Even Temperley–Lieb algebras and the dga of planar loops

Rachael Boyd, Guy Boyde, Oscar Randal-Williams, Robin J. Sroka · 2025

Read Even Temperley–Lieb algebras and the dga of planar loops by Rachael Boyd, Guy Boyde, Oscar Randal-Williams, Robin J. Sroka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08550.txt.

Introduction

Rachael Boyd and three co-authors study the homology of Temperley-Lieb algebras, algebraic objects that arise from diagrams of strands and loops. They restrict attention to algebras built on an even number of strands, where the homology turns out to be rich and often far from trivial.

The key claim is that one smaller structure controls all of this homology: a differential graded algebra built from planar loops. The authors construct a small model for that algebra, small enough to compute with directly. Feeding the model back into the problem yields concrete consequences for the homology of the original algebras. The work ties a diagram-based algebra to loop geometry in a precise, usable way.

Catalog record

CREATORRachael Boyd, Guy Boyde, Oscar Randal-Williams, Robin J. Sroka
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08550

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Even Temperley–Lieb algebras and the dga of planar loops Rachael Boyd, Guy Boyde, Oscar Randal-Williams, Robin J. Sroka Abstract . We show that the homology of a Temperley–Lieb algebra on an even number of strands has a rich algebraic structure and is highly nontrivial in general. This is achieved by proving that it is entirely governed by a differential graded algebra: the differential graded algebra of planar loops. We provide a small model for this dga, and use it to obtain consequences on homology. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 20J06, 16E40, 16E45 1. Introduction Given R a unital commutative ring, a\in R and n\geq 0 a natural number, the Temperley–Lieb algebra is a diagrammatic algebra denoted \TL_{n}(R,a) . The goal of this paper is to calculate the homology groups \Tor_{*}^{\TL_{n}(R,a)}(R,R) of this algebra when n is even, complementing the calculation [ Sro24 ] of the last-named author which treated the case n odd. While the homology turned out to be trivial in positive degrees when n is odd, this work shows that it has a rich structure when n is even. The core of the calculation is to describe the homology of an associated object, which we call the differential graded algebra of planar loops. This object can be introduced in a stand-alone way, so we first do so and describe our results in this direction, then later explain their connection to Temperley–Lieb algebras. 1.1. The differential graded algebra of planar loops We introduce the differential graded R -algebra (dga) of planar loops L(2n)=L(2n;R,a) . Its chain module in degree p , L(2n)_{p} , is defined to be the free R -module on the set of all systems of planar loops (of height 2n ) pinned by p bars , described as follows. • Place p vertical lines ( bars ) in the plane. Mark 2n points on each bar: we call these nodes . • A basis element of L(2n)_{p} is an isotopy class of a number of disjoint circles ( loops ) in the plane. Then we require that each loop contains at least two nodes, and that every node is in precisely one loop, see Figure 1 . We think of the bars as ‘pinning’ the loops. The differential of L(2n) is given as an alternating sum of face maps. The k -th face map removes the k -th bar: we take the resulting isotopy class (now with p-1 bars), and for each loop which is completely ‘unpinned’ by the removal of this bar, we discard the loop and multiply by a\in R ( Figure 1 , Part \mathrm{(a)} ). Juxtaposing two such pictures defines a graded multiplication which gives L(2n) the structure of a dga ( Figure 1 , Part \mathrm{(b)} ). The dga L(2n) also arises from a bar construction on the Temperley–Lieb algebra \TL_{2n}(R,a) , see Section 2.2 , and it is this algebraic description that we will work with in the main body of this article. \mathrm{(a)} d\Biggl( \Biggr) = - + a^{2}\cdot \mathrm{(b)} \cdot = Figure 1. With 2n=4 : \mathrm{(a)} a typical basis element of L(4)_{3} , with the differential d applied (‘barwise’) to that element, and \mathrm{(b)} the (‘juxtaposition’) product. Our main theorem gives a small model for the dga of planar loops. To state it we introduce the notation \Phi\in L(2n;R,a)_{1} for the element shown in Figure 2 . Its key feature is that the underlying diagram consists of a single loop, so it satisfies d(\Phi)=a , and is a cycle if and only if a=0 . \Phi= , , , Figure 2. The element \Phi\in L(2n)_{1} , shown (left-to-right) for 2n=2,4,6,8 . Theorem 1.1 . There is a weak equivalence (T_{R}[x_{1},x_{3},\ldots,x_{2n-1}],d)\overset{\sim}{\to}L(2n;R,a) of differential graded R -algebras, where the left-hand side is the tensor algebra on the generators x_{i} of degree i equipped with the differential given by d(x_{1})=a\text{ and }d(x_{2i-1})=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}j+k=i\\ j,k>0\end{subarray}}\binom{i}{j}x_{2j-1}x_{2k-1}\text{ for }2i-1>1. Under this equivalence x_{1} is mapped to \Phi . This is a quasi-free (hence cofibrant) model for L(2n;R,a) , and is minimal in any reasonable sense. The model is completely explicit and can be directly used to calculate H_{*}(L(2n;R,a)) to some extent. However, as we shall see in Section 4.2 , the most powerful computational tool is to observe that in the case a=0 this model is simply the cobar construction of an explicit coalgebra over R . The R -linear dual of this coalgebra is the R -algebra A_{n}:=\Gamma_{R}[y]/(y^{[i]},i\geq n+1), i.e. a truncated divided power algebra. This leads to an algebra isomorphism H_{*}(L(2n;R,0))\cong\Ext^{*}_{A_{n}}(R,R). Hence, the homology of L(2n;R,0) may be calculated by a minimal resolution of R as an A_{n} -module, instead of the cobar complex (T_{R}[x_{1},x_{3},\ldots,x_{2n-1}],d) . This renders calculations much more tractable. In Section 2.5 we describe some simple tools for reducing calculations over (R,a) to calculations over (\mathbb{Z}[a],a) , and then to calculations over (\mathbb{Z},0) , so treating the case a=0 is not a major loss of generality. We include the following selection of explicit calculations obtained using the model, the observation above, and several other techniques. We will justify these calculations in Section 4 , where we give slightly more precise statements. Corollary 1.2 . (a) H_{0}(L(2n;R,a))=R/a , so the R -module structure on H_{i}(L(2n;R,a)) descends to R/a , i.e. the homology groups are all annihilated by a . (b) For 2n=2 there is an isomorphism H_{*}(L(2;R,0))\cong R[\Phi] of graded algebras, with |\Phi|=1 . (c) If n!\in R^{\times} and 2n\geq 4 then there is an isomorphism H_{*}(L(2n;R,0))\cong R[\Phi,\alpha]/(\Phi^{2}) of graded algebras, with |\Phi|=1 and |\alpha|=2n . Furthermore, the class \alpha may be described as the (n+1) -fold Massey product \langle\Phi,\Phi,\ldots,\Phi\rangle . (d) If a\in R is not a zerodivisor and n!\in(R/a)^{\times} then there is an isomorphism H_{*}(L(2n;R,a))\cong R/a[\beta] of graded algebras, with |\beta|=2n . The class \beta is uniquely determined by the property that under the change-of-rings map for (R,a)\to(R/a,0) it maps to the class \alpha\in H_{2n}(L(2n;R/a,0)) described in (c) (or to \Phi^{2} if 2n=2 ). (e) H_{*}(L(4;\mathbb{Z},0)) only has 2-torsion, which is all simple. Modulo torsion there is an isomorphism H_{*}(L(4;\mathbb{Z},0))/\text{torsion}\cong\mathbb{Z}[\Phi,\gamma]/(\Phi^{2}) of graded algebras, with |\Phi|=1 and |\gamma|=4 . We may take \gamma:=\langle\Phi,2\Phi,\Phi\rangle . The Poincaré series for the \mathbb{Z}/2 -dimension of the simple 2-torsion is \frac{t^{2}}{(1-t-t^{3})(1-t^{4})}=t^{2}+t^{3}+t^{4}+2t^{5}+4t^{6}+5t^{7}+7t^{8}+\cdots. 1.2. Relation to the homology of Temperley–Lieb algebras The algebra of planar loops arose naturally while we were investigating the homology, by which we mean \Tor_{*}^{\TL_{2n}(R,a)}(R,R) , of the Temperley–Lieb algebra \TL_{2n}=\TL_{2n}(R,a) . Recall that these algebras are free R -modules on a basis of Temperley–Lieb (2n,2n) -diagrams. These diagrams correspond to planar matchings between two bars each with 2n nodes, with a multiplication which concatenates diagrams and replaces loops with factors of a . An example multiplication is shown in Figure 3 . \cdot = = a\cdot Figure 3. Multiplication in the Temperley–Lieb algebra \TL_{4} . These algebras, and some of their modules, already implicitly appeared in our description of the complex of planar loops: we will define them formally in Section 2.1 as endomorphism objects in the Temperley–Lieb category \TL . Our formal definition of the differential graded algebra of planar loops L(2n) uses \TL_{2n} explicitly. The relationship between \Tor_{*}^{\TL_{2n}}(R,R) and the homology of L(2n) is as follows. Theorem 1.3 . There are R -module isomorphisms \Tor_{i}^{\TL_{2n}(R,a)}(R,R)\cong\begin{cases}R&i=0\\ 0&0<i<2n-1\\ H_{i-2n+1}(L(2n;R,a))&2n-1\leq i.\end{cases} Combined

Read the complete text