gas, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and dust, in addition to the ubiquitous warm/hot gas ionized by various mechanisms. Molecular gas traces the dense ISM and directly fuels star formation. PAHs are regarded as the carriers of absorption features, such as the ultraviolet (UV) bump around 2175 Å ( 42 ; 11 ; 48 ; 57 ; 43 ; 22 ; 4 , e.g.) , and diffuse interstellar bands ( 37 ; 10 ; 59 ; 54 ; 56 ; 55 , e.g.) . PAH emission originates from the immediate re-radiation of absorbed UV photons and is destroyed in hot and ionized environments. As a result, PAH emission serves as a tracer for photodissociation regions. Dust influences the shielding and chemistry of the ISM through its absorption, scattering, and chemical catalytic properties. The evolution of molecular gas, PAH and dust is interconnected. Stars formed within molecular clouds are the primary source of dust. Dust, in turn, facilitates the shielding of UV photons, thereby promoting the formation of molecular clouds. Furthermore, the transition from H i to H ii is significantly accelerated on dust surfaces. The aromatization of small dust grains produces PAHs. In addition, the behavior of these components is regulated by ionization conditions, such as radiation from stars, radiation from active galactic nuclei (AGN), and shocks. Therefore, the relationships among these components encode essential information about the physical state of the ISM, physical and chemical processes that affect ISM, and the regulation of star formation across different environments and scales. Due to its importance, the correlation of molecular gas with both PAH and dust emission has been extensively studied in recent years, on scales from galaxy sizes down to \sim kpc. For instance, 27 and 20 identify log-linear scaling relations of molecular gas (traced by CO(1-0) or CO(2-1) 1 1 1 Unless otherwise specified, CO in this paper refers to 12 CO ) with PAH (traced by the WISE W3 band; 66 ) and dust (traced by the WISE W4 band) at galactic scales. They find that the CO(1-0)–WISE W3 band correlation exhibits less scatter compared to the CO(1-0)–WISE W4 correlation. The correlation between CO(1-0) emission and 6.2~\mu m PAH features are also reported in 9 . 8 extend the correlation between CO(1-0) and the WISE W3 band to kpc scales and find a slope consistent with that observed at galactic scales. 38 further validate these results by studying the correlation between CO(1-0) and CO(2-1) with 8~\mu m (Spitzer; 63 ), 12~\mu m (WISE W3), 22~\mu m (WISE W4), and 24~\mu m (Spitzer) bands across kpc to galactic scales. Comparing different bands, they report steeper CO vs. mid-infrared slopes for the 8~\mu m and 12~\mu m bands than for the 22~\mu m and 24~\mu m bands. Additionally, they identify an anti-correlation between the intercept of these scaling relations and the host galaxies’ specific star formation rate (sSFR). 18 find that the W3 band correlates more tightly with 12 CO than with 13 CO, C 18 O, or other dense gas tracers (e.g., HCN(4-3), HCO + (4-3)). More recently, 19 report that the CO(1-0)–WISE W3 and CO(2-1)–WISE W3 scaling relations exhibit steeper slopes in early-type galaxies compared to star-forming galaxies. The launch of JWST ( 21 ) has recently enabled both PAH and dust emission to be measured at sub-arcsecond spatial resolution. By combining PHANGS-JWST ( 36 ; 65 ) and PHANGS-ALMA ( 39 ; 41 ) data, 40 and 7 are the first to explore the correlations of CO with PAH and dust at cloud scales ( \sim 100 pc). However, as noted by 29 , the use of suboptimal regression techniques in these studies may bias the results and obscure the analysis of the intrinsic scatter in the scaling relations. For instance, as demonstrated in 29 , the previously reported sublinear slope of the CO– {\rm F2100W} scaling relation primarily arises from the limited signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of {\rm F2100W} and the presence of outliers. Moreover, the effect of ionization conditions on these scaling relations remains unexplored. The ionization condition dependence encodes critical information about the influence of stellar or AGN feedback on the coupling of CO, PAH, and dust in the ISM. In this work, we analyze 19 galaxies in the PHANGS sample, which are included in the PHANGS-JWST, PHANGS-ALMA, and PHANGS-MUSE ( 14 ) samples. The optical emission line measurements provided by PHANGS-MUSE enable us to divide the regions into H ii -like, composite-like, and AGN-like ionization subgroups, facilitating the study of the dependence on ionization conditions. For the regression analysis, we adopt the recently developed method raddest ( 29 ). As demonstrated by 29 , raddest achieves the highest accuracy among all existing widely used techniques, particularly for datasets with limited S/N ratios and outliers. This is validated using both mock datasets and

Read the complete text