Encounter between an extended hyperelastic body and a Schwarzschild black hole with quadrupole-order effects
Nishita Jadoo, J. David Brown, Charles R. Evans · 2025
Read Encounter between an extended hyperelastic body and a Schwarzschild black hole with quadrupole-order effects by Nishita Jadoo, J. David Brown, Charles R. Evans (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08699.txt.
Introduction
Nishita Jadoo, David Brown, and Charles Evans simulate what happens when a small elastic body swings past a black hole on a nearly unbound orbit. The body is modeled as a hyperelastic sphere, a rubber-like object whose parts pull on each other while curved spacetime pulls on all of them.
The calculation uses a general relativistic finite element scheme that follows many mass elements at once in Schwarzschild coordinates. Afterward the team measures how the body's center of mass drifts from its starting orbit, how orbital and spin angular momentum shift, and how much orbital energy sinks into internal elastic motion. The multipolar equations of motion match the simulation through quadrupole order. In one sample run the encounter captures the body into an extremely eccentric bound orbit.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nishita Jadoo, J. David Brown, Charles R. Evans |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 109 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08699
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Encounter between an extended hyperelastic body and a Schwarzschild black hole with quadrupole-order effects Nishita Jadoo, J. David Brown, Charles R. Evans Abstract We model the general relativistic interaction of a small hyperelastic sphere with a Schwarzschild black hole as it follows an initially marginally-bound orbit through a close encounter. While the interaction reveals effects that are encoded by the Mathisson-Papapetrou-Dixon (MPD) multipolar equations through quadrupole order, the calculation is made using an independent general relativistic finite element scheme that we described earlier (Phys. Rev. D 108(8):084020, October 2023). The finite element calculation is done in Schwarzschild coordinates, following a large and scalable number of mass elements in interaction with each other through elastic forces derived from a potential energy function and with the spacetime geometry. After the fact, we analyze the dynamics using a local Fermi coordinate system, computing (1) the deviation of the center of mass of the body relative to the initial marginally-bound orbit, (2) changes in orbital and spin angular momenta, and (3) the decrease in orbital energy and accompanying deposition of energy into internal elastic dynamics. The interaction leads to the capture of the small body into a highly eccentric orbit ( e ≃ 0.99998 e\simeq 0.99998 in a sample calculation). I Introduction The study of extended bodies in general relativity has a long history beginning with Einstein and Grommer 19 . In the test particle limit, a point particle moves along a geodesic of the given spacetime. The motion of a physical, extended body deviates from a geodesic due to two effects. First, if the mass cannot be ignored, the object will produce a gravitational field that alters the geometry and gives rise to a self-force and self-torque that affect the trajectory and spin angular momentum. Second, even in the test-mass limit, the infinitesimal pieces of the extended body move along separate worldlines and experience different interactions with the gravitational field. The net result of these individual interactions drives changes in the center of mass motion and spin. Subsequently, Mathisson 43 developed equations of motion for an extended test body in curved spacetime using a covariant multipolar expansion. Further work was done by Papapetrou 45 and others 47 ; 57 ; 39 , including the elucidation of various spin-supplementary conditions 11 . The approach was extended and clarified in a series of papers by Dixon 17 ; 13 ; 14 , who derived the laws of motion for the worldline and spin through all multipole order contributions. The resulting equations are commonly referred to as the Mathisson–Papapetrou–Dixon (MPD) equations. At zeroth order, the body moves along a geodesic, while the next order effect is due to the coupling of the body’s spin to the spacetime curvature, producing both precession and deflection of the worldline. Beyond this so-called pole-dipole approximation, the body’s quadrupole and higher-order moments couple to the spacetime curvature and gradients in the curvature, lending further corrections to the motion and spin dynamics. See reviews in 15 ; 16 ; 24 . More recently, work has been done in using action principles to obtain equivalent results 2 ; 49 ; 53 ; 36 and efforts have been pursued to extend the laws of motion to extended bodies with self-gravity 52 ; 23 ; 24 ; 33 ; 21 , where the momenta respond to an effective metric. This latter approach is an extension to finite-sized objects of the familiar point-particle self-force problem that is widely used in first-order perturbation theory calculations of extreme-mass-ratio inspiral (EMRI) (see reviews e.g., 3 ; 50 ). Numerous calculations of deviations from geodesic point-particle motion under combined MPD and gravitational wave emission effects during EMRI inspirals or scattering events have been made over the past decade 5 ; 20 ; 38 ; 58 ; 41 ; 35 ; 56 ; 18 ; 42 . The MPD formalism involves the choice of a worldline, with associated spatial hypersurfaces that foliate the worldtube within which the extended body is confined 14 ; 25 . The integrated conservation laws constrain only the monopole and dipole moments. The quadrupole and higher-order moments, which contribute to the dynamics of the linear and spin angular momenta, must be determined by added internal dynamics within the body, subject to the specifics of the stress-energy-momentum tensor. See recent work 25 ; 22 on “what is possible” as far as effects of higher moments on the bulk motion. To close the system of equations, either the internal dynamics must be evolved, and higher moments determined dynamically, or a constitutive relation is imposed to place a stationary relationship between these moments and moments of the tidal field, especially the quadrupole (i.e., I-Love-Q relations; see 26 ; 60 ) or rapid spin of the body. A quasistationary deformation, set by a Love-relation, will occur in the tidal field of a circular orbit binary, whereas eccentric motion or misaligned spin would generally require added dynamical evolution. In this paper we sidestep these issues initially by making a full numerical computation of the dynamics of a small but extended-size elastic body in the test-mass limit. We can therefore examine MPD effects beyond pole-dipole order using an encounter between a stationary (Schwarzschild) black hole and an object with full internal dynamics. The dynamics is governed by a stress-energy-momentum (SEM) tensor based on a model of general relativistic hyperelasticity 12 ; 9 ; 32 ; 7 ; 4 ; 6 , with the elasticity deriving from a potential energy function that allows large elastic deformations. The numerical method was described in Ref. 27 , which we based on a Lagrangian finite-element approach for numerically modeling extended bodies of arbitrary shape and size and for any given spacetime metric. The scheme does not require the use of a tailored, local normal-neighborhood coordinate system. However, after the fact, as we show in this paper, it is possible to construct a local Fermi coordinate system based around some timelike geodesic that closely follows the extended body, transforming the description of the system from Schwarzschild coordinates. It is then possible to analyze the behavior of the system in more familiar terms, providing estimates of spin angular momentum and energy deposition and measuring the deflection of the orbit and decrease in orbital energy and orbital angular momentum. The behavior is similar to that found in the tidal interaction of a white dwarf star with an intermediate mass black hole 10 , though in the latter calculation the dynamics is computed in the Fermi frame itself and the internal dynamics is provided by a balance between fluid pressure and self-gravity. Our numerical scheme was previously validated in flat spacetime. In this paper, we introduce general relativistic effects by modeling the interaction of a hyperelastic body on a marginally-bound scattering orbit (i.e., an orbit inbound from infinity with specific energy \mathcal{E}=1 ) with a Schwarzschild black hole. The total mass of the extended body is small enough to have negligible effect on the spacetime curvature. Thus there is no gravitational self-force or radiation reaction; all of the self-force derives from internal dynamics and (effectively) the coupling between multipole moments and the tidal field. The timelike and rotational Killing vectors lead to the total mass-energy and total angular momentum being conserved