Trapped and Unstable: Axion-like particle fragmentation at finite temperature Preprint: SISSA 15/2025/FISI
Nicklas Ramberg, Daniel Schmitt · 2025
Read Trapped and Unstable: Axion-like particle fragmentation at finite temperature Preprint: SISSA 15/2025/FISI by Nicklas Ramberg, Daniel Schmitt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-10086.txt.
Introduction
Nicklas Ramberg and Daniel Schmitt study how axion-like particles, candidates for dark matter, can fragment when they escape a temperature-dependent trap in the early universe. In trapped misalignment models, a finite-temperature barrier holds the field in place until cooling releases it. As the field is freed, spatial inhomogeneities grow exponentially through an instability, and the axion field breaks apart.
That fragmentation, they show, is a new source of gravitational waves, similar to the zero-temperature version but with a distinct spectral shape. The signal can be up to a hundred times stronger than in the standard fragmentation scenario, and the authors map its peak frequency and amplitude. The catch is that the region producing both strong signals and the right dark matter abundance is limited.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicklas Ramberg, Daniel Schmitt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-10086
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Trapped and Unstable: Axion-like particle fragmentation at finite temperature Preprint: SISSA 15/2025/FISI Nicklas Ramberg, Daniel Schmitt Abstract We investigate the emergence of a resonant behavior in axion-trapped misalignment models featuring finite-temperature potential barriers. As the temperature decreases and the field is released from its trapped configuration, inhomogeneities are exponentially amplified through an instability in their equation of motion, leading to the fragmentation of the axion field. We show that this process constitutes a novel source of gravitational waves (GWs), analogous to those generated in zero-temperature axion fragmentation, but with distinct characteristics. We quantify the resulting GW spectrum, identifying the peak frequency and amplitude associated with the inhomogeneous axion dynamics. Our results indicate that the GW signal can be enhanced by up to two orders of magnitude compared to the standard fragmentation scenario, while exhibiting a markedly different spectral shape. The parameter space featuring both strong GW signals and reproducing the correct dark matter abundance is, however, limited. I Introduction The QCD axion was originally introduced to resolve the strong CP problem in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) through the Peccei–Quinn (PQ) mechanism 77 ; 93 ; 92 . Beyond this motivation, the axion also stands out as a compelling candidate for cold dark matter (CDM), produced non-thermally through the misalignment mechanism 78 ; 1 ; 28 . In so-called trapped misalignment models, the axion potential acquires additional contributions in the form of explicit PQ-breaking or temperature-dependent operators, generating additional minima separated by a barrier 74 ; 26 ; 25 ; 27 . For exceptionally light axions in the pre-inflationary scenario, ultraviolet (UV) completions based on discrete \mathcal{Z}_{N} symmetries have been proposed as a natural realization of this framework 48 . Meanwhile, for post-inflationary PQ breaking, the QCD axion model is particularly predictive, leaving only a narrow window of viable parameter space 43 ; 10 ; 82 ; 20 . More generally, pseudoscalar fields arising as pseudo–Nambu–Goldstone bosons of broken global symmetries are referred to as axion-like particles (ALPs). Such fields appear abundantly in string theory compactifications 90 ; 6 ; 68 ; 55 and have also been considered as potential inflaton candidates 40 ; 76 ; 2 ; 24 ; 91 ; 29 ; 56 . In this work, we focus on pre-inflationary ALPs as the underlying field content, while noting that the mechanism we propose may also find realization within QCD axion models. In particular, we study ALPs that are initially trapped by a thermal barrier 27 ; 41 . Then, the ALP remains in a metastable minimum until the barrier disappears, after which it rolls towards the true vacuum. We show that the delayed onset of oscillations triggers a resonance in the ALP equation of motion, leading to a copious production of ALP quanta in the early Universe, resulting in the fragmentation of the ALP field 38 ; 17 ; 73 ; 65 ; 35 ; 34 ; 16 . 1 1 1 Note that such dynamics are absent in the standard misalignment mechanism, unless the initial misalignment angle is tuned close to the potential maximum 45 . Intriguingly, the generation of long-wavelength fluctuations generates anisotropies in the energy-momentum tensor of the cosmic fluid that act as a source of stochastic GWs 59 ; 44 ; 60 ; 31 ; 32 ; 19 ; 13 ; 37 ; 36 ; 9 ; 84 ; 33 . A stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) generated in the pre-nucleosynthesis universe propagates almost entirely undisturbed until today, hence offering deep insights into the physics of the very early universe, if ever observed 14 . While typical sources include, for example, first-order phase transitions 50 ; 47 ; 86 ; 15 ; 21 ; 72 ; 51 ; 81 ; 54 ; 53 ; 52 , ALPs are attracting growing interest as a source of GWs 4 ; 30 ; 66 ; 23 ; 62 ; 63 ; 79 ; 83 ; 75 ; 58 ; 57 ; 8 ; 64 ; 89 ; 41 . In particular, GW emission from axion fragmentation has been explored in monodromy 17 and kinetic misalignment 65 scenarios. In this work, we show that trapped misalignment provides initial conditions that lead to ALP fragmentation and estimate the GW signal both analytically and numerically. Remarkably, initial trapping significantly enhances the GW amplitude compared to previous works. We further compute the ALP relic abundance, finding that simultaneously generating large GW amplitudes and the correct CDM abundance is hard to realize. We structure this paper as follows. First, we outline the model and calculate the analytic conditions for the release temperature and angle. Then, we identify the instability band, derive the conditions for efficient growth, and perform a numerical analysis of the resonant behavior. We compute the GW spectrum for different benchmarks and discuss its characteristics, demonstrating that trapped misalignment offers a viable GW source. II Thermally trapped misalignment In the ordinary misalignment mechanism, one considers an ALP \phi with a potential V(\phi)=m_{\phi}^{2}f_{\phi}^{2}\left(1-\cos\left(\frac{\phi}{f}\right)\right)\,. (1) Initially displaced by the misalignment angle \theta_{i}\sim\mathcal{O}(1) , the ALP starts to oscillate around the potential minimum as the Hubble parameter drops below the ALP mass H\sim m_{\phi} . This corresponds to the temperature \displaystyle T_{\mbox{\scriptsize osc}}^{\mbox{\scriptsize mis}}=\left(\frac{90}{\pi^{2}g_{\epsilon}}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}}\sqrt{m_{\phi}M_{\mbox{\tiny\rm{Pl}}}}\,. (2) Here, g_{\epsilon} denotes the effective relativistic degrees of freedom and M_{\mbox{\tiny\rm{Pl}}} is the reduced Planck mass. Subsequently, the ALP energy density follows a matter-like scaling \rho_{\phi}\propto a^{-3} , making the pseudoscalar a viable CDM candidate. Trapped misalignment has been suggested as an alternative mechanism for ALP production in the early Universe 26 ; 25 ; 27 . Here, further explicit PQ-breaking terms alter the structure of the ALP potential, generating additional minima. This can trap the ALP in a false minimum, thereby delaying the onset of ALP oscillations. In this work, we consider the temperature-dependent trapping potential from 27 ; 41 \begin{split}V(\phi,T)=&m_{\phi}^{2}f_{\phi}^{2}\left(1-\cos\left(\frac{\phi}{f_{\phi}}\right)\right)\\ &+\Lambda_{\cancel{{\mbox{\tiny\rm{PQ}}}}}^{4-q}T^{q}\left(1-\cos\left(n\frac{\phi}{f_{\phi}}+\delta\right)\right)\,,\end{split} (3) where m_{\phi} is the axion mass, f_{\phi} its decay constant, \Lambda_{\cancel{{\mbox{\tiny\rm{PQ}}}}} is the energy scale at which explicit PQ breaking operators emerge, n denotes the multiplicity of minima, and \delta is the phase shift. For simplicity, we focus on n=2 hereafter. 2 2 2 Note that it is straightforward to extend our results to an arbitrary number of additional minima. An exemplary ALP potential is shown in fig. 1 . At high temperature, the T -dependent terms in the potential ( 3 ) generate a false minimum that vanishes at the release temperature T=T_{\mbox{\scriptsize rel}} . The time when the field is released from the trapping potential is defined by the following conditions: \frac{\partial V(\phi,T)}{\partial\phi}=0\,,\quad\frac{\partial^{2}V(\phi,T)}{\partial\phi^{2}}=0\,. (4) This corresponds to a saddle point in the potential. In the following, we analytically derive approximate conditions on the model parameters for trapping to terminate. First, from eq. ( 4 ) we find a relation for the position of the false minimum, i.e., the release angle \tan(\thetarel)=\frac{1}{n}\tan(n \thetarel+ \delta)\,. (5) In the case of n=2 one can reformulate the equation into an algebraic trigonometric equation of cubic order 2\tan^{3}(\theta_{\mbox{\scriptsize rel}})+3\tan(\delta)\tan^{2}(\theta_{\mbox{\scriptsize rel}})+\tan(\delta)=0\,. (6) If \delta=0 , the equation becomes a triple-root. For small but non-zero \delta one can Taylor-expand \tan(\delta)~\approx~\delta~+~\mathcal{O}(\delta^{3}) , which reduces eq. ( 6 ) to 2t^{3}+3\delta t^{2}+\delta=0\,, (7) with t=\tan(\thetarel) . We will only concern ourselves with real-valued solutions to this equation, which can be shown to