Evidence for in-situ acceleration of relativistic particles in the wings of X-shaped radio galaxies Journal: ApJ

Dusmanta Patra, Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi · 2025

Read Evidence for in-situ acceleration of relativistic particles in the wings of X-shaped radio galaxies Journal: ApJ by Dusmanta Patra, Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08676.txt.

Introduction

Dusmanta Patra, Gopal-Krishna, and Ravi Joshi report fresh evidence that old radio galaxy lobes can re-energize their own particles. Their sample holds forty X-shaped radio galaxies, sources whose two pairs of lobes form an X, including fifteen newly reported from the LOFAR survey data.

Spectral maps combine low-frequency LOFAR images with higher-frequency FIRST data for sixty-eight well-resolved wings. In eleven wings the spectrum stops steepening along the lobe, or even flattens, exactly the signature of particles gaining energy in place rather than only aging. The change mostly begins where the lobe stream bends into the wing. The authors expect the enlarged set of examples to spur follow-up observations, theory, and simulations of this acceleration clue.

Catalog record

CREATORDusmanta Patra, Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08676

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence for in-situ acceleration of relativistic particles in the wings of X-shaped radio galaxies Journal: ApJ Dusmanta Patra, Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi Abstract We report evidence for in-situ acceleration/re-acceleration of relativistic particles in 11 radio wings out of a total of 68 wings sufficiently well-resolved for spectral mapping, which belong to our sample of 40 X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs). This representative XRG sample includes 15 XRGs newly reported here, which we selected from the LOTSS-DR2 survey, following well-defined criteria. The evidence for in-situ particle acceleration comes from the observed cessation of steepening, or even flattening (i.e., gradient reversal) of the spectral index profile along the lobe into the associated wing, as determined here by combining the LoTSS-DR2 (144 MHz) and FIRST (1.4 GHz) maps. Interestingly, the afore-mentioned trends in spectral gradient, indicative of in-situ particle acceleration, are mostly found to set in near the region where the lobe plasma stream bends to connect to the wing. Such a spatial coincidence with bending of radio lobe/tail has been noticed in recent years for just a couple of radio galaxies. The large increase in such examples, as reported here, is expected to give a fillip to observational, theoretical and numerical simulation follow-up investigations of this important clue about the occurrence of in situ particle acceleration in lobes of radio galaxies. I Introduction In powerful radio galaxies the pair of radio lobes is energised by two nearly anti-parallel jets of comparable power, launched from the active nucleus in the core of the parent galaxy. Even when the jets undergo directional changes due to precession ( 37 ; 7 , e.g.,) , the two lobes represent the long-term average of the directions of the jets feeding them. Thus, the two lobes usually exhibit a broadly symmetric disposition about the nucleus and together define the primary (i.e. the main) radio axis, roughly along which they are normally found to extend, unless sometimes swept aside by a strong external cross-wind. In a small fraction of radio galaxies, however, the two lobes are seen to bend away from the radio axis broadly in opposite directions, giving the appearance of a second pair of radio lobes which are fainter, diffuse and distinctly misaligned from the main radio axis defined by the two primary lobes. The pair of fainter radio lobes representing the off-axis emission is usually termed ‘secondary lobes’ or ‘wings’. Such sources, exhibiting two mis-aligned pairs of radio lobes are known as X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) and they constitute \sim 10\% of the radio galaxy population ( 60 ; 10 ; 3 ) . One possibility is that the secondary lobe pair, i.e. the two ‘wings’ form due to buoyancy-driven diversion of the back-flowing synchrotron plasma streaming in the primary lobes, as the two plasma streams impinge asymmetrically on the interstellar medium (ISM) of the parent elliptical galaxy ( 44 ; 43 ; 59 ; 9 ; 33 ; 34 ; 14 ; 27 , e.g.,) . However, this simple scenario may run into tension with the existence of some XRGs in which wings are longer than the primary lobes. A few prominent such examples are the radio galaxies: B2 0828+32 ( 50 ; 36 ) , J1130+0058 ( 39 ) , 3C 403 ( 5 ; 12 ; 16 ) and J2011-298 ( 8 ) . Here it may also be relevant to recall the recent discovery of huge radio ‘chimneys’ emanating almost orthogonally from the lobes of standard radio galaxies, namely J022830+382108 and J093032+311215 ( 28 ) . The other popular model of XRGs, the ‘spin-flip’ model ( 55 ; 62 ; 17 ; 21 ; 41 ) invokes a minor merger (or, accretion-disk instability leading to inhomogeneous mass accretion) and is particularly explored in ( 46 ) . This model is known to encounter difficulty in accounting for the observed radio-optical alignments and the high ellipticity of the host galaxy in XRGs ( 24 ; 8 , e.g.) . Another difficulty which lies in explaining the lateral offset between the two wings, as observed distinctly in several XRGs, can be overcome in a variant of the basic spin-flip model. This modified scenario, which seeks to reconcile this particular observational challenge with the basic spin-flip model, posits that the twin-jets prior to the spin-flip are diverted in opposite directions due to their dynamical interaction with the ISM of the host galaxy, which is already set in rotation, e.g., due to inspiralling of a dwarf galaxy ( 25 ; 24 ) . Here, we also recall another model of XRGs which seeks to explain the wing formation as a consequence of the twin-jets interacting with the gaseous shells rotating around the host elliptical ( 26 ; 29 ; 23 ; 24 ; see also, 31 for further evidence of jet-shell interaction). As pointed out by 35 , this scenario has the potential to explain not only the wings that sometimes grow longer than the associated primary lobes (see above), but also the intriguing finding that so often the wings are seen to start off rather close behind the tip of the primary lobe, far away from the host galaxy ( 56 ) . Of course, depending on the angular resolution of the map, such XRGs could even be classified as Z-shaped radio galaxies, ZRGs, which are conventionally explained in terms of jet precession ( 54 ; 20 ; 6 ; 47 ; 63 ; see also, 50 , for possible role of conical jet precession in the case of XRG). However, as seen below, pinning down the exact physical process responsible for the wing formation in XRGs is not critical for the main theme pursued in this paper and indeed more than one mechanisms may lead to the X-shaped radio morphology ( 56 ; 39 ; 50 ; 8 , see, e.g.) . Adequate for the present purpose is just the observed fact that in XRGs, the two primary lobes are seen to bend in roughly opposite directions, connecting to their respective wings. In all these XRG models, the radiating synchrotron plasma in the wings is expected to be older compared to that in the associated primary lobes and consequently one would expect to observe in the wings signs of synchrotron aging, i.e., a steeper radio spectrum. Yet in a sample of 26 XRGs, selected regions within the wings and in their primary lobes were found to be statistically indistinguishable in terms of radio spectral index (averaged over the individual regions) and cases of wings having spectra flatter than their primary lobes were inferred to be as common as the obverse ( 39 ) 1 1 1 Curiously, these authors found the spectra of the wings to be systematically flatter compared to the spectra of the diffuse emission (of comparable surface brightness) associated with classical double radio sources. . This statistics led these authors to conclude that in XRGs the pairs of primary lobes and wings exhibit no systematic spectral difference attributable to synchrotron ageing and hence the two pairs are being independently energised quasi-simultaneously by two twin-jets launched from a binary of supermassive black holes situated within the core of the parent galaxy ( 40 ; 39 ) . This interesting proposal, however, falls short of

Read the complete text