The effects of International Monetary Fund programs: a systematic review with narrative synthesis on poverty, inequality, and social indicators

Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero · 2025

Read The effects of International Monetary Fund programs: a systematic review with narrative synthesis on poverty, inequality, and social indicators by Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08617.txt.

Introduction

Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero reviews what research says about the social costs of International Monetary Fund programs. Following PRISMA guidelines, the review searches five large archives plus grey literature and keeps fifty-three studies that pass a screening, each checked for risk of bias.

Studies using weaker designs, often propensity score matching, tend to report no clear pattern of harm. Work with stronger research designs, especially instrumental variable methods, tells a darker story. Those studies link the Fund's terms to higher income inequality, worse health results including tuberculosis and child deaths, and a larger informal economy. Salguero concludes that austerity-centered programs carry real social costs and that the Fund's terms should be redesigned to protect social spending.

Catalog record

CREATORRicardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08617

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The effects of International Monetary Fund programs: a systematic review with narrative synthesis on poverty, inequality, and social indicators Ricardo Alonzo Fernández Salguero Abstract Background: The debate over the impact of the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) structural adjustment programs on borrowing countries has been a central topic in political economy for decades. The empirical evidence is profoundly heterogeneous and often contradictory. Objective: This systematic review with narrative synthesis synthesizes and critically analyzes the literature to assess the effects of such programs on key indicators like poverty, income inequality, social spending (health and education), health outcomes (mortality, infectious diseases), the labor market, and informality. Methods: A systematic search was conducted in five academic databases and grey literature, following PRISMA guidelines. A total of 53 studies and empirical contributions that met predefined selection criteria were included. The risk of bias for each study was assessed, paying special attention to the control of endogeneity and selection bias. Due to the methodological heterogeneity of the studies, the results were synthesized narratively. Results: A minority of studies, often employing methodologies with a higher risk of bias such as Propensity Score Matching (PSM), find no significant negative effects. In contrast, a robust body of research, using quasi-experimental designs with a low risk of bias like Instrumental Variables (IV), documents an increase in inequality, a deterioration of health outcomes (especially in tuberculosis and child mortality), and a rise in the informal economy as a consequence of IMF conditionalities. Conclusion: The differences in findings are largely attributed to the diversity of methodologies and the rigor with which they address causal inference. Higher-quality evidence suggests that IMF programs, particularly those with austerity conditionalities and structural reforms, impose significant social costs. These impacts call for a redesign of conditionality that prioritizes social protection to meet the Sustainable Development Goals. 1 Introduction The International Monetary Fund (IMF), since its creation at Bretton Woods, has played a central role in the global financial architecture, primarily through the provision of loans to countries facing balance of payments crises. These loans, however, are not unconditional; they are accompanied by a set of economic policy reforms, known as conditionalities, which aim to stabilize the macroeconomy and lay the groundwork for sustainable growth ( Joyce, 2004 ) . The nature and rigor of these conditionalities have evolved, from the emphasis on austerity and liberalization of the ”Washington Consensus” to a more recent discourse that incorporates the importance of social spending and inclusive growth. Nevertheless, in practice, structural adjustment policies have historically included measures of fiscal consolidation, trade and financial sector liberalization, privatization of state-owned enterprises, and labor market reforms ( Andritzky et al., 2021 ) . The effectiveness and consequences of these programs have been the subject of intense academic and political debate. Supporters of the IMF argue that its interventions are a necessary, albeit sometimes bitter, remedy to correct unsustainable macroeconomic imbalances and that, in the long run, they promote stability and growth ( Doroodian, 1994 ; Balima and Sokolova, 2020 ) . Although Balima and Sokolova, 2020 reports publication bias, they do not correct for it in their meta-analysis, which could change their conclusions. From this perspective, any negative social impact is considered a transitory and unavoidable cost of a necessary adjustment, or it is attributed to the pre-existing crisis that motivated the intervention and not to the program itself ( Eicher et al., 2024 ) . On the other hand, a vast critical literature argues that IMF policies, especially austerity measures, impose disproportionate social costs, exacerbating poverty and inequality, weakening health and education systems, and harming the most vulnerable populations ( Stuckler and Basu, 2009 ; Lang, 2016 ; Stubbs et al., 2021 ) . This review delves into this complex and polarized debate with a distinctive approach. Unlike previous reviews, which often focus on a single sector such as health ( Thomson et al., 2017 ) or on purely macroeconomic outcomes, this research offers several key contributions. First, it provides a multidimensional scope by synthesizing evidence across a broad spectrum of interconnected social outcomes: poverty, inequality, social spending, health, mortality, labor market, and informality. Second, it presents an updated and comprehensive coverage of the literature, incorporating the most recent studies and allowing for a view of the evolution of conditionality and its evaluation over time. Finally, and crucially, it uses the comparative analysis of research methodologies as the primary lens to explain the divergences in findings, arguing that rigor in addressing causal inference is a key predictor of the studies’ conclusions. By grouping and comparing studies not only by their conclusions but also by their methodological designs and quality assessment, this review aims to offer a nuanced overview that recognizes the contingency of the IMF’s effects and the inherent complexities in their evaluation. 2 Review Methodology This research is structured as a systematic review with a narrative synthesis, an approach designed to map, interpret, and critically synthesize the diverse and often methodologically heterogeneous evidence on the socioeconomic impacts of IMF programs. To ensure transparency and rigor, the reporting process adhered to the PRISMA 2020 (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) checklist guidelines ( Page et al., 2021 ) . Given that the intervention measures (types of programs and conditionalities) and outcomes (different social indicators) vary considerably among studies, a quantitative meta-analysis was not feasible. Instead, a narrative synthesis was chosen, which allows for contextualizing contradictory findings, with special attention to the methodological designs underlying each study’s conclusions. 2.1 Search and Identification Strategy A systematic literature search was conducted during the period from July 5, 2025, to October 16, 2025. The search covered five top-tier academic databases to ensure multidisciplinary coverage: Scopus and Web of Science for their broad scope; PubMed for its specialization in public health; EconLit for its focus on economic literature; and Google Scholar to capture additional studies and grey literature. A sensitive Boolean search strategy was designed and applied, adapted to the syntax of each database, combining key terms related to the intervention and outcomes of interest. The search logic was as follows: ("International Monetary Fund" OR "IMF") AND ("structural adjustment" OR "conditionality" OR "austerity" OR "IMF program*") AND ("poverty" OR "inequality" OR "social spending" OR "health outcome*" OR "education" OR "infant mortality" OR "maternal mortality" OR "labor market" OR "informal economy" OR "gender gap") To complement the database search, a manual search of grey literature was performed, including working papers from the IMF, the World Bank, and reports from relevant non-governmental organizations (e.g., Oxfam, Center for Economic and Policy Research). Additionally, a ”snowballing” technique was applied, systematically reviewing the reference lists of key articles and systematic reviews identified to capture further studies. This exhaustive search process yielded an initial total of 845 records. 2.2 Selection Criteria and Screening The study selection process was guided by a set of predefined and rigorous inclusion and exclusion criteria, which are summarized in Table 1 . The goal was to include only empirical studies that directly evaluated the impact of IMF programs on social indicators in low- and middle-income countries. Purely theoretical studies, commentaries, and analyses focused exclusively on macroeconomic outcomes without an explicit link to social welfare were excluded. The screening of records was conducted in two phases by

Read the complete text