“It Looks All the Same to Me”: Cross-index Training for Long-term Financial Series Prediction
Stanislav Selitskiy · 2025
Read “It Looks All the Same to Me”: Cross-index Training for Long-term Financial Series Prediction by Stanislav Selitskiy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08658.txt.
Introduction
Stanislav Selitskiy tests a simple question with neural networks: does a model trained on one stock index forecast a different country's index just as well? The study tries several network designs, from standard architectures to more exotic ones, on long-term forecasts of indexes from different global markets.
The answer is mostly yes. Cross-trained models often match or beat models trained on the target index itself, suggesting the indexes share deep behavioral patterns that networks pick up. Selitskiy reads this as fresh evidence for the Efficient Market Hypothesis, the long-debated idea that prices already reflect available information. If markets process information alike everywhere, a model that learns one market's habits may genuinely carry those habits abroad.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stanislav Selitskiy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08658
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
“It Looks All the Same to Me”: Cross-index Training for Long-term Financial Series Prediction Stanislav Selitskiy Abstract We investigate a number of Artificial Neural Network architectures (well-known and more “exotic”) in application to the long-term financial time-series forecasts of indexes on different global markets. The particular area of interest of this research is to examine the correlation of these indexes’ behaviour in terms of Machine Learning algorithms cross-training. Would training an algorithm on an index from one global market produce similar or even better accuracy when such a model is applied for predicting another index from a different market? The demonstrated predominately positive answer to this question is another argument in favour of the long-debated Efficient Market Hypothesis of Eugene Fama. 1 Introduction The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) in the well-known form was popularized by Eugene Fama [ 4 ] in the late 60’s - the early ’70s, though the earliest documented high-level formulation was known since 16’th century [ 28 ] . In various forms of strictness, it postulates that all potentially available information is immediately incorporated into market prices. This quite radical and superficial (and, in a way, superstitious and superfluous) proposition was fiercely debated over time. The early discussion of the EMH hypothesis was primarily conducted by proponents of the hypothesis on the material of the developed markets, which led to over-confident conclusions. In the ’80s, the application of the theory was tested on emergent markets, which brought mixed results. In the ’90s, the challenge of the EMH became widespread, though, even in the 21st century, the discussion still continues [ 35 ] . The economic [ 21 ] , environment [ 20 ] , logical paradoxes [ 10 ] , and psychological [ 29 ] aspects of the debate are out of the scope of this paper. Machine Learning (ML) and statistical market prediction methods based on the previous historical data are the “bread and butter” of the practising traders and one of the arguments favouring the EMH [ 33 ] . However, even though these algorithms have some limited predicted power in plain form, they do not strictly show the use of the information in the predictions but possibly stochastic correlations. Research on tracing how publicly unknown information finds its way to the public and into market prices, the rate and cost of its dissipation is still to be conducted. In this research, we still use the indirect method. We investigate the hypothesis that if today’s global markets are affected by information, then their behaviour is correlated long-term. It is a trivial proposition, which has been debated for decades [ 3 ] , but we give it a practical spin in our applied research, going beyond usual statistics correlation analysis [ 18 ] . If we train an ML model on one index (potentially on one market) and then use it for index prediction of another index on another global market, and those predictions have similar or better accuracy (due to less over-fitting), then this correlation would be an argument in favour to EMH. In the study, we experiment with various Artificial Neural Network (ANN) architectures, the well-known easily assembled from the layers available in many ML libraries, more “exotic” that require additional manual coding, and developed from scratch by the authors, to ensure that cross-training effects are common and not bound to one particular ANN architecture. We show how successfully those ANN models work in long-term forecasting for 30 days when trained on the same index data and then when they are cross-trained. We use historical data from 2005 to the beginning of 2022 for the NASDAQ, Dow Jones, NIKKEI and DAX indexes to cover intra-market and cross-market effects. The contribution is organized in the following way: Section 2 presents closely related to the study’s existing work, Section 3 high-level describes ML algorithms chosen for the study, data sets and their partition, which were used in computational experiments, as well as accuracy metrics for algorithms’ evaluation. Section 4 lists hardware parameters and model configurable parameters, as well as details of the less-popular ANN architectures implemented from scratch. Section 5 shows the results of the experiments in diagram and table form, discusses these results and study limitations, draws conclusions and outlines future research directions. 2 Related work ML algorithms of different types were used for various markets, stock types, observation periods, and prediction intervals. Two classes of the ML algorithms, Decision Tree (DT) based and ANN-based, were used on the 10 years interval for the Tehran Stock Exchange data (financial, petroleum, mineral, and metal indexes) in [ 14 ] . Various prediction intervals ranging from 1 to 30 days in the future were used, measuring accuracy with four metrics. Unfortunately, the best results were reported over the whole time span and prediction intervals, which makes the research of limited interest. However, systematically, Long Short-term Memory (LSTM) ANN was reported as superior to other ML models. In [ 30 ] , not just composite indexes, but instead, stocks of the 25 individual companies on the Bucharest Stock Exchange were experimented with on the span of over 21 years. Two ANN models, LSTM and 1 -dimensional temporal Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), were used not just for accuracy calculation but also for the trading gain simulation in comparison with traditional simple trading tactics. Predictions were run on training intervals from 30 to 120 days, but with only 1 day prediction in the future at a time. Both architectures demonstrated superior performance compared to the simple tactics specialising in the window frequency for CNN or gain amounts for LSTM. Traditionally ML models are trained on the same indexes but on the previous chronological data. Of our particular interests are approaches of the ML models training on the different time series. “Cross-training” is not a well-established term; therefore, such methods come under various rubrics, such as ensembles, pre-training, and transfer learning. They include noise-augmented training data [ 36 ] , contrastive self-supervised learning targeting on the extraction of the augmented components [ 34 ] , averaged LSTM training on multiple index data [ 32 ] , or averaging of the ensemble of the models trained on the multiple indexes [ 7 ] . Although some similarities could be seen between the above-mentioned and presented research, it is worth pointing out that the aim of the existing research is the enriching training data of the pre-trained transfer-learning models with the superset of the patterns found either in other indexes (or domain) or synthetic time series. In our study, ANN models are trained on the index of one single market and then tested on the other three markets, and such experiments are applied to all four markets in a circular fashion. No averaging or other use of data from multiple markets for training is done because the study aims to experimentally confirm the alleged by EMH synchronicity of the markets, strong enough to have no need for averaging or multiple data sets pre-training. 3 Methods It could be easily seen in Figure 1 , Table 1 , the stock indexes used in this study and described in more detail in Section 3.2 , are correlated. Figure 1: Stock indexes NASDAQ, DOW, NIKKEI,