Dephasing-induced Quantum Hall Criticality in the Quantum Anomalous Hall system

Fei Yang, Dong E. Liu · 2025

Read Dephasing-induced Quantum Hall Criticality in the Quantum Anomalous Hall system by Fei Yang, Dong E. Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08635.txt.

Introduction

Fei Yang and Dong Liu challenge a basic belief about the quantum Hall effect: that frozen disorder in the material is what creates its flat plateaus. They show that pure dephasing, the loss of quantum phase coherence, can produce the same critical behavior on its own.

Starting from a Keldysh formulation, they derive an open-system sigma model with a topological term and no Cooperon sector, then show that instantons still drive the two-parameter flow of conductances. In a quantum anomalous Hall setting the theory predicts a critical point at half-integer Hall conductance with finite longitudinal conductance. Boundary-driven simulations of a standard lattice model with local dephasing match the prediction. The authors propose reading conductances from Hall potential maps as an experimental check.

Catalog record

CREATORFei Yang, Dong E. Liu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08635

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dephasing-induced Quantum Hall Criticality in the Quantum Anomalous Hall system Fei Yang, Dong E. Liu Abstract Conventional wisdom holds that static disorder is indispensable to the integer quantum Hall effect, underpinning both quantized plateaus and the plateau–plateau transition. We show that pure dephasing, without elastic disorder, is sufficient to generate the same θ \theta -driven criticality. Starting from a Keldysh formulation, we derive an open-system nonlinear σ \sigma model (NL σ \sigma M) for class A with a topological θ \theta term but no Cooperon sector, and we demonstrate that nonperturbative instantons still govern a two-parameter flow of ( σ x ​ x , σ x ​ y ) (\sigma_{xx},\sigma_{xy}) . Evaluating θ \theta in a dephasing quantum–anomalous-Hall setting, we predict a quantum Hall critical point at σ x ​ y = 1 / 2 \sigma_{xy}=1/2 with finite σ x ​ x \sigma_{xx} —the hallmark of the integer quantum Hall universality class realized without Anderson localization. Boundary-driven simulations of the Qi–Wu–Zhang model with local dephasing confirm this prediction and provide an experimentally aligned protocol to extract ( σ x ​ x , σ x ​ y ) (\sigma_{xx},\sigma_{xy}) from Hall-potential maps. By establishing dephasing as a self-contained route to Hall criticality, our framework reframes plateau physics in open solid-state and cold-atom platforms and offers practical diagnostics for topological transport in nonunitary matter. I Introduction Dephasing, ubiquitous across quantum platforms, governs the quantum-to-classical crossover quantum_2_classical ; quantum_2_classical_1 ; quantum_2_classical_2 and can generate novel many-body behavior optical_lattice_rev ; dephasing_many_body_1 ; dephasing_many_body_2 . Fundamentally, it is the weak-measurement–averaged dynamics of a system continuous_measure , this placing dephasing at the center of mixed-state topology mixed_topology ; mixed_topology_1 ; mixed_topology_2 ; mixed_topology_3 ; mixed_topology_4 and topological transport in open systems topology_transport . Intriguingly, the effect of dephasing is similar to that of disorder, continuous monitoring can drive phase transitions CM_phase_transition_0 ; CM_phase_transition ; CM_phase_transition_1 ; CM_phase_transition_2 ; CM_phase_transition_3 reminiscent of many-body localization MBL ; the corresponding effective description shares the non-linear \sigma -model (NL \sigma M) structure of Anderson localization NLSM_CM_1 ; NLSM_CM_2 ; NLSM_CM_3 . Moreover, dephasing tight-binding models become diffusive in the thermodynamic limit dephasing_enhenced , with a diffuson NL \sigma M as the field theory NLSM_dephasing . However, disorder and dephasing are fundamentally different: the former is static and unitary, whereas the latter is dynamical and non-unitary. Non-unitarity explicitly breaks time-reversal symmetry and forbids the cooperon, the time-reversed partner of the diffuson, so weak localization is absent in dephasing-dominated dynamics NLSM_dephasing . Localization under weak measurement is then attributable to the quantum Zeno effect quantum_zeno , not interference physics. These observations suggest that quantum Hall responses in a purely dephasing environment (without disorder) may differ qualitatively from conventional, disordered quantum Hall systems. Since dephasing is now a tunable control parameter in solids and ultracold atoms, resolving the quantum Hall effect under pure dephasing is both timely and essential. Prior studies examined dephasing in disordered quantum Hall settings dephasing_TIs ; dephasing_QHE , yet the disorder-free, pure-dephasing regime remains unexplored. Intuitively, diffusion in dephasing systems is described by an NL \sigma M, while the universal structure of the integer quantum Hall effect is encoded by an NL \sigma M with a topological \theta -term. Thus, a central open question is whether the \theta -term and its nonperturbative phenomena survive in a non-unitary, open setting. In this work, we resolve this issue by investigating a dephasing quantum anomalous Hall (QAH) system, in which an open-system NL \sigma M with a topological \theta term is derived. Unlike static disorder, dephasing is inelastic and non-unitary yet leaves the \theta sector intact, so instantons and the Pruisken’s two-parameter flow survive in an open setting. Nonperturbative instantons generate a renormalization-group (RG) flow, enabling a \theta -controlled quantum phase transition. We identify a critical dephasing rate \gamma_{c} , that separates a robust topological phase ( \gamma<\gamma_{c} ) from a trivial one ( \gamma>\gamma_{c} ). The two phases are distinguished by their RG trajectories and finite-size scaling, verified in a boundary-driven Qi–Wu–Zhang (QWZ) model. Numerically, dephasing tight-binding dynamics is diffusive rather than Anderson localized, showing that open-system Hall transport differs qualitatively from disorder-driven transport. We show that dephasing or a weak-measurement/monitoring channel provides a self-contained pathway to integer quantum Hall criticality via the \theta -sector. II Fermionic gases under dephasing Microscopically, dephasing typically arises from inelastic scattering (e.g., electron–phonon interactions) origin_dephasing ; origin_dephasing_1 , which progressively suppresses phase coherence. More broadly, dephasing is an intrinsic feature of open-system dynamics. For fermionic gases it can be captured phenomenologically by Büttiker probes Buttiker_prob or, more systematically, by the particle-number-conserving Lindblad master equation dephasing_many_body ; dephasing_enhenced ; continuous_measure \frac{d}{dt}\rho(t)=-i[\hat{H},\rho(t)]-\frac{\gamma}{2}\sum_{j}\left[\hat{n}_{j},\left[\hat{n}_{j},\rho(t)\right]\right]. (1) Here \hat{n}_{j}=c_{j}^{\dagger}c_{j} denotes the local density and \gamma the dephasing rate. The main structure is the double-commutator (recycling) term on the right-hand side, \hat{n}_{j}\rho(t)\hat{n}_{j} , which, in stochastic unravelings or the Keldysh field theory, generates multiplicative noise and effective quartic couplings. These induce mesoscopic fluctuation effects that, at the level of transport and correlations, closely parallel those produced by static disorder. Recent work shows that these mesoscopic fluctuations are captured by an NL \sigma M NLSM_dephasing with action S_{0}[Q]=\frac{\sigma_{xx}}{8}\!\int d^{d}x\,\mathrm{Tr}\!\left[\partial_{i}Q(x)\,\partial_{i}Q(x)\right], (2) where the matrix field Q(x) represents the diffuson Goldstone modes arising from causal-symmetry breaking. This mirrors the disordered NL \sigma M, except that dephasing explicitly breaks time-reversal symmetry, eliminating the cooperon (the time-reversed partner of the diffuson). Consequently, weak (anti)localization from quantum interference is absent, and the longitudinal conductivity, \sigma_{xx}\!\propto\!1/\gamma , is scale-invariant. III Effective filed theory of QAH under dephasing The experimental QAH discovery in magnetically doped topological insulators observation_QAH established that quantized Hall physics need not rely on Landau levels but can instead robustly emerge from time-reversal breaking together with strong spin–orbit coupling. Absence of time-reversal symmetry explicitly places the ferimoic systems in class A, whose NL \sigma M admits a topological \theta -term in even spatial dimensions anderson_transition . This term provides the effective field theory of the integer quantum Hall effect and also of disordered QAH systems disorder_qwz . Here, we theoretically examine the QAH system under dephasing, that a most simple QAH system—the QWZ model qwz_model is studied, whose effective action is an NL \sigma M with \theta -term. The QWZ model is defined by the Bloch Hamiltonian H(\mathbf{k})=h_{a}(\mathbf{k})\sigma^{a} , where \vec{h}(\mathbf{k})=(\sin k_{x},\sin k_{y},u+\cos k_{x}+\cos k_{y}) , the Pauli matrix structure is defined in A/B -sublattices space, u is the staggering potential. Its topological property is captured by the Chern number C=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int_{BZ}dk_{x}dk_{y}\vec{n}\cdot\left(\vec{n}\times\vec{n}\right) , where the unit vector is \vec{n}=\vec{h}/|\vec{h}| , i.e., C counts the times that Pauli vector \vec{h} winding around the unit sphere. Nonzero Chern number exists when |u|<2 : To be exact C=-1 for 0<u<2 and C=1 for -2<u<0 correspondingly. However, the topology of the system under dephasing is no longer characterized by the momentum space invariants, an effective field theory defined in real space is required. With the Keldysh contour integral of the Lindblad master equation in Eq. ( 1 ), the action of fermionic gases under dephasing is obtained as (see Supplemental Material, Sec. I) S=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dt_{1}dt_{2}\bar{\Psi}_{t_{1}}\tilde{G}_{0}^{-1}(t_{1},t_{2})\Psi_{t_{2}}+\frac{i\gamma}{2}\int dt\bar{\Psi}_{t}\Psi_{t}\bar{\Psi}_{t}\Psi_{t}, (3) where \bar{\Psi}=\left(\bar{\psi}_{1},\bar{\psi}_{2}\right) is defined in the retarded and advanced space. And the nonequilibrium Green’s function is \displaystyle\tilde{G}_{0}(\varepsilon,\mathbf{k}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\begin{pmatrix}\tilde{G}^{R}(\varepsilon,\mathbf{k})\,\,\,&\tilde{G}^{K}(\varepsilon,\mathbf{k})\\ 0&\tilde{G}^{A}(\varepsilon,\mathbf{k})\end{pmatrix}, (4) where \tilde{G}^{R/A}(\varepsilon,\mathbf{k})=\left(\varepsilon-\xi_{\mathbf{k}}\pm i\frac{\gamma}{2}\right)^{-1} , \xi_{\mathbf{k}} is the spectrum of system. The Keldysh Green’s function is

Read the complete text