Experimental road of the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi mass spectrum, current status, and implications
Hongjian Zhou 1, Xining Wang 2, Feng Zhu 1, Liming Zhang 3, Gerry Bauer 1, and Kai Yi 1 · 2025
Read Experimental road of the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi mass spectrum, current status, and implications by Hongjian Zhou 1, Xining Wang 2, Feng Zhu 1, Liming Zhang 3, Gerry Bauer 1, and Kai Yi 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08495.txt.
Introduction
Hongjian Zhou and co-authors review the experimental history of the J psi phi mass spectrum, a hunting ground for exotic hadron structures since 2009. The CDF experiment first reported the X(4140) structure, and later searches in related channels claimed ten structures in one decay system. LHCb amplitude analyses and diffractive studies form the backbone of the modern picture, alongside theoretical interpretations of the claimed states.
A triplet of states with the same quantum numbers and wide mass spacing appears to form a radially excited family, with X(4140) as its first member. Its measured width still disagrees between experiments, and the review discusses possible reasons. Parallels with the double J psi system close the discussion.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hongjian Zhou 1, Xining Wang 2, Feng Zhu 1, Liming Zhang 3, Gerry Bauer 1, and Kai Yi 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08495
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Experimental road of the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi mass spectrum, current status, and implications Hongjian Zhou 1, Xining Wang 2, Feng Zhu 1, Liming Zhang 3, Gerry Bauer 1, and Kai Yi 1 Abstract Inspired by the X ( 4140 ) X(4140) structure reported in the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi system by the CDF experiment in 2009, a series of searches have been carried out in the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi and J / ψ K J/\psi K channels, leading to the claim of ten structures in the B → J / ψ ϕ K B\rightarrow J/\psi\phi K system. This article provides a comprehensive review of experimental developments, from the initial evidence of X ( 4140 ) X(4140) at CDF to the amplitude analyses and diffractive process investigations by the LHCb experiment, as well as theoretical interpretations of these states. A triplet of J P C = 1 + + J^{PC}=1^{++} states with relatively large mass splittings [about 200 MeV (natural units are adopted)] has been identified in the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi system by LHCb. Their mass-squared values align approximately linearly with a possible radial quantum number, suggesting that the triplet may represent a radially excited family. For X ( 4140 ) X(4140) , the first state in the triplet, its width reported by LHCb is inconsistent with that measured by other experiments, and possible reasons for this discrepancy are discussed. A potential connection between an excess at 4.35 GeV in the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi mass spectrum reported by the Belle experiment through a two-photon process and a potential spin-2 excess in the LHCb data is also investigated. In addition, potential parallels between the J / ψ ϕ J/\psi\phi and J / ψ J / ψ J/\psi J/\psi systems, both composed of two vector mesons, are discussed. The continued interest in, and complexity of, these systems underscore the necessity of further experimental exploration with increased statistical precision across a variety of experiments, particularly those with relatively flat efficiency across the Dalitz plot. The J / ψ ω J/\psi\omega , ϕ ϕ \phi\phi , ρ ω \rho\omega , and ρ ϕ \rho\phi systems are mentioned, and the prospects for the J / ψ Υ J/\psi\Upsilon and Υ Υ \Upsilon\Upsilon systems, are also highlighted. keywords heavy flavors; tetraquark; amplitude analysis; vector-vector final state; radially excited family. 1 Introduction Heavy-flavor quarks have historically played a vital role in establishing and validating the quark model, most notably exemplified by the discovery and study of the J/\psi meson and its excitations. Similarly, they have been central to the exploration and identification of exotic hadronic states, as extensively reviewed in [ 1 ] . Among the quarks, charm ( c ), bottom ( b ), and top ( t ) are classified as heavy flavors; up ( u ) and down ( d ) as light flavors; while strange ( s ) occupies an intermediate position. While systems composed solely of heavy quarks, such as X\rightarrow J/\psi J/\psi [ 1 ] , provide a unique perspective on exotic hadrons, the present review concentrates on systems without light quarks, with emphasis on the J/\psi\phi system. Experimental reviews of structures in the J/\psi\phi mass spectrum have been published in 2013 [ 2 ] and 2018 [ 3 ] . Since then, several new structures have been discovered [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . With more than a decade having passed since the first review, substantial progress has been made in studies of the J/\psi\phi system, as well as in the development of the J/\psi K^{+} system. The exploration of the J/\psi\phi system has proven complex and challenging, and its history continues to unfold. Recent results from LHCb, using an amplitude analysis [ 4 ] , have revealed numerous new resonances, two of which have been independently confirmed. Yet the intricacies of this system remain unresolved, and much of its nature is still unknown. At present, the leading experiments investigating the J/\psi\phi system are the CMS and LHCb experiments, both of which benefit from the significantly higher integrated luminosities collected in recent years. In light of these advances, a new comprehensive review of the subject is timely. Progress has been made in the similar system J/\psi J/\psi [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , with a recent and significant advance achieved by CMS using data collected from 2016 to 2018 and from 2022 to 2024. Three structures, named X(6600) , X(6900) , and X(7100) , are identified, and interference effects between them are determined. All these structures, together with their interferences, are observed with statistical significances well above 5 \sigma , implying common J^{PC} quantum numbers [ 10 ] . X(6900) has been confirmed, and evidence for X(7100) has been reported in an independent decay mode, J/\psi\psi(2S)\rightarrow\mu^{+}\mu^{-}\mu^{+}\mu^{-} [ 11 ] . The squared masses of the structures fall on a line consistent with radial excitations [ 1 ] , with widths that systematically decrease as the mass increases. CMS also measured their J^{PC} using the 2016–2018 dataset, showing that the data favor the 2^{++} assignment, with other possibilities excluded at least at the 95% confidence level [ 12 ] . These features disfavor molecular or threshold interpretations and instead support a J^{PC}=2^{++} tetraquark picture composed of aligned spin-1 diquarks without orbital excitation [ 10 , 12 ] . Spin-2 states are rare among both conventional and exotic hadrons. Since 2003, when the first heavy-exotic was discovered [ 13 ] , around 60 exotic hadrons have been discovered, including 23 at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), yet none have been firmly established with J=2 . The J/\psi\phi and J/\psi J/\psi systems provide favorable environments to search for spin-2 particles, as both the J/\psi and the \phi mesons carry spin-1. However, the production of spin-2 particles can be suppressed if they originate from a spin-0 system, such as the B meson, as will be discussed in detail later. A potential structure with J^{P}=2^{-} has been reported in the J/\psi\phi system [ 4 ] , but it does not reach the 5 \sigma significance threshold and has not been confirmed by other experiments. Another possible spin-2 state, around the 4.35 GeV region in the J/\psi\phi mass spectrum, is noted in this article. Among the many states claimed in the J/\psi\phi system, three share identical quantum numbers, J^{PC}=1^{++} , yet display large mass splittings of about 200 MeV. These states may potentially form a family of radial excitations. This article begins with a brief recap of studies in the J/\psi\phi system prior to 2013, and then primarily outlines the experimental landscape of the J/\psi\phi structures from 2013 to the most recent developments. The main focus is on the J/\psi\phi system, while the J/\psi K system is also briefly discussed, since these two can correspond to different two-body subsystems within the same three-body decay process B^{+}\to J/\psi\phi K^{+} , and are dynamically coupled. These experimental results are combined with theoretical studies to shed further light on the nature of exotic hadrons. In addition, the connection between the J/\psi J/\psi and J/\psi\phi systems is