First-Order Axiom Systems ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} and ℰ d ​ a \mathscr{E}_{da} Extending Tarski’s ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} with Distance and Angle Function Symbols for Quantitative Euclidean Geometry

Hongyu Guo · 2025

Read First-Order Axiom Systems ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} and ℰ d ​ a \mathscr{E}_{da} Extending Tarski’s ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} with Distance and Angle Function Symbols for Quantitative Euclidean Geometry by Hongyu Guo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08494.txt.

Introduction

Hongyu Guo rebuilds Euclidean geometry on a single distance function, extending Tarski famous first order axiom system for the subject. Tarski system is complete and decidable, yet it cannot state the Pythagorean theorem directly because distance is not a primitive notion in its language. The new system works in a two sorted language where a two place distance function is the only geometric primitive, making numerical distance directly expressible.

An extension adds a three place angle function as well. The axiom of similarity does double duty: it grounds proportion and similarity theory rigorously and implies the parallel postulate, acting as a quantitative form of it. Pythagoras theorem and other quantitative similarity results can finally be stated inside the system.

Catalog record

CREATORHongyu Guo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE102 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08494

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

First-Order Axiom Systems ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} and ℰ d ​ a \mathscr{E}_{da} Extending Tarski’s ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} with Distance and Angle Function Symbols for Quantitative Euclidean Geometry Hongyu Guo Abstract Tarski’s first-order axiom system ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} for Euclidean geometry is notable for its completeness and decidability. However, the Pythagorean theorem—either in its modern algebraic form a 2 + b 2 = c 2 a^{2}+b^{2}=c^{2} or in Euclid’s Elements —cannot be directly expressed in ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} , since neither distance nor area is a primitive notion in the language of ℰ 2 \mathscr{E}_{2} . In this paper, we introduce an alternative axiom system ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} in a two-sorted language, which takes a two-place distance function d d as the only geometric primitive. We also present a conservative extension ℰ d ​ a \mathscr{E}_{da} of it, which also incorporates a three-place angle function a a , both formulated strictly within first-order logic. The system ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} has two distinctive features: it is simple (with a single geometric primitive) and it is quantitative. Numerical distance can be directly expressed in this language. The Axiom of Similarity plays a central role in ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} , effectively killing two birds with one stone: it provides a rigorous foundation for the theory of proportion and similarity, and it implies Euclid’s Parallel Postulate (EPP). The Axiom of Similarity can be viewed as a quantitative formulation of EPP. The Pythagorean theorem and other quantitative results from similarity theory can be directly expressed in the languages of ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} and ℰ d ​ a \mathscr{E}_{da} , motivating the name Quantitative Euclidean Geometry . The traditional analytic geometry can be united under synthetic geometry in ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} . Namely, analytic geometry is not treated as a model of ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} , but rather, its statements can be expressed as first-order formal sentences in the language of ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} . The system ℰ d \mathscr{E}_{d} is shown to be consistent, complete, and decidable. Finally, we extend the theories to hyperbolic geometry and Euclidean geometry in higher dimensions. keywords quantitative Euclidean geometry; hyperbolic geometry; distance function; angle function; axiom of similarity; Tarski’s axioms; real closed fields; completeness; decidability MSC 03B30; 03C35; 51M05; 51M10 † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 13 † † issue: 21 † † articlenumber: 3462 † † year: 2025 † † copyright-year: 2025 † † external-editor: Adara M. Blaga † † received: 18 July 2025 † † revised: 25 September 2025 † † accepted: 25 September 2025 † † published: 30 October 2025 † † hreflink: https://doi.org/10.3390/math13213462 † † titlecitation: First-Order Axiom Systems \mathscr{E}_{d} and \mathscr{E}_{da} Extending Tarski’s \mathscr{E}_{2} with Distance and Angle Function Symbols for Quantitative Euclidean Geometry † † authornames: Hongyu Guo † † authorcitation: Guo, H. † † address: Department of Computer and Information Sciences, Texas A&M University–Victoria, Victoria, TX 77901, USA; [email protected] † † reftitle: References Contents 1. Introduction 2. Theory \mathscr{E}_{d} —Quantitative Euclidean Geometry with a Single Geometric Primitive Notion—Distance Function d 3. Analytic Geometry United under Synthetic Geometry in \mathscr{E}_{d} 4. Theory \mathscr{E}_{da} —A Conservative Extension of \mathscr{E}_{d} with Angle Function a 5. Consistency of \mathscr{E}_{d} and \mathscr{E}_{da} 6. Theory \mathscr{E}_{d} and Tarski’s \mathscr{E}_{2} Are Mutually Interpretable with Parameters 7. Completeness and Decidability of \mathscr{E}_{d} 8. Theory \mathscr{H}_{da} —Quantitative Hyperbolic Geometry 9. Theories \mathscr{E}_{d}^{n} and \mathscr{E}_{da}^{n} —Quantitative Euclidean Geometry in Higher Dimensions Appendix A . Axioms of Real Closed Fields (RCF) Appendix B . Tarski’s Axioms of Plane Euclidean Geometry \mathscr{E}_{2} Appendix C . SMSG Axioms of Euclidean Geometry Appendix D . The Convoluted Statement of the Pythagorean Theorem in Tarski’s \mathscr{E}_{2} 1 Introduction For more than two thousand years, Euclid’s Elements Heath 1956 stood as a standard of logical rigor. In the late nineteenth century, however, its shortcomings were exposed, prompting efforts to rebuild Euclidean geometry on firmer foundations. Two milestones were Hilbert’s Grundlagen der Geometrie (1899) Hilbert 1971 and the axiom system \mathscr{E}_{2} developed by Tarski and his students Tarski 1959 ; Tarski 1999 ; Schwabhauser . Hilbert used natural language, while Tarski introduced a first-order formal system “which can be formulated and established without the help of any set-theoretical devices” ( Tarski 1959 ) (p. 16). Tarski’s \mathscr{E}_{2} is formulated in a 1-sorted language: the only primitive objects are points. There are two primitive predicate symbols—a 3-place predicate symbol B for betweenness, and a 4-place predicate symbol D for segment congruence—with B(\mathbf{pvq}) meaning that \mathbf{v} lies between \mathbf{p} and \mathbf{q} , and D(\mathbf{pquv}) meaning segment \mathbf{pq} (as a pair of end points) is congruent to segment \mathbf{uv} . This system has 11 axioms Tarski 1999 ; Schwabhauser (including one axiom schema), which are listed in Appendix B . Tarski established that \mathscr{E}_{2} is complete and decidable. What part of the content in the Elements is not formalized in \mathscr{E}_{2} ? Notably, \mathscr{E}_{2} contains no notion of area—not even for polygons. In modern mathematics, area is a set function assigning a real number to every measurable set. Even when restricted to polygons, it still requires set-theoretic machinery, which Tarski deliberately avoided in \mathscr{E}_{2} . The area function of polygons could be discussed in second-order logic, or in first-order logic with two sorts—one sort for points and the other for finite sets of points. The latter approach was discussed by Tarski in his 1959 paper Tarski 1959 , with a sketch of a system \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} as a possible extension of \mathscr{E}_{2} : “The theory \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} is obtained by supplement the logical base of \mathscr{E}_{2} with a small fragment of set theory. Specifically, we include in the symbolism of \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} new variables X,Y,\ldots assumed to range over arbitrary finite sets of points (or, what in this case amounts essentially to the same, over arbitrary finite sequences of points); we also include a new logical constant, the membership symbol \in , to denote the membership relation between points and finite point sets. … In consequence the theory of \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} considerably exceeds \mathscr{E}_{2} in means of expression and power. In \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} we can formulate and study various notions which are traditionally discussed in textbooks of elementary geometry but which cannot be expressed in \mathscr{E}_{2} ; e.g., the notions of a polygon with arbitrarily many vertices, and of the circumference and the area of a circle. As regards metamathematical problems which have been discussed and solved for \mathscr{E}_{2} in Theorems 1–4, three of them—the problems of representation, completeness, and finite axiomatizability—are still open when referred to \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} . In particular, we do not know any simple characterization of all models of \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} , nor, do we know whether any two such models are equivalent with respect to all sentences formulated in \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} .” Tarski did, however, resolve the decision problem for \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} in his Theorem 5 Tarski 1959 : Theorem 5. The theory \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} is undecidable, and so are all of its consistent extensions. This follows from the fact that Peano arithmetic (PA) is (relatively) interpretable in \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime} . Note that in the same paper Tarski 1959 , Tarski discussed several axiom systems, which he denoted \mathscr{E}_{2} , \mathscr{E}{}_{2}^{\prime} , \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime\prime} , and \mathscr{E}_{2}^{\prime\prime\prime} , but with his primary focus on \mathscr{E}_{2} . Each of these, in his own words, qualifies as a feasible interpretation of

Read the complete text