True spin-orbit obliquities distribution: data-driven confirmation of no clustering of misaligned planets Preprint: A. M. Rossi
A. M. Rossi, M. Rainer, F. Borsa, S. Facchini · 2025
Read True spin-orbit obliquities distribution: data-driven confirmation of no clustering of misaligned planets Preprint: A. M. Rossi by A. M. Rossi, M. Rainer, F. Borsa, S. Facchini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10313.txt.
Introduction
Alessandro Matteo Rossi, Monica Rainer, Francesco Borsa, and Stefano Facchini test whether exoplanets cluster into aligned and sideways orbits relative to their stars' spin. Earlier small samples suggested that dichotomy, and similar claims circulated for Neptune-sized planets, but selection biases were suspected. Starting from 264 projected values, the team computed true obliquities in one uniform way for 116 planets by the rotation period method. They added four literature values.
The enlarged set of 120 true obliquities, the largest yet, shows one cluster of aligned planets plus an isotropic scatter of misaligned ones with no preferred angle. For Neptune-sized planets the split remains only tentative, and the authors warn that a possibly uneven distribution of stellar inclinations could still distort the picture until samples grow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. M. Rossi, M. Rainer, F. Borsa, S. Facchini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10313
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
True spin-orbit obliquities distribution: data-driven confirmation of no clustering of misaligned planets Preprint: A. M. Rossi A. M. Rossi, M. Rainer, F. Borsa, S. Facchini Abstract Context. True spin-orbit obliquities Ψ \Psi offer valuable insights into the evolutionary history of exoplanetary systems. Previous studies have suggested that exoplanets tend to occupy either aligned or perpendicular orbits. However, recent research has indicated potential biases caused by the low sample, questioning whether this dichotomy would persist with a larger dataset. Simultaneously, a similar dichotomous behavior has been suggested for Neptune-sized planets. Aims. We aim to investigate the distribution of true spin-orbit obliquities Ψ \Psi with an enlarged sample, looking for confirmation of the disputed dichotomy previously found, with a focus also on the obliquities of Neptunes. Methods. Starting from a sample of 264 projected obliquities λ \lambda , we homogeneously compute true obliquities Ψ \Psi for 116 planets using the rotation period method. We combine them with 4 further values gathered from literature and we then study their distribution, also as a function of various star-planet system parameters. Results. Our data-driven work based on 120 true obliquities Ψ \Psi — the largest sample to date — strongly confirms the presence of a single cluster of aligned planets, followed by an isotropic distribution of misaligned planets with no preferred misalignment. This result is based on a uniform distribution of stellar inclinations i ⋆ i_{\star} , for which non-uniformity could have biased previous interpretations of the arrangement of true obliquities. We confirm that Neptunians show a tentative dichotomous distribution with data available today, but its veracity needs confirmation with an enlarged sample, also because an anisotropic distribution of stellar inclination may be one of the factors hindering the real distribution. Conclusions. The future increase of the measured Ψ \Psi sample over different planet types will allow better investigation of the relation between misalignment and system properties and help to depict a more comprehensive picture of the planetary evolution processes. 1 Introduction The formation and evolution of planetary systems is one of the fundamental questions in modern astrophysics, as it provides key insights into not only the origin of our Solar System but also the diversity of thousands of exoplanets discovered in recent decades ( 104 ; 68 ) . It is still an open topic of debate, with many aspects yet to be fully understood ( 83 ; 89 ; 126 ; 84 , e.g.) . One of the key parameters that can provide valuable insights into planetary formation and evolution is the spin-orbit obliquity, the angle between the stellar rotation axis and the planet orbital plane. It is possible to derive the projected spin-orbit obliquity \lambda — as projected on the line of sight — via the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect ( 106 ; 88 ) , which is an apparent change in the radial velocity curve caused by a planet transiting in front of its host star’s disk ( 125 , e.g.,) . Observational studies of projected spin-orbit obliquities in exoplanetary systems have revealed a diverse range of alignments, suggesting complex dynamical histories. While many hot Jupiters (HJs) exhibit low obliquities, indicating alignment with their host stars’ equatorial planes, a significant fraction display misalignments, including polar and even retrograde orbits (see 6 for a review). Trends have emerged linking obliquity distributions to stellar properties: planets around cool stars ( T_{\mathrm{eff}}\leq 6250\,\mathrm{K} ) tend to be well-aligned, whereas those orbiting hotter stars often show a broad range of misalignments, likely due to weaker tidal interactions ( 138 ; 7 ; 39 ) . Additionally, multi-planet systems and smaller exoplanets generally exhibit lower obliquities ( 8 ; 139 ) , suggesting a different dynamical evolution compared to isolated hot Jupiters. Phenomena such as migration ( 72 ) and planet-planet scattering ( 102 ; 135 ) are some of the possible explanations for exoplanets’ tilted — sometimes dramatically — orbits. Recent literature has focused on the distribution of true spin-orbit obliquities \Psi , which are obtained by detrending the values of \lambda from the projection on the line of sight for those systems where it is possible to do this. Some authors have noted a dichotomy in the \Psi distribution, with most planets clustering in aligned orbits ( 0^{\circ}-41^{\circ} ), and a non-negligible fraction residing in nearly perpendicular orbits ( 85^{\circ}-125^{\circ} ), leaving the intermediate spin-orbit inclinations empty ( 5 ) . Subsequent works have applied advanced statistical techniques and simulations to investigate how this dichotomy may arise from a biased sample. This bias, possibly caused by the stellar projected rotation velocities v\sin i_{\star} or the stellar inclination i_{\star} selection ( 113 ) , may obscure the true \Psi distribution. Simulations indicate that the distribution of the projected spin-orbit angle \lambda serves as a proxy for \Psi , suggesting a true spin-orbit distribution primarily composed of aligned planets, with a sparse population of misaligned ones and no significant clustering at obliquities near perpendicularity ( 43 ) . However, this has never been verified with actual data, as the sample of planets with measured \Psi was too small. Other authors have also suggested a similar dichotomous trend in the projected obliquity distribution \lambda of Neptune-sized planets ( 46 , e.g.,) , highlighting how compact systems tend to be aligned ( 101 ) . Among the \sim 6000 confirmed exoplanets as of December 2024, only a few hundreds have a \lambda value, and even fewer have a measure for the true obliquity \Psi ( 93 ; 92 ) . In this work, we compile the most up-to-date catalog of true obliquities by computing them using the rotation period method or by collecting from literature. This paper is structured as follows. In Section 2 we detail the rotation period method. In Section 3 we present our comprehensive catalog of exoplanets with \lambda measures available in the literature. In Section 4 we describe our Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm, created adopting widely accepted techniques, to compute true obliquities values \Psi via the rotation period method. In Section 5 we analyze the \Psi distribution, and speculate about correlation with different parameters, such as stellar inclination and stellar age, focusing in particular on Neptune-sized planets. Finally, in Section 6 we discuss possible mechanisms that could explain the distributions we infer. 2 From projected to true obliquities: the rotation period method The RM effect provides information about the spin-orbit obliquity angle projected onto the plane of the sky \lambda , which corresponds to the line-of-sight difference between the host star spin axis and the planet orbital axis ( i_{\star} and i_{\mathrm{orb}} , respectively). The primary challenge to understand the geometry of planetary systems is to de-project this obliquity from the line of sight, to obtain the true obliquity \Psi . This can be achieved using the rotation period method , a well established technique that constrains both the stellar inclination i_{\star} and \Psi ( 30 ; 87 ; 5 ; 27 ; 29 ; 90 , e.g.,) . We briefly recall here the mathematical framework used to derive \Psi . We can follow the approach of 49 and derive an expression for the cosine of the true obliquity \cos\Psi=\hbox{$\sin i_{\star}$}\cos\lambda\sin i_{\mathrm{orb}}+\hbox{$\cos i_{\star}$}\cos i_{\mathrm{orb}} (1) which depends on the stellar inclination i_{\star} ,