Publish Your Threat Models! The benefits far outweigh the dangers
Loren Kohnfelder,, Adam Shostack, · 2025
Read Publish Your Threat Models! The benefits far outweigh the dangers by Loren Kohnfelder,, Adam Shostack, (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-08295.txt.
Introduction
Loren Kohnfelder and Adam Shostack argue that technology companies should publish their threat models instead of keeping them internal. Threat modeling guides secure software design, and a public version can tell customers and partners what security thinking stands behind a product. Early adopters already provide precedents, and regulators increasingly push in this direction.
Internal models usually need redaction and review before disclosure, and the authors give guidance for that process and for later updates. Publishing, they contend, lets providers show their work, helps customers evaluate claims up and down the supply chain, and could easily become normal practice because many fine models already exist.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Loren Kohnfelder,, Adam Shostack, |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-08295
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Publish Your Threat Models! The benefits far outweigh the dangers Loren Kohnfelder,, Adam Shostack, Abstract Threat modeling has long guided software development work, and we consider how Public Threat Models (PTM) can convey useful security information to others. We list some early adopter precedents, explain the many benefits, address potential objections, and cite regulatory drivers. Internal threat models may not be directly suitable for disclosure so we provide guidance for redaction and review, as well as when to update models (published or not). In a concluding call to action, we encourage the technology community to openly share their PTMs so the security properties of each component are known up and down the supply chain. Technology providers proud of their security efforts can show their work for competitive advantage, and customers can ask for and evaluate PTMs rather than be told “it’s secure” but little more. Many great products already have fine threat models, and turning those into PTMs is a relatively minor task, so we argue this should (and easily could) become the new norm. I Introduction Structured, in-depth threat modeling techniques have been used for over 25 years to guide secure development of technical systems [ 16 ] . Originally conceived as a tool for developers, we now realize they are also a powerful encapsulation of a product’s security properties. Note that we are using the term “published” in its traditional sense, rather than the academic sense. Thus, this Position Paper centers on dissemination of information, not on threat modeling. We anticipate future work could test some subset of these claims, perhaps comparing PTM to “privacy nutrition labels” or disclosures about product security. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first formal exploration of publishing threat models, an extension of Saltzer and Schroeder’s Principle of Open Design. This is a well-explored strategy for source code, and increasingly common with Software Bills of Materials (SBOMs). While focusing on software because it is the center of our own experience — and medical scenarios in particular as especially promising for early adoption — everything herein applies to digital hardware and perhaps an even broader scope of technology products. Seeing great potential value to customers and the larger software community, we urge software makers to consider publishing threat models — if necessary, starting with creating them — we expect that it is the single most effective and accessible action to promote better customer and end-user understanding of security. Throughout this paper we will use the term “customer” to mean the people who are integrating a completed digital product, or possibly evaluating doing so. Publishing a work product already done is a remarkably low-cost, relatively low-effort, and quickly achievable step that delivers an unparalleled return on investment for security communication. If no threat model exists, now is the best time to get started 1 1 1 See the “What is a Threat model?” Section for the justification of this assertion. . We are well aware that some will have immediate strong responses, such as “this is a roadmap for attackers.” We address those concerns in the Frequently Raised Objections Section. PTM precedents do exist: we mention several good examples to illustrate the benefits of publishing, as one of us has, repeatedly, to good effect 2 2 2 Zero-Knowledge Systems released a set of “security analyses” white papers for our products, for example “Freedom 2.1 Security Issues and Analysis.” This 2001 document is not structured as a modern threat model, but explains the security choices we made in ways that meet the criteria presented in this essay [ 3 ] . Similarly, we included a threat model for the Microsoft Threat Modeling Tool (v3) as an example within the tool. . PTM aligns with a pillar of the “Secure by Design” guidance from many cybersecurity regulators: “embracing radical transparency and accountability.” [ 11 ] The recently enacted EU Cyber Resilience Act (CRA) requires many technology products to “include the cybersecurity risk assessment referred to in paragraph 3 of this Article in the technical documentation” (see Article 13(4)) [ 20 ] . Since threat models are an essential part of such a risk assessment, this is tantamount to requiring PTM (effective late 2027). Australia’s Secure by Demand guidance for operational technology (OT) calls for a “full and detailed threat model” as a procurement requirement [ 28 ] . Without access to a threat model, for closed-source products we can only assume all threats are anticipated and fully addressed. Realistically, relying on such an assumption strains credulity, yet independent security assessment is difficult and expensive, PTMs offer a new option which buyers may start to demand. And even with the code in full view, deriving a complete threat model is a major undertaking, if it is even possible. Some choices may not be recorded, and some aspects (e.g. operations procedures and policies) are not in the code. Moreover, guessing about security is a risky game, and misunderstanding about responsibilities at just such boundaries is a common point of vulnerability. We expect products with excellent threat models and significant investments in security work to lead the pack establishing PTMs as a new standard practice. And to the extent this puts pressure on competitors it serves as just the right kind of incentive for a healthy and more secure marketplace. II What is a threat model? A threat model document is the primary engineering record of the security analysis of a software or digital hardware design. It can take many forms, including an analysis document, a security operations guide, or as bug bounty rules (expressing in-scope threats). A PTM may be a lightly edited version of an internal document or a new document created to serve some outsiders. It may or may not be labeled with the words “threat model” . A threat model document for a given product anticipates what could go wrong, how potential threats are addressed, and expresses overall security of the design. It can also show the limits of security aspirations of the designers (e.g., physical access, insider attack by administrators). Designers gain security insights from threat modeling that reveals how well the design handles many potential threats, indicating security vulnerabilities that need shoring up. When the design and its threat model show acceptable threat mitigation across the board, this is good evidence that security goals have been achieved. It is important to note that threat models are important for IT systems [ 26 ] , and multi-system infrastructure as well. In fact, PTMs shine here because they allow integrators to understand the security of the whole from the models of the constituent parts. In our view, designing or deploying digital technology without a threat model is “flying blind” with respect to risk, and only as PTMs become the norm will the fact and prevalence of such an omission become evident. Security vulnerabilities, even very severe and obvious ones, can go undetected for years because no attacker has for whatever reason bothered to look or act yet. Honest people often overlook these because their focus is on using the product as intended, and threat modeling is one of the best ways to surface just these issues. For all these reasons, a history of