Schrödinger equation is ℛ \mathcal{R} -separable in toroidal coordinates

Matheus E. Pereira, Alexandre G. M. Schmidt · 2025

Read Schrödinger equation is ℛ \mathcal{R} -separable in toroidal coordinates by Matheus E. Pereira, Alexandre G. M. Schmidt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08646.txt.

Introduction

Matheus Pereira and Alexandre Schmidt solve the Schrödinger equation, the basic equation of quantum mechanics, in a coordinate system shaped like a donut. Toroidal coordinates fit ring-shaped systems, but the equation had never been separated and solved exactly in them before.

Using an irregular separation-of-variables method rarely tried in physics, they obtain exact solutions in both the classic Moon and Spencer toroidal system and an electromagnetic toroidal-poloidal variant. A surprise runs through the results: the angular momentum comes out fractional, a direct effect of the hole in the torus. Solutions cover several external potentials, including a magnetic field, and the authors add a plane-wave expansion and a Green function for later work.

Catalog record

CREATORMatheus E. Pereira, Alexandre G. M. Schmidt
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08646

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Schrödinger equation is ℛ \mathcal{R} -separable in toroidal coordinates Preprint: APS/123-QED Matheus E. Pereira, Alexandre G. M. Schmidt Abstract We present, for the first time, exact solutions for the Schrödinger equation in Moon and Spencer’s toroidal coordinates, and in the electromagnetic toroidal–poloidal coordinate systems. Curiously, both systems present a fractional angular momentum, because of the torus’s hole. We achieve these novel solutions using the irregular ℛ \mathcal{R} -separation of variables, an unexplored approach in Physics, which results in a wavefunction with fractional angular momentum eigenvalues. Numerous solutions for the Schrödinger equation in a variety of external potentials are shown, including an external magnetic field. A plane-wave expansion and a Green function are also presented, setting the stage for future progress in this area. I Introduction Usually, one of the steps to solve Schrödinger equation using simple separation of variables is to consult Moon and Spencer’s handbook 32 and find if the equation is said to be separable in a given coordinate system. Historically, it has been shown 33 ; 30 ; 31 ; 11 ; 12 that the free Schrödinger (Helmholtz) equation is simply separable in exactly eleven coordinate systems, while \mathcal{R} -separation is possible only for rotational coordinate systems, like spherical and spheroidal. Therefore, the challenge to solve the Helmholtz equation in any coordinate system that defies Moon and Spencer’s impossibility theorems remained open for decades. While most textbook problems revolve around symmetric configurations, which are contemplated by one of those eleven coordinate systems 4 , real-life physical applications are seldom trivial 40 ; 6 ; 26 . In particular, we found important contributions in the solution of the Laplace and hydrodynamic equations in bispherical coordinates 50 ; 44 ; 27 ; 17 . The theory of regular and irregular \mathcal{R} -separation can be found in the seminal works of Kalnins and Miller 22 ; 8 ; 23 ; 20 ; 21 . The toroidal geometry is widely known, for example, for shaping both donuts and tokamaks 36 ; 18 , which are devices designed to manipulate plasma at extremely high temperatures (hundreds of thousands of kelvins) 45 ; 7 . Because of its deceptively simple and symmetric shape, attempts to solve Helmholtz equation using Moon and Spencer’s toroidal coordinates or the electromagnetic toroidal–poloidal coordinates via simple separation of variables only resulted in failure. In the previous two decades, there have been several attempts to investigate the Schrödinger equation in toroidal coordinates, either on the torus surface or in a toroidal quantum well. Encinosa and collaborators studied numerically 15 bound states induced by curvature and in the presence of a magnetic field 16 . Schulze-Halberg 42 ; 43 also tackled the problem of a quantum particle adhered to a toroidal surface; however, the azimuthal quantum number was taken to be zero, and the geometrical potential was not taken into account. Encinosa also studied the quantum mechanical problem in an elliptical torus 13 and the role of hard and soft boundary conditions 14 , both using a numerical approach. Atanasov and collaborators also made an important contribution where they considered the geometrical potential, however, their results are valid for weak magnetic fields and certain approximations in the geometrical parameters 5 . In our paper we do not resort to approximations in these geometrical parameters, nor in particular choices of quantum numbers. The next section reveals the only known closed-form solution to the Helmholtz equation in Moon and Spencer’s toroidal coordinate system. Additionally, we present an alternative coordinate system in the same section to serve as a basis to the ensuing discussions. Solutions for a free particle and for a particle in an infinite potential well are shown in section III . The first is concisely written in terms of Bessel and exponential functions. The last are written using Heun functions 41 . Section IV presents a Green function and the plane-wave expansion. We conclude with a discussion and our final remarks in section V . II Preliminary considerations and an alternative toroidal coordinates II.1 A toroidal trouble Consider Moon and Spencer’s toroidal coordinate system \displaystyle x \displaystyle=\frac{R\sinh\tau\cos\phi}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}, \displaystyle y \displaystyle=\frac{R\sinh\tau\sin\phi}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}, \displaystyle z \displaystyle=\frac{R\sin\theta}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}. Here, R is a constant that describes the distance from the cartesian origin to a ring of radius R at the xy plane — the focal ring. More details can be found in the works of Moon and Spencer and of Weston 30 ; 31 ; 33 ; 47 ; 48 ; 46 . Now consider the Helmholtz equation in these coordinates 32 , \frac{(\cosh\tau-\cos\theta)^{3}}{R^{2}\sinh\tau}\Bigg[\sinh\tau\,\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}\left(\frac{1}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial\theta}\right)+\frac{\partial}{\partial\tau}\left(\frac{\sinh\tau}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial\tau}\right)\\ +\frac{1}{\sinh\tau(\cosh\tau-\cos\theta)}\frac{\partial^{2}\psi}{\partial\phi^{2}}\Bigg]+k^{2}\psi=0. (1) Ever since Moon and Spencer laid down their well-known works on separation of variables, it has been believed that a separable solution was impossible to achieve for such an equation. This is still true. However, more recent investigations by Kalnins, Miller, Prus and Sym 39 introduced a new type of solutions for partial differential equations, known as an irregular \mathcal{R} -separation of variables. Following the results of Prus and Sym, calculations revealed \displaystyle\psi(\tau,\theta,\phi) \displaystyle=N_{\pm}\exp{\left(\pm ikR\frac{\sinh\tau}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}\right)}\sqrt{e^{i\phi}\frac{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}{\sinh\tau}} (2) \displaystyle=e^{i\phi/2}\left[c_{1}J_{1/2}\left(kR\frac{\sinh\tau}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}\right)+c_{2}H_{1/2}^{(1)}\left(kR\frac{\sinh\tau}{\cosh\tau-\cos\theta}\right)\right] is the solution of Helmholtz equation ( 1 ) in toroidal coordinates using irregular \mathcal{R} -separation of variables 39 , where J_{\nu} is the ordinary Bessel function of order \nu and H_{\nu}^{(1)} is the Hankel function of the first kind with order \nu . A simple investigation reveals a troubling fact though, that this solution cannot be used for solving physical problems, in agreement with 39 . Indeed, consider the problem of a particle in an infinite toroidal well of minor radius a and major radius R . Because (0,0,0) is actually outside the well, we have c_{2} may not be zero. For integer n , we get \psi(a,\theta,\phi)=0\quad\rightarrow\quad kR\frac{\sinh a}{\cosh a-\cos\theta}=n\pi\quad\rightarrow\quad\cos\theta=\cosh a-\left(\frac{kR}{n\pi}\right)\sinh a, (3) revealing the well does not trap the particle except where \cos\theta obeys the last expression, which is not a valid condition for the particle in a well problem. II.2 The toroidal–poloidal coordinate system To remedy the situation explained in the previous section, consider the Dupin cyclide parametric equations, \displaystyle x \displaystyle=\frac{b^{2}\cos v\cosh\eta+w(c\cosh\eta-a\cos v)}{a\cosh\eta-c\cos v}, \displaystyle y \displaystyle=s_{y}\frac{b\sin v(a\cosh\eta-w)}{a\cosh\eta-c\cos v}, \displaystyle z \displaystyle=s_{z}\frac{b\sinh\eta(w-c\cos v)}{a\cosh\eta-c\cos v}. where s_{z} and s_{y} are dimensionless scaling quantities and c^{2}=a^{2}-b^{2} . Prus and Sym 39 studied the irregular \mathcal{R} -separation in this coordinate system, achieving some exact solutions for Helmholtz equation. We lift most of their restrictions, allowing the Dupin cyclide to reduce to a very special case. If a=b=R , these equations describe a ring circular torus whose minor and major radii are measured by w and R=b respectively. Namely, \displaystyle x \displaystyle=(R-w\sech\eta)\cos v, \displaystyle y \displaystyle=s_{y}(R-w\sech\eta)\sin v, \displaystyle z \displaystyle=s_{z}w\tanh\eta. This is not a good choice of coordinates, because it lacks periodicity in \eta , which is a necessary feature of toroidal symmetry. Morever, Prus and Sym 39 did solve the Helmholtz equation for the more general case, and their solution is not appropriate for physical problems, as they recognize. Therefore, we must make a dramatic change in these coordinates, in order to recover periodicity. Following Maxwell 28 , by transforming \cosh\eta\rightarrow\sec u and \sinh{\eta}\rightarrow\tan u we acquire \displaystyle x \displaystyle=(R+w\cos u)\cos v, (4) \displaystyle y \displaystyle=s_{y}(R+w\cos u)\sin v, \displaystyle z \displaystyle=s_{z}w\sin u, where s_{z}=\pm 1,s_{y}=\pm 1 and we made w\rightarrow-w for convenience. These are the parametric equations of a regular circular

Read the complete text