Anomaly in canonical semiclassical gravity
Viqar Husain, Irfan Javed · 2025
Read Anomaly in canonical semiclassical gravity by Viqar Husain, Irfan Javed (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07753.txt.
Introduction
Viqar Husain and Irfan Javed report an inconsistency in one approach to quantum gravity. Semiclassical gravity keeps spacetime classical while matter follows quantum rules, replacing matter terms in the Einstein constraints with expectation values from quantum states. In the canonical formulation, those constraints must close into a consistent algebra. Husain and Javed show the algebra does not close, so the formulation contradicts itself. The short result warns that expectation-value sourcing, at least in canonical form, cannot serve as a consistent halfway house between classical geometry and quantum matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Viqar Husain, Irfan Javed |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07753
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Anomaly in canonical semiclassical gravity Viqar Husain, Irfan Javed Abstract We show that the canonical formulation of the semiclassical Einstein equation, where the matter terms in the constraints are replaced by expectation values of the corresponding operators in quantum states, is inconsistent due to the non-closure of the resulting constraint algebra. I Introduction Hybrid systems in which classical and quantum dynamics interact and influence one another are of interest from several perspectives, both in quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. One of the important questions in formulating hybrid models Anderson 1995 ; Oppenheim 2023 ; Terno 2023 ; Diósi 2024 is whether it is possible to maintain the linear evolution of the wave function. The earliest approach is one where this does not hold, and the classical system couples with the expectation value of a quantum operator in an evolving state. This is illustrated by considering a state dependent hybrid Hamiltonian with classical variables X,P and quantum ones \hat{x},\hat{p} : \displaystyle H_{\Psi}=\frac{P^{2}}{2M}+V(X)+\langle\Psi|\frac{\hat{p}^{2}}{2m}+V(\hat{x})+h_{I}(X,\hat{x})|\Psi\rangle, (1) with evolution given by Hamiltonian equations and the time dependent Schrodinger equation, \displaystyle\dot{X} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{X,H_{\Psi}\},\ \ \dot{P}=\{P,H_{\Psi}\}, \displaystyle i\frac{\partial\Psi(x)}{\partial t} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\left(\frac{\hat{p}^{2}}{2m}+V(\hat{x})+h_{I}(X,\hat{x})\right)\Psi(x). (2) This type of hybrid model model includes full “backreaction” of the quantum system on the classical one through the \dot{P} equation, and of the classical system on the quantum system through the interaction term in ( 2 ). The question of whether such an evolution can arise from a fully quantum dynamics of both systems, at least in some regimes, has been the subject of recent studies Husain et al. 2022 ; Husain et al. 2023 . The answer is that this can occur for a limited time only, as entanglement increases in a fully quantum bi-partite system, and initial semiclassical states do not remain so for long. Hybrid models in gauge theories require additional consideration. In non-Abelian gauge theory coupled to fermions, the interaction is of the form g\bar{\Psi}\gamma^{\mu}A_{\mu}\Psi . This leads to a source term in the Gauss law of the canonical theory \displaystyle D_{a}E^{a}=g\bar{\Psi}\Psi, (3) where D_{a}=\partial_{a}+igA_{a} . In a hybrid theory where the gauge field is classical, the source term becomes an expectation value in a quantum state of the Fermi field, with no dependence on the gauge field. This is important because it avoids a gauge anomaly and the corresponding Hamiltonian remains gauge invariant, leading to a self-consistent hybrid theory. These considerations are important in applying the hybrid scheme to gravity, where matter is quantum and gravity remains classical. The central feature of canonical formulations of general relativity is that the evolution of phase space variables is given by a linear combination of the spatial diffeomorphism and Hamiltonian constraints. These constraints satisfy a closed Poisson algebra, and so are themselves preserved under evolution. When matter is present, the phase space is extended to include the corresponding phase space variables, and the constraints are modified with additional terms corresponding to the energy density and flux of the matter field. These are the only changes, and the constraint algebra remains closed. In the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM) canonical formulation Arnowitt et al. 2008 , the phase space variables are the intrinsic 3-metric q_{ab} of a spatial hypersurface embedded in the manifold, and its conjugate momentum \pi^{ab} is a function of the extrinsic curvature of the hypersurface. The canonical action with a scalar field with phase space variables (\phi,p_{\phi}) takes the form \displaystyle S \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int dtd^{3}x\left[\pi^{ab}\dot{q}_{ab}+p_{\phi}\dot{\phi}-N{\cal H}-N^{a}{\cal C}_{a}\right], (4) \displaystyle{\cal H} \displaystyle= \displaystyle H^{\text{G}}+H^{\text{M}}, (5) \displaystyle{\cal C}_{a} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C_{a}^{\text{G}}+C_{a}^{\text{M}}, (6) where N and N^{a} are the lapse and shift functions and the superscripts denote the gravity and matter components of the constraints. The corresponding spacetime metric is \displaystyle ds^{2}=-N^{2}dt^{2}+(dx^{a}+N^{a}dt)(dx^{b}+N^{b}dt)q_{ab}. (7) With the constraint functionals defined by {\cal C}(N)=\int d^{3}x\ N^{a}{\cal C}_{a} and {\cal H}(M)=\int d^{3}x\ M{\cal H} , the Poisson algebra of the constraints is \displaystyle\{{\cal C}(N),{\cal C}(N^{\prime})\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\cal C}([N,N^{\prime}]), \displaystyle\{{\cal C}(N),{\cal H}(M)\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\cal H}({\cal L}_{N}M), \displaystyle\{{\cal H}(M),{\cal H}(M^{\prime})\} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\cal C}(W), (8) where [N,N^{\prime}] is the commutator of vector fields, {\cal L} denotes the Lie derivative, and W^{a}=q^{ab}(M\partial_{b}M^{\prime}-M^{\prime}\partial_{b}M) . The problem of canonical quantum gravity is that of representing this algebra as a commutator algebra on a suitably defined kinematical Hilbert space, solving the Dirac quantization conditions DeWitt 1967 ; Carlip et al. 2015 \displaystyle\hat{{\cal C}}(N)\Psi[q]=0,\quad\hat{{\cal H}}(M)\Psi[q]=0 (9) to find the physical Hilbert space, and then studying the “dynamics” of physical operators. This remains an unsolved problem both in the ADM variables, where it was originally posed, and in its later incarnation in the Ashtekar-Barbero connection-triad variables Thiemann 2001 ; Ashtekar and Lewandowski 2004 ; Bodendorfer 2016 . Given this impasse, one of the directions pursued is to seek suitably modified “effective” constraints that are designed to capture desirable quantum gravity effects, such as fundamental discreteness and curvature singularity avoidance. There are many such proposals, and they accompany questions in addition to the required closure of the constraint algebra, such as the spacetime interpretation of the modified constraints — see, e.g., Bojowald et al. 2016 and references therein. An apparently simpler problem is that of semiclassical gravity Rosenfeld 1963 ; Ford 2005 , where matter is quantum and the gravitational field is classical: the postulated and much studied equation is \displaystyle G_{ab}+\Lambda g_{ab}=8\pi G\bra{\psi}T_{ab}(g,\hat{\phi}\ket{\psi}. (10) The quantum state |\psi\rangle is given in the Heisenberg representation and the equation determines the “semiclassical metric” g given the stress-energy tensor operator. This leads to the immediate issue that \hat{T}_{ab}(g) is also not known since it is a function of the unknown g . (In quantum field theory on curved spacetime, the metric g is fixed and \hat{T}_{ab}(g) can be well defined). There are also questions of interpretation, such as the meaning of the metric for a state that is a linear combination of states that describe matter in disparate spacetime regions Isham 1995 . The equation may also be viewed as a modified theory of gravity with no reference to quantum states, where the right-hand side is a divergence-free rank two tensor made from the metric. II Canonical semiclassical gravity The question we address here is whether it is possible to define a self-consistent canonical version of ( 10 ). The proposal we consider has the following assumptions: (i) The quantum matter state is \displaystyle\Psi[\phi,q]=\int d^{3}x\ \sqrt{q}\ g(x)f(\phi); (11) it is a functional of the spatial metric q_{ab} , the field \phi , and a smearing function g(x) that may be used to localize points; it evolves via the functional Schrodinger equation (see e.g. Long and Shore 1998 ) \displaystyle\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\Psi[\phi]=\left(\hat{H}^{\text{M}}(M)+\hat{C}^{\text{M}}(N)\right)\Psi[\phi], (12) where the t is coordinate time; (ii) The effective constraints (at each space point) are defined by \displaystyle{\cal H}^{\rm eff} \displaystyle= \displaystyle H^{\text{G}}(q,\pi)+\langle\hat{H}^{\text{M}}\rangle(q), (13) \displaystyle{\cal C}_{a}^{\rm eff} \displaystyle= \displaystyle C^{\text{G}}_{a}(q,\pi)+\langle\hat{C}^{\text{M}}_{a}\rangle(q), (14) where the expectation values are in the matter state ( 11 ), and hence depend on the spatial metric; (iii) The evolution of the gravitational variables is given by the constraint functionals {\cal H}^{\rm eff}(M)=\int d^{3}x\ M{\cal H}^{\rm eff} and {\cal C}^{\rm eff}(N)=\int d^{3}x\ N{\cal C}^{\rm eff} : \displaystyle\dot{q}_{ab} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{q_{ab},H^{\text{G}}(M)+C^{\text{G}}(N)\}, (15) \displaystyle\dot{\pi}^{ab} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\{\pi^{ab},{\cal H}^{\rm eff}(M)+{\cal C}^{\rm eff}(N)\}. (16) The first of these equations is exactly the same as that for classical gravity since the expectation values of the matter terms in the effective constraints are functions of