Excited Σ \Sigma states of the hydrogen-antihydrogen molecule
L. Brumm, J. Schürmann, A. Saenz · 2025
Read Excited Σ \Sigma states of the hydrogen-antihydrogen molecule by L. Brumm, J. Schürmann, A. Saenz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08308.txt.
Introduction
L Brumm, J Schurmann, and A Saenz compute potential curves for excited states of the hydrogen antihydrogen pair. This exotic system pairs usual hydrogen with its antimatter twin, and its leptonic states can hold spin and shake patterns near breakup energy. Calculations use explicitly correlated basis functions of Kolos Wolniewicz type, covering states of both symmetry classes and including free positronium states.
Several excited states turn out to support ro vibrational levels with energies close to the ground state dissociation threshold. That finding changes how collisions between ground state hydrogen and antihydrogen must be modeled, because these excited leptonic states can no longer be ignored in exact treatments.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | L. Brumm, J. Schürmann, A. Saenz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08308
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Excited Σ \Sigma states of the hydrogen-antihydrogen molecule L. Brumm, J. Schürmann, A. Saenz Abstract Adopting explicitly correlated Kołos-Wolniewicz-type basis functions, the Born-Oppenheimer potential curves of a number of excited Σ \Sigma states of the hydrogen-antihydrogen system ( H H ¯ \mathrm{H}\bar{\mathrm{H}} ) were calculated for both, even and odd, Q symmetries, including also free positronium states. It is demonstrated that the excited leptonic states support ro-vibrational states with energies close to the ground-state dissociation threshold. As a consequence, the excited leptonic states need to be considered in theoretical treatments of ground-state H– H ¯ \bar{\mathrm{H}} collisions. I Introduction Antimatter is not only fascinating by itself, but the evident asymmetry of matter and antimatter in our universe (together with the absence of a corresponding large amount of cosmic background radiation that would be expected from the annihilation of matter and antimatter when generated in equal amounts at the big bang) motivates experiments generating and trapping the simplest neutral compound antimatter atom, antihydrogen ( \bar{\mathrm{H}} ) Baur et al. 1996 ; Blanford et al. 1998 ; Amoretti et al. 2002 ; Gabrielse et al. 2002a ; Gabrielse et al. 2002b . These experiments investigate possible violations of the charge-parity-time (CPT) conservation or the weak-equivalence principle (WEP) by comparing the spectroscopic properties or gravitational behavior of \bar{\mathrm{H}} with the ones of H, see, e. g., Bertsche et al. 2015 ; Ahmadi et al. 2018 ; Baker et al. 2025 ; Anderson et al. 2023 and references therein. With the experimental accessibility of the \bar{\mathrm{H}} atom, there is on the other hand also an increasing interest in its interaction with ordinary matter. In fact, long before the first experimental realization of antihydrogen atoms, the interaction with its matter counterpart, the hydrogen atom, has been studied very carefully theoretically Kołos et al. 1975 . It was found that the Born-Oppenheimer Hamiltonian shows a symmetry closely related to charge-parity symmetry, called Q symmetry, which splits the eigenvalue spectrum into even and odd states. Using explicitly correlated basis functions in prolate spheroidal coordinates, known as Kołos-Wolniewicz basis functions, a very accurate ground-state potential curve was found, proving the local maximum found in Morgan and Hughes 1973 to be an artifact of the limited accuracy of the therein adopted numerical approach. Similar to the corresponding anion (cation) that is obtained, if one positron (electron) is removed from the \mathrm{H}\bar{\mathrm{H}} system, it was found that the \mathrm{H}\bar{\mathrm{H}} molecule is stable only above a critical distance R_{c} (also known as Fermi-Teller radius, as it was first mentioned in Fermi and Teller 1947 for the corresponding one-lepton ion). Below R_{c} the system breaks-up into protonium (p \bar{\mathrm{p}} ) and positronium (e \bar{\mathrm{e}} ), since the energy of p \bar{\mathrm{p}} and e \bar{\mathrm{e}} lies below the one of \mathrm{H}\bar{\mathrm{H}} , at least within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The occurrence of a critical distance is intuitively understandable, as at some point the dipole formed by the proton and the antiproton is insufficient to bind the positronium (in the united-atom limit the positronium is evidently completely unbound). (A more stringent mathematical argument is given in Gridnev and Greiner 2005 .) However, the rather sharp change of the slope of the leptonic energy curve close to the critical distance lead to some speculation. It may be caused by an avoided crossing between the molecular state and the one describing a free protonium-positronium pair, or the molecular state simply changes continuously into an unbound state Saenz 2006 ; Jonsell 2008 . Besides the importance of \mathrm{H}\bar{\mathrm{H}} as a paradigmatic matter-antimatter system, the interest in this system was also raised by a proposal to use ultracold H atoms for the sympathetic cooling of \bar{\mathrm{H}} Shlyapnikov et al. 1993 and the corresponding experimental progress in cooling H atoms, even achieving a Bose-Einstein condensate Fried et al. 1998 . This initiated theoretical investigations regarding the question whether the elastic cross-section responsible for cooling can successfully compete with the destructive inelastic collisions, including the rearrangement into protonium and positronium and, of course, leptonic or hadronic annihilation Voronin and Carbonell 1998 ; Froelich et al. 2000 ; Sinha and Ghosh 2000 ; Jonsell et al. 2001 ; Armour and Chamberlain 2002 ; Froelich et al. 2004 ; Jonsell et al. 2004 ; Zygelman et al. 2004 ; Armour et al. 2005 ; Jonsell et al. 2005 ; Cohen 2006 ; Jonsell 2006 (see Jonsell 2018 for a short review), but also, e. g., a study investigating radiative association Zygelman et al. 2001 . Most of those scattering calculations were based on the Born-Oppenheimer potential curve (possibly including adiabatic corrections) describing the interaction of H and \bar{\mathrm{H}} , each being in their respective ground states. This raised the question how to treat the system for interhadronic separations R<R_{c} . In fact, adopting explicitly correlated Gaussians Strasburger did not only calculate the to the authors’ knowledge still most accurate ground-state potential curve Strasburger 2002 , but later demonstrated a complete break-down of the Born-Oppenheimer, even the adiabatic, approximation, since the correction terms were shown to diverge Strasburger 2004 as the interhadronic distance R approaches the critical value R_{c} (from above). Most problematic is thus the treatment of the rearrangement channel into protonium and positronium with the question of a proper theoretical framework for R<R_{c} . In fact, since the protonium (and in principle also the positronium) can be left in different bound states, various rearrangement channels are accessible. Furthermore, the two particles (protonium and positronium) may have variable translational energy. The results obtained within the plane-wave Sinha and Ghosh 2002 or distorted-wave Jonsell et al. 2004 approximations were thus found to be improved, if the rearrangement channels were explicitly included using the Kohn variational method Armour and Chamberlain 2002 or an optical potential Zygelman et al. 2004 . In yet another approach, a mass-scaled Born-Oppenheimer potential was used to cope with the divergence close to the critical distance within a Born-Oppenheimer framework Stegeby et al. 2012 . In view of the obtained results, in Jonsell 2008 the importance of the explicit inclusion of the rearrangement channels, e. g., in a close-coupling type approach (see Eq. (7) in Jonsell 2008 ) was emphasized. A general formulation of the required T matrix elements including the approximation to include only a single molecular Born-Oppenheimer potential is given in Armour and Jonsell 2007 . In Voronin and Froelich 2008 an approximation was formulated and adopted that requires the channels only in the asymptotic regime, i. e. for R>R_{c} , by invoking unitarity arguments. A natural, but computationally very demanding extension is to directly treat the full four-body problem, as was done in Piszczatowski et al. 2014a ; Piszczatowski et al. 2014b ; Stegeby and Piszczatowski 2016 ; Yamashita and Kino 2018 . Even if a very powerful four-body code, in this case one based on the Gaussian expansion method using different sets of Jacobian coordinates, exists Hiyama et al. 2003 , the calculation is extremely challenging, since the collision channel of hydrogen and antihydrogen involves very highly excited states, even if both atoms start in their ground state. The reason is that within a full four-body treatment, all the above-mentioned protonium and positronium channels are automatically included, starting with their ground states. The protonium ground-state energy